National Coal Board v J E Evans & Co (Cardiff) Ltd [1951] 2 KB 861
The Court of Appeal held that contractors were not liable in trespass for accidentally damaging an underground electricity cable where, on the facts found, the damage was neither intentional nor negligent. It allowed their appeal against an award of £500 to the National Coal Board.
Facts
Glamorgan County Council employed J E Evans & Co to build workshops at the School of Mines in Treforest. The work included a drainage trench. Evans subcontracted the excavation to Maberley Parker Ltd.
An electricity cable belonging to the National Coal Board ran beneath the council’s land across the proposed trench. It had been placed there by the Board or its predecessors without any established right or permission and, so far as the evidence showed, without the council’s knowledge. The cable was absent from the plan supplied to the contractors, and neither contractor knew it was there.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
In September 1948, the subcontractor’s mechanical excavator struck the cable’s concrete cover and damaged the cable. The council’s clerk of works learned what had happened, but the Board was not notified. Water subsequently seeped through the damaged insulation. In May 1949 an explosion interrupted the electricity supply.
The Board sued both companies in negligence and trespass. Donovan J rejected the pleaded allegations of negligence but held the companies liable in trespass: they had deliberately excavated the trench, even though they had not intended to damage the cable. Both companies appealed.
Issues
Did the deliberate act of excavation make the contractors liable for its direct consequences even though they had acted without negligence and did not intend to interfere with the cable? The court also considered the finding of no negligence and an attempted argument about the failure to notify the Board after the damage.
Decision and reasoning
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on 13 June 1951. Cohen, Singleton and Morris LJJ agreed that the Board’s action should have been dismissed.
The contractors were entitled, in these circumstances, to rely on the council’s plan. Although electricity pylons were visible nearby, a straight route between them would not have crossed the trench. The court upheld the finding that the contractors were not negligent in failing to anticipate the cable’s actual route.
The court rejected liability in trespass merely because the excavation itself was deliberate. Drawing on Weaver v Ward, Holmes v Mather and Stanley v Powell, the judges recognised that an accidental interference could be excused where the defendant was entirely without fault. Here the contractors were carrying out lawful work authorised by the landowner, unaware of the unmarked cable.
The cable’s placement without the council’s knowledge or permission was central to the reasoning. The court attributed the accident principally to that situation rather than to any fault in the excavation. Its decision defeated the Board’s claim against the contractors; it was not an award of damages against the Board.
The separate notification point
The suggested negligence in failing to notify the cable’s owners after the accident was not properly pursued in the pleadings and at trial, so the Board could not raise it on appeal. Singleton LJ stressed the importance of reporting damage to a cable but expressed no final view on that proposed liability. The case therefore did not establish a general exemption from responsibility for failing to report accidental damage.
Judgment: National Coal Board v J E Evans & Co (Cardiff) Ltd [1951] 2 KB 861.