Pearce v Brooks (1866) LR 1 Ex 213
Contract, unlawful or immoral purposes, and a supplier’s knowledge of the intended use of goods.
Facts
Coachbuilders supplied an ornamental brougham, a type of horse-drawn carriage, to a woman who worked as a prostitute. They later sued her under the hiring agreement.
The case was tried before Bramwell B and a jury. The jury found both that the defendant had hired the carriage for the purposes of prostitution and that the coachbuilders knew that purpose. The carriage was supplied to help her attract customers through its display. The verdict was for the defendant, and the coachbuilders sought to have it set aside.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issue
Could the coachbuilders enforce the agreement despite supplying the carriage with knowledge of its intended use? In particular, did the defence require proof that they expected payment from the proceeds of prostitution?
Decision
The Court of Exchequer unanimously upheld the verdict for the defendant and discharged the rule challenging it. The coachbuilders could not recover under the bargain. Proof that they expected to be paid from the defendant’s earnings was unnecessary.
Reasoning
Pollock CB applied the principle that a person who contributes to an unlawful act by supplying something knowing that it is to be used for that purpose cannot recover its price. For this purpose, the court treated participation in an immoral purpose in the same way as participation in an illegal one. The decision concerned enforcement of the contract; it did not depend on treating every aspect of the defendant’s occupation as a criminal offence.
The important findings concerned the purpose for which this particular carriage was supplied. Knowledge of the defendant’s occupation alone was not the whole case. Bramwell B had distinguished ordinary goods, such as shoes, which could be needed for everyday purposes, from goods supplied in circumstances indicating that they were required for the particular immoral purpose. The jury’s answers showed that it had appreciated that distinction.
There was no need for the parties expressly to write the intended use into their agreement. The jury could infer the purpose and the coachbuilders’ knowledge from the evidence. Bramwell B accepted that the relevant authorities prevented recovery even though the suppliers’ commercial motivation was to earn a profit.
Martin B explained that the defence remained sufficient without its additional allegation about payment from the proceeds. Pigott B likewise rejected a rule under which silence about the source of payment would allow recovery while an express reference to it would defeat the claim. The known purpose of the supply was decisive.
Sources: Judgments of the Court of Exchequer, 17 April 1866; Bramwell B’s trial direction, reproduced in Anglo Petroleum Ltd v TFB (Mortgages) Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 456, paragraphs 74–76.