Penfold v Westcote (1806) 2 B & P (NR) 335
Slander; imputation of crime; words capable of defamation
Facts
The defendant said the following about the claimant: “Why don’t you come out you blackguard rascal, scoundrel, Penfold, you are a thief”. The trial judge directed the jury that it was for the defendant to prove that by using the word ‘thief’ he did not imply the need to charge the claimant with a felony. The jury found in favour of the claimant.
Issues
The defendant appealed to have the verdict set aside. He argued that the words and expressions surrounding the word ‘thief’ proved that he did not intend to impute felony – he only used the word in the heat of the moment. He further claimed that no evidence was put forward, which would have shown that anyone else understood the word ‘thief’ to imply the need to charge the claimant with a crime.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Decision/Outcome
Unless the jury found that the defendant intended to imply that the claimant was to be charged with theft, it should not have found in favour of the claimant. The jury should consider the manner in which the words used were pronounced and also other circumstances, which could explain the meaning of the word. If the jury found that the word ‘thief’ was merely used as general abuse, they should have dismissed the claimant’s case. All in all, however, if someone calls another a ‘thief’ together with other names of general abuse (that would not normally impute crime), then – in the absence of any evidence to support any other meaning of the word ‘thief’ – the jury can find for the claimant as the word ‘thief’ is actionable in itself as imputing theft.