Poland v John Parr & Sons [1927] 1 KB 236
Court of Appeal, 11 June 1926. Vicarious liability for an employee’s attempt to protect his employer’s property.
Facts
John Parr and his son Henry were cartage contractors. Their employee, Arthur Hall, had helped provide an additional horse for a wagon carrying bags of sugar. He was then walking home for his midday meal, alongside the wagon, which Henry Parr was controlling.
Hall saw a twelve-year-old boy with his hand on a sugar bag. The boy was not stealing, but Hall honestly and reasonably believed that he was. Acting to protect his employers’ interests, Hall struck the boy on the back of the neck with his open hand. The boy fell beneath a wheel and suffered an injury that required his leg to be amputated.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The trial judge dismissed the claim against the employers. Although Hall remained their employee, the judge considered that he was neither carrying out his duties as a carter nor doing anything incidental to them. Acting for the employers’ benefit was not, by itself, enough. The judge nevertheless assessed damages at £500 in case the decision was reversed on appeal.
Issue
Could Hall’s intervention fall within his employment even though he was on his way home for lunch, had no responsibility for the wagon at that moment, and used force against an innocent boy?
Decision and reasoning
The Court of Appeal allowed the boy’s appeal and entered judgment for £500. Hall had implied authority to take reasonable steps to protect his employers’ property in what he reasonably believed was an emergency. The blow was a wrongful way of exercising that authority, but it did not take his conduct outside its scope.
The court distinguished an act outside an employee’s authority from an unauthorised way of performing an act within it. Authority could arise from the circumstances, as well as from the employee’s express duties. Hall’s mistaken belief that the sugar was being stolen therefore mattered: it was both honest and reasonable, and he intervened to prevent the apparent theft.
Scrutton LJ explained that being outside normal working hours or performing a different kind of task did not necessarily exclude liability. The question was whether the conduct belonged to a class of acts the employee was authorised to perform. Excessive force could take an act outside that class, but this was a question of degree. The force Hall used was not sufficient to do so.
Atkin LJ also distinguished authority from duty. An employee could be authorised to respond to an emergency without being obliged to face its dangers. The employer’s liability consequently did not depend on proving that Hall had a positive duty to intervene.
Significance of the decision
The case illustrates implied authority to protect an employer’s property in an emergency. It does not make an employer liable for every act intended to benefit the business, or for any level of force an employee chooses to use. The reasonable perception of danger, the nature of the intervention and the extent of any excess were central to the decision.
Case report: Poland v John Parr and Sons (ICLR); case report (vLex).