Promissory estoppel concerns the effect of an assurance that strict legal rights will not be enforced. These cases examine when a party’s promise or conduct prevents enforcement, what reliance matters, and whether the original rights can later be resumed. They distinguish an equitable restriction on existing rights from a new contractual claim requiring consideration.
Hughes v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App Cas 439
A landlord served notice requiring repairs within six months. During that period, the parties began negotiating for the landlord to purchase the tenant railway company’s leasehold interest. The company proposed deferring the repairs while the possibility of an agreement was explored, and the landlord entered negotiations on that footing.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The negotiations did not produce an agreement. The landlord then sought to enforce forfeiture by measuring the repair period from the original notice. The House of Lords dismissed his appeal: the dealings had suspended the operation of the notice, and the repairs were completed within the six months allowed after the negotiations ended.
Lord Cairns explained that strict contractual rights could not be enforced where that would be inequitable in light of the parties’ dealings. The Lords did not find that the landlord had deliberately deceived the tenant. Relief followed from the effect of his conduct, rather than an intention to set a trap.
Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130
The landlord agreed to reduce the annual ground rent of a block of flats from £2,500 to £1,250 while wartime conditions left the flats substantially unoccupied. By early 1945 the flats were fully let, but the tenant continued paying the reduced amount.
Denning J held that the concession applied only while the circumstances giving rise to it continued. The landlord therefore recovered rent at the full rate for the quarters ending September and December 1945.
The judgment explained that a promise intended to affect legal relations, intended to be acted upon and actually acted upon could bind the promisor within its proper scope despite the absence of fresh consideration. The discussion of protection against a claim for the reduced wartime rent went beyond the claim being decided. The actual judgment was for the landlord for the later rent, not a dismissal of a claim for wartime arrears.
Combe v Combe [1951] 2 KB 215
During divorce proceedings, a husband promised to pay his wife £100 a year free of tax. He did not pay, and she later sued for the arrears. The trial judge found no consideration but enforced the promise by applying the principle in High Trees.
The Court of Appeal allowed the husband’s appeal. Denning LJ explained that the principle did not create a new cause of action where none previously existed. It could qualify existing legal relations but could not supply consideration where consideration was necessary to establish the claim.
The wife’s actual forbearance from applying for maintenance did not provide consideration because the husband had not requested it, expressly or impliedly. The description of estoppel as a shield rather than a sword concerns its legal function; it does not mean that its assistance is necessarily confined to the defendant in proceedings.
Tool Metal Manufacturing Co Ltd v Tungsten Electric Co Ltd [1955] 1 WLR 761
A patent-licensing arrangement required Tungsten to pay royalties and additional compensation on material sold or used above a quota. Tool Metal temporarily ceased demanding the compensation. Earlier proceedings had established that an equitable suspension operated and required an intimation before compensation could again be demanded.
The House of Lords held that Tool Metal’s counterclaim in those earlier proceedings sufficiently communicated its intention to resume enforcement. Nine months had passed between that counterclaim and the date from which compensation was sought in the later action. That was sufficient time for adjustment.
No universal rule required a notice in a particular form or specifying a future termination date. What equity required depended on the circumstances. The appeal was allowed and the trial judgment restored. Viscount Simonds agreed on the notice issue but dissented on a separate patent-law question.
D & C Builders Ltd v Rees [1966] 2 QB 617
Builders who were owed £482 13s 1d accepted a cheque for £300 after the customer’s wife, knowing their financial difficulties, insisted that they take it in settlement or receive nothing. They subsequently claimed the balance.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the customer’s appeal on the preliminary settlement issue. His own cheque for the smaller sum did not supply fresh consideration for discharging the larger debt. Denning MR also held that the pressure applied prevented a true accord and left no equitable basis for preventing recovery.
The decision therefore illustrates a limit on reliance on an agreed reduction: the circumstances must make enforcement inequitable. It did not hold that this creditor had permanently surrendered the balance.
W J Alan & Co Ltd v El Nasr Export and Import Co [1972] 2 QB 189
Coffee sellers accepted and used a sterling letter of credit although their contracts initially specified Kenyan currency. After sterling was devalued, they sought an additional payment to make up the difference. The Court of Appeal allowed the buyers’ appeal: the sellers’ acceptance of the credit involved variation or waiver, and the buyers owed no additional sum.
Denning MR considered that acting on the belief induced by the other party was sufficient without separate detriment. Stephenson LJ left that wider question open, finding detriment on the facts. The judgment also distinguished a temporary concession from an accepted payment arrangement which could not later be revoked unilaterally.