BLACK FRIDAY
20%OFFSITEWIDE

Any product. As many orders as you like.

USE CODEBLACKFRIDAY2026
Order now

Ends 28 November · 23:59 UK time

Cannot be used with another coupon.

Disclaimer: This work was produced by one of our expert legal writers, as a learning aid to help law students with their studies.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of LawTeacher.net. Any information contained in this case summary does not constitute legal advice and should be treated as educational content only.

R v Stewart [2009] EWCA Crim 593

1,287 words (6 pages) Case Summary

07 Mar 2018 Case Summary Reference this LawTeacher

Jurisdiction / Tag(s): Criminal law UK Law

R v Stewart [2009] EWCA Crim 593; [2009] 1 WLR 2507; [2009] 2 Cr App R 30

Introduction to the topic

Diminished responsibility is a partial defence to murder, having the effect of reducing the charge to voluntary manslaughter,1 which carries a discretionary, as opposed to mandatory,2 life sentence. Stewart was decided under the earlier wording of section 2 of the Homicide Act 1957. The defence advanced required an abnormality of mind induced by disease or illness which substantially impaired his mental responsibility for the killing.

Later statutory framework (from 4 October 2010)

The Coroners and Justice Act 2009 later amended section 2.33 In outline, the amended section provides that a person suffering from an ‘abnormality of mental functioning’3 which arises from a ‘recognised medical condition’4 and substantially impairs5 the defendant’s ability to either understand the nature of his conduct, form a rational judgment or exercise self-control,6 and whose abnormality provides an explanation for the defendant’s conduct in killing the victim,7 is not to be convicted of murder but, instead, manslaughter.8

Law Teacher writing support

Writing a law essay?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.

Voluntary intoxication

Voluntary intoxication is not a defence in itself, but may bear on whether the prosecution has proved the intent required for murder.9 A voluntarily intoxicated defendant has no defence to crimes of basic intent such as assault occasioning actual bodily harm contrary to s.47 Offences Against the Person Act 1861.10

Issue raised by the case

The case raised the issue of the relationship between voluntary intoxication and diminished responsibility, and whether R v Tandy (1989)11 still remained good law. That case considered that if the first drink of the day was voluntary, then the defendant’s intoxication could not be said to be involuntary. Under that restrictive approach, drinking short of brain damage had to be wholly involuntary to support the defence; Stewart reconsidered that position in light of Wood.

It also concerned whether or not alcohol dependency syndrome is sufficient alone to satisfy the defence.

Facts

The defendant killed the victim during a drunken fight whilst heavily intoxicated. He suffered from alcohol dependency syndrome, a recognised medical condition.12

Decision

The decision in R v Tandy (1989) was considered to be too strict in light of the decision in R v Wood (2008).13 The contention that the defence would fail if any of the defendant’s drinking was voluntary was incorrect.14 Alcohol dependency syndrome did not require complete involuntariness: ‘one of the criteria for ICD10 purposes includes the “difficulty”, not, we emphasise, the impossibility of controlling the use of alcohol’15

At paragraph 26 Lord Judge CJ noted that the recognition of alcohol dependency syndrome as a disease needed to be reconciled with the general bar on the use of voluntary intoxication as a defence unless it bears on the question of the defendant’s intent.16

The key paragraph of the judgment is paragraph 29:

The consumption of vast amounts of alcohol may therefore reduce murder to manslaughter, first, when the effect of the intoxication is so extreme that the prosecution has failed to prove the necessary intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm (R v Sheehan and Moore)17 and second, assuming that the necessary intent is proved notwithstanding the consumption of alcohol, on the basis of diminished responsibility, provided the Defendant proves that he was suffering from such abnormality of mind induced by the disease or illness of alcohol dependency syndrome that his mental responsibility for his actions in doing the killing was substantially impaired.18

Therefore, the existence of alcohol dependency syndrome, without more, is insufficient to found the defence of diminished responsibility; the requirements of abnormality of mind and substantial impairment under the then wording of section 2 also had to be satisfied. ‘Not every alcoholic is suffering from such abnormality of mind that his mental responsibility for his actions at the time of the killing is or must be treated as if it were substantially impaired.’19

The Court of Appeal allowed Stewart’s appeal against his murder conviction because the directions effectively excluded diminished responsibility if any of his drinking was voluntary. A retrial was ordered; the court did not substitute a manslaughter conviction. It rejected the separate challenge to the judge’s summary of the expert evidence.

The jury was to assess the nature and severity of the dependency and the defendant’s control over his drinking in the circumstances. It was not required to classify every individual drink as voluntary or involuntary. Relevant matters included periods of abstinence, the pattern and reasons for drinking, and the ability to make sensible decisions.

Analysis

R v Stewart (2009)20 acts as a clarification on the law following R v Wood (2008),21 clearing up any uncertainty regarding when chronic alcoholism constitutes an ‘abnormality of mind’ and when it ‘substantially impairs’ the defendant’s responsibility.

Ashworth notes that Lord Judge CJ ‘re-examined’ his judgment in R v Wood (2008),22 which was previously interpreted as meaning that the jury need to separate out D’s voluntary and involuntary drinking – something it was criticised for. Lord Judge CJ sets out six considerations for the jury dealing with the ‘extent of D’s alcohol dependency’ and ‘D’s pattern of drinking on the day and preceding days.’ Ashworth considers that this is, in fact, no different to the test in R v Wood,23 which is ‘afflicted with the same problem of determining whether D’s apparent choices of when and what to drink were real choices, or actions stemming chiefly from his alcohol dependency.’24

The reasoning in R v Wood (2008)25 stems from the decisions of R v Dietschmann (2003)26 and R v Gittens (1984)27 which considered that when there has been a combination of a mental abnormality and voluntary intoxication not amounting to alcohol dependency syndrome, the correct approach is to consider whether the mental abnormality was sufficient, alone, to substantially impair D’s responsibility, irrespective of the intoxication (which would not normally fall within s.2(1)). These decisions, therefore, required the separation of two contributing factors. One can easily see the logic in extending this reasoning to separate out mental abnormality caused by alcohol dependency syndrome and voluntary intoxication, as in R v Wood (2008).28

Later developments

Following the amendments introduced in the Coroners and Justice Act 2009, the question arose whether it might be open to the jury to find that an irresistible craving for alcohol amounts to an ‘abnormality of mental functioning arising from a recognised medical condition’, since ‘acute intoxication’29 is listed as a condition in the ICD-10. 30 R v Dowds (2012)31 made it clear that the amendments were not intended to reverse the rule in R v Wood (2008) and R v Stewart (2009) that ‘voluntary acute intoxication, uncomplicated by alcoholism or dependence, is not capable of being relied upon’ alone.32

Footnotes

1S.2(3) Homicide Act 1957.

2S.1(1) Murder (Abolition of the Death Penalty) Act 1965.

3S.2(1) Homicide Act 1957.

4Ibid, s.2(1)(a).

5Ibid, s.2(1)(b).

6Ibid, s.2(1A).

7Ibid, s.2(1)(c).

8Ibid, s.2(2)-(3).

9R v Sheehan and Moore [1975] 1 WLR 739 (CA).

10R v Majewski [1977] A.C. 443.

11[1989] 1 All ER 267.

12Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders IV (DSM-IV) (2000) and now Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders V (DSM-V) (2013), International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (10th edn) (ICD-10) (2012).

13[2008] EWCA Crim 1305.

14R v Stewart [2009] 1 WLR 2507, at [24] (Lord Judge CJ).

15Ibid, at [27] (Lord Judge CJ).

16R v Sheehan and Moore [1975] 1 WLR 739 (CA).

17Ibid.

18R v Stewart [2009] 1 WLR 2507, at [29] (Lord Judge CJ).

19Ibid, at [27] (Lord Judge CJ).

20Ibid.

21[2008] EWCA Crim 1305.

22Ibid.

23[2008] EWCA Crim 1305.

24Andrew Ashworth, ‘R. v Stewart: manslaughter – diminished responsibility – alcohol dependency’ Crim. L.R. 2009, 11, 807-809.

25[2008] EWCA Crim 1305.

26[2003] 1 AC 1209 (HL).

27[1984] Q.B. 698.

28[2008] EWCA Crim 1305.

29R v Dowds [2012] EWCA Crim 281.

30International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (10th edn) (ICD-10) (2012), the official classification of health problems used by the National Health Service.

31[2012] EWCA Crim 281.

32James Richardson (ed), Archbold: Criminal Pleading, Evidence and Practice (63rd edn, Sweet and Maxwell 2015), 18-89.

33Coroners and Justice Act 2009, section 52, in force from 4 October 2010.

Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

LawTeacher

LawTeacher

LawTeacher.net is the UK’s leading provider of academic legal support, offering both writing services and an extensive collection of law study resources for students in the UK and overseas.

Founded in 2003 by Grey’s Inn graduate Barclay Littlewood, the Company was built on a commitment to excellence, with unique guarantees and a high standard of service from day one.

The team includes over 500 UK legally qualified writing experts, with many practising solicitors and barristers, and several former lecturers.

Areas of Legal Expertise

Contract Law Criminal Law Constitutional and Administrative Law EU Law Tort Law Property Law Equity and Trusts Jurisprudence Company Law Commercial Law Family Law Human Rights Law Employment Law Evidence Public International Law Legal Research and Methods Dispute Resolution Business Law and Practice Civil Litigation Criminal Litigation Professional Conduct Taxation Wills and Administration of Estates Solicitors’ Accounts

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Related Services

View all

Related Content

Jurisdictions / Tags

Content relating to: “Criminal law”

Related Articles

Prices from

£ 99

Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery

Place an order

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report