R v Williams; R v Davis [1992] 1 WLR 380
Directions on evidence and causation in manslaughter by an unlawful act (joint enterprise)
Facts
The victim was a hitchhiker picked up by Mr Williams; Mr Davis and Mr Bobat were passengers in the car. After a few miles, the victim jumped out of the moving car and suffered fatal injuries. Mr Williams and Mr Davis were convicted of manslaughter and robbery after the jury accepted that they robbed the victim (as pre-planned) and threatened him with physical violence as a result of which he jumped out of the car; Mr Bobat was acquitted. Messrs Williams and Davis appealed.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The judge directed the jury that statements to the police could only be used against the maker of the statement, but Mr Williams argued that the evidence was too tenuous to go before the jury, and that his conviction was inconsistent with Mr Bobat’s acquittal. Mr Davis claimed that the judge should have accepted a submission of no case to answer; that his conviction was based on Mr Bobat’s statement to the police and that evidence of the mere presence of a knife and stick in the car should not have been admitted.
Decision/Outcome
The appeals were allowed and the convictions quashed. In Williams’s case, the evidence relied on to infer a joint enterprise to rob applied equally to Bobat, who had been acquitted. The court concluded that the jury must have used Davis’s incriminating statement against Williams despite the judge’s warning. Williams’s robbery conviction was unsafe; the manslaughter conviction, which depended on that robbery as the unlawful act, also failed.
Davis’s appeal raised the separate need for adequate directions on causation. The jury had to consider both whether the threat was one from which sober and reasonable people would foresee some physical harm, and whether the deceased’s attempt to escape was within the range of responses that might be expected in his situation. The victim’s characteristics and the possibility of an impulsive reaction in the agony of the moment had to be taken into account.
There was an almost total lack of evidence about the nature of the threat. Its gravity could not simply be inferred from the fact that the deceased jumped from the car. The court therefore rejected that reasoning and found the directions inadequate.
Further citations: [1992] 2 All ER 183; (1992) 95 Cr App R 1; [1992] Crim LR 198.
Law report: Court of Appeal, 18 October 1991, [1992] 1 WLR 380.