Re Ecclesiastical Commissioners for England’s Conveyance [1936] Ch 430
Restrictive covenants, neighbouring land and enforcement by people who were not parties to the conveyance.
Facts
A conveyance dated 21 April 1887 contained restrictive covenants made with the Ecclesiastical Commissioners and their successors. It also expressed a separate covenant with their assigns who owned land adjoining or adjacent to the conveyed land.
The dispute concerned the benefit of those covenants. Owners of neighbouring land claimed entitlement to enforce them even though they had not been parties to the 1887 conveyance. The relevant owners included people whose land had been conveyed away before that transaction.
Issue
Did the wording identify those owners as people with whom the covenants were made, despite their absence as formal parties to the deed? The court also had to determine what land the expressions “adjoining” and “adjacent” described.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Decision and reasoning
Luxmoore J held that the owners of the land intended to benefit could enforce the covenants notwithstanding that they were not parties to the conveyance. Their right depended on the construction of the instrument: it expressly provided a separate covenant with an identifiable class of owners.
The judge approached the deed in its circumstances at the time of execution. The question was whether people outside its formal parties were nevertheless described as covenantees, and which land the covenants were intended to affect. The decision therefore did not give every nearby owner an automatic right to enforce a restriction.
The distinction between “adjoining” and “adjacent” mattered in identifying the benefited land. In its primary sense, adjoining land touched the land in question. Adjacent land, used in contrast, could lie near it without actually touching it. How close it needed to be depended on the circumstances; “adjacent” did not have a single fixed distance applicable to every conveyance.
The case illustrates why identifying the land and people meant to benefit is a separate task from identifying the land burdened by a covenant. Here, the express wording of the separate covenant allowed the relevant owners to enforce it.
References: [1936] Ch 430, especially 438–441; judicial quotations in Xu v Natarelli [2018] VSC 759 and Re 713 Yardley Wood Road [2013] UKUT 355 (LC), paragraph 100.