Legal Case Summary
Spartan Steel and Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1972] EWCA Civ 3; [1973] QB 27; [1972] 3 WLR 502; [1972] 3 All ER 557
NEGLIGENT DAMAGE TO PROPERTY – QUANTUM OF DAMAGES
Facts
The defendants were responsible for digging up a road about a quarter of a mile from the plaintiff’s smelting factory. As a result of their negligence when carrying out this task, they inadvertently severed a power supply under the road resulting in a loss of power to the plaintiff’s factory. The plaintiffs suffered a number of forms of damage as a result of this, including loss of profits as a consequence of the factory being non-operational for the period while it was without power, and physical damage to the metal which was in the process of being smelted at the time the power was lost.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The question was whether the plaintiff could recover damages for the loss of profits or whether this was irrecoverable in negligence as it was a ‘pure economic loss’.
Decision / Outcome
By a majority of two to one, the Court of Appeal held that the profits lost through the interruption of further production were irrecoverable, despite the admitted negligence and the foreseeability of that loss. Lord Denning MR relied on policy considerations, including the risk of widespread claims from interruptions to electricity supplies; Lawton LJ applied the established rule against recovery of such loss. However, economic losses consequential on the damage to the metal in the melt (such as lost profits on the damaged metal) were recoverable. The result was therefore that the damage to the metal which was damaged due to the smelting process being cut short was recoverable (as were the lost profits from the sale of this metal), but the loss of profits from further melts which could have been completed during the time the factory was without power could not be recovered as this was ‘pure’ economic loss.
The appeal was allowed and damages reduced to £768: £368 for damage to the metal and £400 for the consequential lost profit on that melt. The £1,767 profit on four further melts was disallowed.
Edmund Davies LJ dissented. Given the admitted duty and the direct, foreseeable loss, he would have allowed recovery of all the claimed profits.