Tenax Steamship Co v Owners of the Motor Vessel Brimnes [1974] EWCA Civ 15
Contract – Charterparty – Withdrawal – Notice – Instantaneous Communication
Facts
The ship called Brimnes originally belonged to the claimant charterers, Tenax Steamship Co. They agreed to sell her to the defendant shipowners on the condition that she would be time-chartered back to them. On several occasions, the hire payment was made later than agreed. Clause 5 allowed the owners to withdraw the vessel if hire was not paid punctually and regularly. After the payment due on 1 April 1970 was late, the owners sent a Telex message withdrawing the ship from service. It arrived at the charterers’ office during normal business hours on 2 April, but their staff did not read it until the next day. A bank transfer of the overdue hire was also being processed on 2 April, making the order of payment and notice important.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
The claim was dismissed by the court, but this decision was appealed. The issue in the appeal concerned whether the notice of withdrawal of service was effective before the charterers’ payment of hire. The appeal also concerned the effect of late payment and alleged waiver of the owners’ right to withdraw.
Decision/Outcome
It was held that the withdrawal was effective when the Telex message was received, not when the message was read. It arrived during ordinary business hours when, on the charterers’ own case, the staff member responsible for Telex messages was still in the office. They could not rely on her failure to notice it to postpone its effect. The decision concerned notice terminating an existing charter, rather than withdrawal of an offer. The relevant principle was that a notice arriving by a means and at a time when it would normally come to the recipient’s attention could not be delayed by the recipient’s failure to deal with it in a normal businesslike way.
The bank’s receipt of instructions to transfer money was not itself payment. The transfer had to reach the stage at which the instructions had been accepted and the funds made available as required. On the balance of probabilities, effective notice preceded payment. The Court of Appeal therefore dismissed the charterers’ appeal. It also rejected the owners’ cross-notice arguing that the repeated late payments amounted to repudiation independently of the express withdrawal clause.
Full judgment. Parallel citations: [1975] QB 929; [1974] 3 WLR 613; [1974] 3 All ER 88.