Disclaimer: This work was produced by one of our expert legal writers, as a learning aid to help law students with their studies.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of LawTeacher.net. Any information contained in this case summary does not constitute legal advice and should be treated as educational content only.

R (Whiston) v Secretary of State for Justice [2014] UKSC 39

615 words (3 pages) Case Summary

07 Mar 2018 Case Summary Reference this LawTeacher

Jurisdiction / Tag(s): Human rights law Public law UK Law

R (Whiston) v Secretary of State for Justice [2014] UKSC 39

The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed a prisoner’s challenge to his recall from home detention curfew. Article 5(4) of the European Convention on Human Rights did not require a further judicial review of his detention in these circumstances. Lady Hale agreed with the outcome but questioned the majority’s wider reasoning about recall after mandatory release.

Facts and statutory framework

On 5 October 2010, Stuart Whiston received an 18-month prison sentence for robbery. He was entitled to automatic release on licence halfway through that sentence, on 5 July 2011. Before reaching that date, he was released on home detention curfew on 21 February 2011 under section 246 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003.

Law Teacher writing support

Writing a law essay?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.

The Secretary of State revoked his licence on 7 April 2011 under section 255 because his whereabouts could no longer be electronically monitored. That recall power applied while the curfew condition remained in force, before the halfway point. It could be exercised even without a breach of licence conditions.

A prisoner recalled under section 255 had to receive reasons and an opportunity to make representations to the Secretary of State, who could cancel the revocation. Unlike recall under the general section 254 procedure, this route provided no review by the Parole Board. Whiston appealed after the Court of Appeal rejected his challenge.

The legal question

Article 5(4) requires access to a court which can decide the lawfulness of detention speedily and order release where detention is unlawful. Whiston argued that release had restored his liberty, so recall required fresh judicial scrutiny. The Secretary of State argued that the original sentence already supplied the judicial decision required by the Convention.

The majority’s reasoning

Lord Neuberger gave the main judgment, with Lord Kerr, Lord Carnwath and Lord Hughes agreeing. Under the Strasbourg authorities, the judicial supervision required by article 5(4) is normally incorporated into a lawful determinate sentence imposed by a competent court. Throughout that fixed sentence, the original court has already determined the lawfulness of the loss of liberty. Discretionary early release does not ordinarily create a fresh entitlement under article 5(4) when the prisoner is recalled.

This differs from indeterminate detention where continued imprisonment can depend on changing assessments of risk and require periodic judicial scrutiny. The majority considered the Strasbourg decisions in Ganusauskas and Brown, together with the House of Lords’ reasoning in Giles, to support dismissal of Whiston’s appeal.

Lord Neuberger also addressed the apparent conflict with R (Smith and West) v Parole Board. He held that West was decided per incuriam—without proper consideration of the relevant authorities—so far as it held or assumed that article 5(4) applied. This did not undermine its actual result, which rested primarily on common-law procedural fairness. He rejected Lord Brown’s contrary observation in Black and considered the common law capable of protecting prisoners in Whiston’s position.

Lady Hale’s separate opinion

Lady Hale distinguished recall before and after the date when release on licence becomes mandatory. Whiston had not yet reached that date. His release was discretionary, and his original sentence continued to justify his imprisonment.

She considered recall after mandatory release different: Parliament had given the prisoner a right to release, and subsequent detention could depend on risk rather than the original sentencing decision. She therefore defended the approach in West and would confine this decision to Whiston’s circumstances. In her view, the majority’s wider observations were obiter, meaning unnecessary to decide this appeal.

Outcome

The appeal was dismissed. The absence of Parole Board review of Whiston’s section 255 recall did not infringe article 5(4). All five justices agreed on that result; they differed over how far the reasoning should extend beyond discretionary release on home detention curfew.

Read the full Supreme Court judgment (2 July 2014).

LawTeacher

LawTeacher

LawTeacher.net is the UK’s leading provider of academic legal support, offering both writing services and an extensive collection of law study resources for students in the UK and overseas.

Founded in 2003 by Grey’s Inn graduate Barclay Littlewood, the Company was built on a commitment to excellence, with unique guarantees and a high standard of service from day one.

The team includes over 500 UK legally qualified writing experts, with many practising solicitors and barristers, and several former lecturers.

Areas of Legal Expertise

Contract Law Criminal Law Constitutional and Administrative Law EU Law Tort Law Property Law Equity and Trusts Jurisprudence Company Law Commercial Law Family Law Human Rights Law Employment Law Evidence Public International Law Legal Research and Methods Dispute Resolution Business Law and Practice Civil Litigation Criminal Litigation Professional Conduct Taxation Wills and Administration of Estates Solicitors’ Accounts

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Related Services

View all

Related Content

Jurisdictions / Tags

Content relating to: “Human rights law”

Related Articles

Prices from

£ 99

Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery

Place an order

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report