White v Blackmore [1972] EWCA Civ 11
Court of Appeal, 15 June 1972 — occupiers’ liability, exclusion notices and voluntary acceptance of risk.
Facts
Graham White attended a jalopy-racing meeting at Quedgeley, Gloucestershire, on 10 September 1967. He registered as a competitor in the morning, left his racing car at the field and returned that afternoon with his family. He paid for his wife and mother-in-law to enter but was admitted without charge because he was competing.
Notices at the entrance and around the field warned that motor racing was dangerous. They also stated that those involved in organising the meeting were absolved from liability for accidents causing personal injury or damage, “howsoever caused”, to spectators or ticket holders.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
After taking part in a race, White went to speak to his family while watching another race. He stood on the track side of the spectators’ rope, near a post to which the spectators’ rope, pit-boundary rope and safety ropes were attached.
A racing car became entangled in a safety rope some distance away. Its wheel pulled the connected ropes and posts out of position, catapulting White into the air. He suffered severe injuries and died on 4 October 1967. His widow sued the organisers.
Proceedings and issues
The trial judge found that the organisers had negligently arranged the ropes. Attaching them to a common post meant that a pull on one part of the system could endanger people elsewhere. The judge also attributed one-third of the responsibility to White because of where he stood.
Nevertheless, the judge dismissed the claim, relying on voluntary acceptance of risk, or volenti non fit injuria. On appeal, the principal questions were whether White had accepted the particular risk and whether the notices independently excluded the organisers’ liability under section 2(1) of the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957.
Decision
The appeal was dismissed by a majority of two to one. Buckley and Roskill LJJ held that the notices excluded liability. Lord Denning MR dissented and would have allowed the appeal. The majority did not uphold the trial judge’s reliance on volenti.
The distinction between accepting a risk and excluding liability
White’s willingness to participate in a dangerous sport did not show that he knowingly accepted the risk created by the negligent safety arrangements. He did not know the nature and extent of that danger. The court therefore rejected the argument that voluntary acceptance of the sport’s risks answered this claim.
The majority treated the exclusion notice as a separate question. Section 2(1) preserved an occupier’s ability, where otherwise legally free to do so, to restrict or exclude the common duty of care by agreement or otherwise. A notice imposing a condition of entry was different from a warning whose purpose was simply to help visitors avoid a danger.
Why the majority held the notices effective
Buckley and Roskill LJJ did not regard White’s registration in the morning as creating a binding contract which fixed the terms of his later admission. They treated his permission to enter as a gratuitous licence capable of being varied when he returned in the afternoon.
The entrance notice was prominently displayed. The trial judge had found that White saw it and appreciated its character, and that notices of this kind were familiar at jalopy meetings. The majority held that reasonable steps had been taken to bring the condition to his attention and that he entered on those terms.
Although White was a competitor during his own races, he was a spectator when watching another race with his family. He therefore fell within the description used in the notice. The words “howsoever caused” were wide enough to include accidents resulting from the organisers’ negligence. The majority could decide the appeal on the displayed notices without determining the alternative argument based on the wording inside the programme.
Lord Denning’s dissent
Lord Denning considered that White had provided consideration through his participation as a competitor and that the programme was the contractual admission document. In his view, the exclusion conditions had not been adequately incorporated into that contract.
He also relied on the distinction between reasonable safety precautions and a general warning that racing was dangerous. He considered that the notices should not permit the organisers to avoid responsibility for their own failure to make the premises reasonably safe. That view did not command the majority.
Legal principle
As decided in 1972, the case distinguished a visitor’s informed acceptance of a particular risk from an effective exclusion of liability. The former failed on these facts, while the majority held that the conditions governing White’s admission excluded the organisers’ liability.
Judgment: White v Blackmore [1972] EWCA Civ 11; also reported at [1972] 2 QB 651, [1972] 3 WLR 296 and [1972] 3 All ER 158.