Legal Case Summary
Williams v Hensman [1861] EWHC Ch J51; (1861) 1 J & H 546; 70 ER 862
Co-Ownership – Severance – Modes of Severance of Joint Tenancy
Facts
Sara Creak’s will and codicil provided a £4,000 fund to support an annuity of £200 for Mrs Hensman during her life, with the principal to go to Mrs Hensman’s eight children on her death. Mrs Hensman and the children authorised an investment outside the terms of the will; three of the children were then minors. Later, William Hensman received a £450 advance secured against his one-eighth interest. The other beneficiaries joined in a deed protecting the trustee against loss and expenses arising from the advance.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
What form of co-ownership in equity did the children have over the fund? Whether or not the beneficiaries were joint tenants of the fund. Whether or not a joint tenancy could be severed by the actions of the tenants. Whether or not this had been severed by their actions.
Decision / Outcome
The will created a joint tenancy between the beneficiaries. This had been severed by the actions of the beneficiaries. There were three ways by which a joint tenancy may be severed. Firstly, an act of one of the persons, operating on their own share. Secondly, by mutual agreement, and thirdly, where there is a course of dealing that is sufficient to show that the interests of all the parties were mutually being treated as a tenancy in common. In this case, the court held that all the shares had been severed. Some beneficiaries had separately dealt with their own shares, including by assignment or mortgage. For the remaining shares, the indemnity deed showed a course of dealing inconsistent with continued joint ownership. The beneficiaries had undertaken liabilities that could bind their estates after death; the court inferred an agreement that their interests were held separately, excluding survivorship. Their lack of awareness that the will had created a joint tenancy did not prevent severance by their dealings.