Last updated: 10 November 2026
INTRODUCTION
“Heart-breaking delays and ruinous costs were the lot of suitors. Justice was dilatory, expensive, uncertain, and remote. To the rich it was a costly lottery: to the poor a denial of right or certain ruin. The class who profited most by its dark mysteries were the lawyers themselves.”
Although this could be a fair comment on the legal system in the 1990s, these words were written by Sir Thomas Erskine May in 1861 (Constitutional History of England).
The social reformer Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) argued for constant radical legislation to achieve the greatest happiness of the greatest number. From this time efforts were made to demystify law and to see it as a set of practical rules. From the Reform Act 1832 onwards, a series of reform measures were passed. The Judicature Acts 1873-75 were followed by a series of Acts codifying substantive branches of law, like the Sale of Goods Act 1893 and the Partnership Act 1890. This continued with a series of reform Acts on land, eg, the law of property legislation of 1925. These various measures, however, were ad hoc responses to particular problems. There was no overall plan or consistency of effort and this was to remain the situation until the 1960s.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The need for continual reform arises for a number of reasons. Statutes may remain in force until repealed, although some contain expiry provisions, and some statutes get overlooked, like the Scottish Innkeepers Act 1424, which was eventually repealed in 1989. The vast amount of law and the increasing rate at which it is being made has become overwhelming. In a rapidly changing society new laws have to be made to meet new needs, eg, section 84 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 extended the law on indecent photographs of children to cover pseudo-photographs, including computer-generated images which appear to be photographs. Responsibility for the law is somewhat diverse: the Ministry of Justice is responsible for courts, prisons and probation, while the Home Office and other departments also have responsibilities for criminal law and its reform. There is no single body or person who can accept responsibility for reform.
WHY NOT LEAVE LAW REFORM TO THE COURTS?
The courts, through their use of the doctrine of precedent, could bring about changes in the law. Some academics favour judge-made law, because it is based on real cases rather than legislation which is made in an artificial way. However, judicial development of the common law has constitutional limits. Courts cannot override an Act of Parliament, and major changes involving competing policies may be better left to Parliament. Other arguments against judges reforming the law were put forward by Norman Marsh, a former Law Commissioner:
(a) A judge cannot make assumptions about people’s values; this is better left to Parliament; (b) reform depends on a case coming before the courts; (c) a reforming decision may be hard on the losing party; (d) the system of precedent is slower than legislation; (e) courts may lack the background information available through a law reform body’s wider consultation. Courts can, however, receive expert evidence and submissions from interveners.
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE LAW REFORM AGENCIES
In 1921 an American lawyer, Benjamin Cardozo, in “A Ministry of Justice” Harvard Law Review, 1921, suggested a permanent body:
“The courts are not helped as they could and ought to be in the adaptation of law to justice. The main reason they are not helped is because there is no one whose business it is to give warning that help is needed…”
In 1934 the Lord Chancellor set up the Law Revision Committee which was followed by the Law Reform Committee in 1952. It was a part time body of practitioners and academics whose task was to examine and report on any matters of civil law referred to it by the Lord Chancellor.
In 1959 the Home Secretary set up the Criminal Law Revision Committee, a part time body, to carry out a similar role as regards criminal law, and it examined matters referred to it by the Home Secretary.
In 1965 a White Paper proposed setting up a full time body:
“One of the hallmarks of an advanced society is that its laws should not only be just but also that they be kept up to date and be readily accessible to all who are affected by them.” (Proposals for English and Scottish Law Commissions 1965 (Cmnd 2573)).
This was quickly followed by the Law Commissions Act 1965, which set up two Commissions, one for England and Wales (jointly) and one for Scotland. Section 3 of the Act provides:
“It shall be the duty of … the Commissions … to keep under review all the law … with a view to its systematic development and reform, including in particular the codification of such law, the elimination of anomalies, the repeal of obsolete and unnecessary enactments, the reduction of the number of separate enactments and generally the simplification and modernisation of the law …”
The section went on to provide that the Commissions should:
(a) consider proposals for reform made to them; (b) prepare and give to the Minister programmes for the reform of different branches of the law; (c) prepare draft bills for matters approved; (d) prepare the consolidation of statutes on request by the Minister; (e) give advice on reform to Government departments and others, and to the Welsh Ministers under the amended Act; (f) obtain information about other legal systems which might help in the task of reform.
WHO CONTRIBUTES TO REFORM OF THE LAW?
THE JUDGES
As we have seen above the judges play a part in reform of the law by adapting old decisions to new situations. The example is often given from the law of tort how the principle in Donoghue v Stevenson, ie, that you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbour, has been used to impose liability in a wide range of situations.
THE LAW REFORM COMMITTEE
This committee produced a range of reports which have been followed by legislation. The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957 and the Latent Damage Act 1986 are examples of this.
THE CRIMINAL LAW REVISION COMMITTEE
This committee also produced reports, and the Theft Act 1968 was the product of one report. However, its report on criminal procedure entitled “Evidence General” which was made in 1972 after eight years of investigation, was not implemented as a whole. This was partly because of its controversial recommendations, which included allowing adverse inferences from a suspect’s silence. Sections 34–37 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 later permitted specified inferences, subject to safeguards; they did not abolish the right to remain silent.
Note: The problems faced by the above two committees were that they were part time, had limited resources, could not initiate reports but had to wait for the Minister to tell them what to examine, and often took a long time to produce a report. The consequence was that their reforms were piecemeal.
The Law Commissions are dealt with separately below.
PARLIAMENT
Parliament has numerous committees which investigate various aspects of law reform from time to time. In July 1988, eg, a Select Committee of the House of Lords was appointed to review the law and procedure relating to murder and life imprisonment. It recommended that the sentence for murder be changed from a fixed sentence of life imprisonment to a maximum of life imprisonment, ie the court would have power to give a lesser term. In December 1995, the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee produced a report on the mandatory life sentence and recommended that the sentence should stay. A life sentence remains mandatory for murder.
GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENTS
These constantly keep under review the law within their particular ambit. They may appoint a committee from within the department to review a topic or may help in directing the work of an independent advisory committee.
One example of a committee within a Government department came from the former Office of Fair Trading. Following numerous complaints about timeshare selling, a departmental report was made calling for legislation. The Timeshare Act 1992 gave consumers cancellation rights. It was replaced by the Timeshare, Holiday Products, Resale and Exchange Contracts Regulations 2010. Regulations 20–22 allow a consumer to withdraw from a regulated contract without giving a reason or incurring costs, normally within 14 days after the later of concluding the contract and receiving a copy. The period is extended where required information or the withdrawal form is missing.
Government ministers may also refer matters to the Law Commission. In 1994, the Home Secretary referred the rules on hearsay evidence in criminal proceedings to the Commission. Hearsay is broadly a statement made otherwise than in oral evidence in the proceedings which is offered as evidence of the truth of what it states. The Commission’s 1997 report, Evidence in Criminal Proceedings: Hearsay and Related Topics (No 245), led to reforms in the Criminal Justice Act 2003; criminal hearsay remains subject to statutory rules and safeguards. Separately, the Commission’s 1993 report, The Hearsay Rule in Civil Proceedings (No 216), led to the Civil Evidence Act 1995, which abolished exclusion on the ground of hearsay in civil proceedings, subject to provisions concerning notice and weight.
ROYAL COMMISSIONS
These bodies also produce ideas for reform, eg, the Royal Commission on Civil Liability and Compensation for Personal Injury reported in 1978 (Pearson Report). One of its recommendations was a “no fault” compensation scheme for the victims of road accidents, funded by a tax on petrol, but this was not implemented. It has been said that such commissions are merely a way of postponing dealing with a problem for at least two years. The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice reported in July 1993. Its recommendations contributed to later reforms, including the Criminal Cases Review Commission under the Criminal Appeal Act 1995 and disclosure rules under the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996. Not every later change followed its recommendations: the restrictions on silence in the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 went against the majority’s recommendation.
UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES
Some academics in certain universities and colleges are constantly carrying out research in various areas of law. One example of such an institution is the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies at Oxford University.
PRESSURE GROUPS
Pressure groups with widely differing aims also contribute to law reform; eg, the former National Consumer Council, whose successor’s consumer advocacy functions transferred to bodies including Citizens Advice in 2014; the Howard League for Penal Reform which campaigns for prisoners; the Justice organisation which upholds the principles of justice and the right to a fair trial and the Legal Action Group which campaigns to improve legal services for disadvantaged members of society.
MEDIA PRESSURE
The influence of the media must not be forgotten, especially with such pioneering programmes as “Rough Justice”.
THE LAW COMMISSION
Although reference will be made to the Law Commission, it must be remembered that there is also a Commission for Scotland. The two Commissions co-operate on matters which affect both Scotland and also England and Wales.
There are five members, namely the chairman and four others, appointed from people qualified by judicial office, legal practice or university teaching of law. They are appointed for terms of up to five years and may be reappointed. The Commissioners work full time. They are supported by lawyers, Parliamentary Counsel, research assistants, administrative staff and specialist advisers. The Commission is sponsored by the Ministry of Justice. Its 2025–26 annual report records some 83 staff and a core budget of £5.16 million. Its Property, Family and Trust Law team now carries out work on land law.
The purpose of the Commission is to keep the whole of the law of England and Wales under review and promote the reform of the law. Its aims include the following:
(a) to simplify the law;
(b) to codify the law;
(c) to eliminate anomalies;
(d) to reduce the number of separate Acts on a particular matter;
(e) to repeal obsolete Acts.
HOW DOES THE LAW COMMISSION CARRY OUT ITS WORK?
The Commission publishes a consultation paper (formerly called a working paper) on a particular matter, explaining the problems and making provisional recommendations. These are circulated to lawyers, academics, Government departments and other interested bodies, asking for comments. After a suitable period to allow for comments to be collated and discussed, a draft report is prepared, usually with a draft bill attached and the final report is presented to the Lord Chancellor and laid before Parliament. The Commission also publishes an annual report. Its four legal teams cover criminal law; commercial and common law; property, family and trust law; and public law and the law in Wales. Consultation is open to the public, and the Commission also works with the Welsh Ministers on devolved matters.
EXAMPLES OF THE COMMISSION’S WORK
Programmes for reform
One of the tasks of the Commission under the Law Commissions Act 1965 was to prepare programmes for reform and to submit these to the Minister. The early programmes included:
(a) the first programme (1965) contained 17 items, including the codification of the entire law of contract;
(b) the second programme (1968) included the codification of criminal and family law;
(c) the third programme (1973) dealt with private international law;
(d) the fourth programme (1989) covered nine items on such diverse matters as the modernisation of conveyancing, and the law relating to mentally incapacitated adults;
(e) the fifth programme (1991) dealt with two items, ie, judicial review and the use of damages in personal injury litigation.
(f) the sixth programme (1995) covered 11 items, ie the law of contract, damages, limitation periods, illegal transactions, landlord and tenant, transfer of land, trusts, family law, company law, third party rights against insurers, and criminal law (including involuntary manslaughter and offences against the person).
The Fourteenth Programme was launched on 4 September 2025. It includes ten new projects, including product liability, agricultural tenancies and public sector automated decision-making, alongside seventeen existing projects.
Reports
Listed below is a very small selection from the reports.
(a) Family Law: Review of Child Law: Guardianship (Law Commission No. 172): the Children Act 1989 was partly based on this.
(b) Statute Law Revision: 13th Report (Law Commission No. 179). This included a draft bill which was presented to Parliament in May 1989 and passed as the Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1989 in November 1989. It repealed a number of disused statutes, including the Scottish Innkeepers Act 1424. The later Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1993 contains 64 pages listing statutes and parts of statutes for repeal, including the Ordinances of Corporations Act 1503.
(c) Criminal Law: Computer Misuse (Law Commission No. 186) was presented to Parliament in October 1989 and led to the Computer Misuse Act 1990, which received Royal Assent in June 1990.
(d) Family Law: The Ground for Divorce (Law Commission No. 192). This was produced in October 1990 and included a draft bill. It suggested that the aim of divorce laws should be to dissolve the marriage with the minimum of distress, to encourage the amicable resolution of practical issues about the home, money and children, and to minimise the harm to children. The resulting divorce provisions in Part II of the Family Law Act 1996 were not brought into force and were repealed in 2014. The present no-fault divorce system was introduced separately by the Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Act 2020, taking effect on 6 April 2022.
(e) Distress for Rent (Law Commission No. 194) was issued in April 1991. It examined the then existing system, under which a landlord who is owed rent can enter the property and take the tenant’s goods, to sell them in order to pay the rent owed. It described the right as being wrong in principle. The common-law right was abolished from 6 April 2014 by section 71 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007. The Act introduced Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery, a statutory procedure limited to qualifying commercial premises and subject to safeguards.
Consultation Papers
For example, in 1995, the Commission published ‘Liability for Psychiatric Illness’ (Paper No 137). This paper examined, in particular, the situation where someone suffers psychiatric illness following the death or injury of a third party caused by the defendant’s negligence. The Commission considered the requirements for liability laid down in Alcock v CC of South Yorkshire Police (1991) too strict. Its final report, Liability for Psychiatric Illness (No 249, 1998), proposed removing some restrictions on claims by people with a close tie of love and affection, while retaining requirements including reasonable foreseeability of recognisable psychiatric illness. Those proposals were not enacted. The current common-law rules must be read in light of Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1; a close tie alone does not establish liability.
Codification
The Commission’s work on the codification of contract law was eventually abandoned, one reason being the difficulty of what to do when faced with conflicting case law. A complete criminal code has not been enacted. Report No 218, Criminal Law: Legislating the Criminal Code: Offences Against the Person and General Principles (November 1993), pointed out that this area of non-fatal offences against the person was in urgent need of reform and cited the archaic language of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. The Commission returned to the subject in Reform of Offences against the Person (No 361, 2015). Its proposed replacement scheme has not been enacted.
Consolidation
The Commission is constantly looking at areas which would benefit from consolidation measures. Examples resulting from the work of the Commission include the Merchant Shipping Act 1995, the Employment Rights Act 1996, the Industrial Tribunals Act 1996 (renamed the Employment Tribunals Act 1996) and the Justices of the Peace Act 1997 (since repealed). A more recent example is the Sentencing Act 2020, which contains the Sentencing Code.
Local legislation
The Commission has been working for some time on a programme of rationalisation of local legislation. The Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1989, for example, repealed wholly or in part some 245 local enactments relating to South Yorkshire. The Law Commission and Scottish Law Commission published a chronological table of local legislation in 1996 covering 26,500 local Acts passed between 1797 and 1994. It recorded specific repeals and amendments; private and personal Acts were the subject of a separate table.
CODIFICATION
The Law Commissions Act 1965 sets out codification as one of the duties of the Commission. The idea of a code is quite simple as the rules from one branch of law would be put together into one book or “code”. This has its attractions, eg, the opportunity could be taken to simplify the law, to use clearer language and all the law on a particular matter could be found in one place. The Commission has pursued criminal law reform in stages. It has emphasised the need for the criminal law to be ‘more accessible and comprehensible to ordinary people’. Its work on sentencing procedure resulted in the Sentencing Code, which came into force on 1 December 2020. However, there are difficulties associated with codification apart from the practical implications of codifying vast areas of the common law. For example: the treatment of earlier case law depends on the terms and purpose of the legislation; the code itself would need to be interpreted; gaps may require judicial interpretation or further legislation; and the code would need amendment as circumstances changed.
There are also problems concerned with the type of code to be chosen. Would it, eg, be a very detailed one like the German Civil Code with section numbers running up to 2,385, or like the French “Code Civil” which sets out basic principles, leaving the courts to fill in the details? A detailed code is more certain but less flexible. Comprehensive codes are less characteristic of the common law system, although parts have been codified, eg, the Sale of Goods Act.
A MINISTER OF JUSTICE
The Haldane Committee in 1918 suggested a Minister of Justice in charge of the legal system. A Ministry of Justice was established in May 2007 and is headed by the Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice. Responsibility remains divided with the Home Office and other Government departments; consumer protection policy, for example, is within the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade. Devolved matters also involve the Welsh Ministers and Senedd. A Ministry of Justice does not therefore have sole control over law reform.
EVALUATION OF PRESENT POSITION ON LAW REFORM
The Law Commission has made progress in some areas, eg, it has achieved the repeal of outdated laws and it has made innovations like the preparation of draft bills containing reform measures, to save Parliament time. The success of Law Commission recommendations for reform has varied over the years of its existence, and its 2025–26 annual report records 171 of 262 law reform reports (65 per cent) as implemented wholly or partly, including accepted reports whose implementation was underway. Historical successes included parts of the Family Law Act 1996, the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 and the Land Registration Act 1997. More recent examples include the Arbitration Act 2025 and the Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025. The 1978 Report on Interest recommended that a creditor should have an automatic right to interest on unpaid debts. The Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 later introduced statutory interest for qualifying commercial debts.
This success rate may in part be due to gaining support for law reform measures from all political parties. New parliamentary procedures have also helped. Under one procedure, after the second reading in the House of Lords a Bill can go to a Special Public Bill Committee, which can hear written and oral evidence. This allows technical Bills, such as those produced by the Commission, to be given expert scrutiny without taking up time on the floor. These committees are known as ‘Jellicoe Committees’. In the House of Commons, Standing Order No 59 provides for qualifying Law Commission Bills to be referred to a Second Reading Committee, unless the House orders otherwise or the Bill is referred to the Scottish Grand Committee. Private Members’ Bills and consolidation Bills are excluded from that rule. The House of Lords also has a dedicated procedure for uncontroversial Law Commission Bills, including a Second Reading Committee and detailed scrutiny by a Special Public Bill Committee.
The system of programmes for reform has not been consistent, with a 16-year gap between the third and fourth programmes. Problems have arisen with the schemes for the codification of certain areas of law.
In spite of the difficulties the Commission has faced, in its Sixth Programme of Law Reform (No 234), published in June 1995, it set out the advantages of having a Commission as having independence of the Government, a single purpose of law reform and expertise developed over 30 years.
The general public now demand that the law should be clear, accessible to all and cheap to use. In the face of these demands the work of the Commission should be given a higher priority and more resources should be allocated to it. In spite of recent successes, it must be remembered that implementation of its reforms is still very much in the hands of the Government. The Law Commission Act 2009 introduced a duty on the Lord Chancellor to report annually to Parliament on implementation. Under the 2010 protocol, the responsible minister should provide an interim response within six months and a final response within a year. The Wales Act 2014 added separate reporting and protocol provisions for Welsh Ministers. Consultation papers and reports are now freely available online, but implementation still depends on government decisions and, where legislation is needed, parliamentary time.
Notes adapted from: T. Blakemore & B. Greene, Law for Legal Executives, Second Edition, 1998.