Contract Frustrations Scenario.
Example Contract Law Problem Question
Scenario
York Racecourse was to host the Royal race meeting on 10th, 11th and 12th October 2014.
As the race meeting would attract more crowds than usual, York Racecourse contracted with Buildanything Ltd (“Buildanything”) for them to build a new car park close to the river. As part of the contract Buildanything were required to resurface and widen the existing access road to the current car park which would then lead onto the proposed new car park. The new car park was to be completed by 8th October 2014. A deposit of £60,000 was payable by York Racecourse before 8th September 2014 and the balance of £100,000 was payable on 8th October 2014.
Law Teacher writing support
Working on a law problem question?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.
York Racecourse decided that the seats in the race stands needed renewing before the Royal race meeting. They therefore contracted with Seating Ltd for them to replace all the seats in stands A and B by 30th September for a total cost of £30,000. Seating Ltd underestimated how long it would take them to replace all the seats and when they left the job on 30th September a number of the seats had been poorly fitted. Seating Ltd are claiming the full £30,000 from York Racecourse.
Mr Robinson has let out his house in York for £5,000 for the 3 days of the Royal race meeting to Miss Jones. Miss Jones paid a deposit of £2,000 on entering into the contract with Mr Robinson and the balance was due on 10th October 2014.
During 2nd, 3rd and 4th October 2014 York suffered from exceptionally heavy rain. The racecourse, which is low lying, was flooded so the Royal race meeting had to be cancelled. It cannot be rescheduled. The area where work was underway on the new car park was entirely submerged by water and most of what had been done was washed away by the river. The area is no longer suitable for any development.
Buildanything are claiming the balance of the monies they say are due. They say that their labour costs for installing the new car park and improving the access road amount to £40,000 and they wish to recover those costs from York Racecourse.
Miss Jones has informed Mr Robinson that she no longer wants to stay at his house in York as the Royal race meeting has been cancelled.
Explain the relevant law and advise York Racecourse as to their liability to Buildanything and Seating Ltd.
Also advise Mr Robinson who is seeking to recover the balance of £3,000 from Miss Jones.
Answer
The scenario relates to the doctrine of frustration. It asks whether the flood or the cancellation of the Royal race meeting discharged any of the contracts[1]. Frustration arises where a supervening event, without the fault of either party, would make performance radically different from what the contract required[2]. It discharges future obligations automatically at the time of the event. Rights arising from an earlier breach may survive.
‘Buildanything’ Contract
Prior to completion of the car park by Buildanything, the site flooded and became unsuitable for development. York Racecourse was to pay a deposit of £60,000 before 8 September, but the facts do not expressly say whether it did. Frustration can apply where performance becomes impossible or where an event fundamentally changes the obligation[3]. It does not apply simply because performance becomes more difficult, expensive or less advantageous[4]. The parties’ terms, the circumstances and their allocation of the risk of flooding matter. If a force majeure or other provision deals with this event, the contract governs to the extent of that provision[5].
This case appears to be one in which the doctrine of frustration could apply. In Taylor v Caldwell, the music hall burned down before the first concert, and both parties were discharged from future performance[6]. In a building contract, the contractor may bear the risk of damage before completion and have to make good the work at its own cost if the site remains usable, depending on the contract[7]. In Appleby v Myers, destruction of the premises before work on them was complete discharged the parties[8]. The question is what the contract required and whether its performance would now be radically different[9]. Here most of the work was washed away and a car park can no longer be built at the agreed location. Unless Buildanything assumed that risk, or its own breach brought about the impossibility, the contract is likely to be frustrated.
If the contract was frustrated, the balance of £100,000 falling due on 8 October is no longer payable[10]. Under section 1(2) of the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, the £60,000 deposit is in principle recoverable if paid, or ceases to be payable if unpaid[11]. The court can allow Buildanything to retain or recover a just sum for expenses incurred before discharge in or for performance, limited to the expenses proved and the amount paid or payable before discharge[12]. If it allows the whole £40,000 claimed and the deposit was paid, Buildanything would return £20,000. If the deposit was unpaid, the court could allow recovery of up to £40,000 on the stated figures. The allowance is discretionary. In Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd the court took into account the parties’ respective expenses and made no allowance to the recipient of the advance[13].
Section 2(4) may apply to the road widening and resurfacing if that part can properly be severed and had been wholly performed before the flood, apart from any payment that can be ascertained under the contract. If so it is treated as a separate contract, and Buildanything can claim the price attributable to that work. The facts do not say whether it was complete or separately priced[14]. If the road works are not severable but conferred a valuable benefit before discharge, section 1(3) may allow a just sum, capped at the benefit’s value. The court takes account of any effect of the flood on its value and any relevant expenses of York Racecourse, including sums Buildanything is allowed to retain or recover under section 1(2). The labour costs alone do not establish the value of the benefit. If the improvement was washed away and no value remained, an award on that basis is unlikely[27].
Seating Ltd Contract
Seating Ltd finished or left the job before the flood. The facts suggest that the seating was intended to remain in use for future race meetings. The cancellation of the Royal meeting does not remove that continuing purpose, even if it explains the original deadline[15]. In National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (Northern) Ltd, the House of Lords held that the closure of the only access road for about 20 months did not frustrate a ten-year lease which had several years left to run[16]. Here the flood did not cause the poor fitting, and there is no indication that it prevented correction of the work. York Racecourse cannot avoid liability to Seating Ltd on the ground of frustration.
Poorly fitted seats constitute defective performance if they fail to meet the contract specification or the duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in fitting them[17]. If Seating Ltd also supplied defective seats in the course of business, the applicable implied term as to satisfactory quality may be breached even if Seating Ltd was not at fault[18]. Whether York Racecourse may terminate depends on the contract and the seriousness of the breach. A breach of condition can entitle it to terminate. Breach of a term that is neither a condition nor a warranty permits termination if the consequences deprive it of substantially the whole benefit of the contract[19]. The question does not say how many seats were affected, whether any were unsafe, or how readily they could be put right.
Damages reflect the loss caused by the breach[20]. If Seating Ltd substantially performed, it can generally recover the contract price, subject to a deduction for the reasonable cost of rectifying the defects. If it did not substantially perform, it may not have earned the lump sum, depending on the payment terms[21]. If the cost of rectification is disproportionate, diminution in value may be the appropriate measure. Any award should avoid putting York Racecourse in a better position than performance would have done[22]. It should give Seating Ltd an opportunity to inspect and, where reasonable, put the defects right. Other losses must be caused by the breach, be recoverable under the rules on remoteness and be mitigated. The cancellation of the meeting was caused by the flood[23].
If the fitting contract is a construction contract under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, York Racecourse must also check the payment and pay less notices. Where there is a notified sum, it may have to pay that sum by the final date unless a valid, timely pay less notice was served. It can then challenge the valuation or pursue its claim for defects. The same payment regime may be relevant to a notified sum for Buildanything’s road and car park works, depending on the notices and the date and effect of discharge[28].
Lease of Mr Robinson’s House
The house was let for the three days of the Royal race meeting. If it remained accessible and fit to occupy, physical performance was possible. The question is whether viewing or attending the meeting was the shared foundation of the bargain or simply Miss Jones’s reason for booking. In Herne Bay Steamboat Co v Hutton, cancellation of the naval review did not frustrate the hire because the other purpose of the trip could still be fulfilled[24]. In Krell v Henry, the agreed hire was frustrated because viewing the coronation procession was the common foundation of the contract[25]. The matching dates support Miss Jones’s argument, but the facts do not say that Mr Robinson let the house on the shared understanding that the meeting was the basis of the hire. If she could still use the house as ordinary accommodation, frustration is less likely.
If the flood made the house uninhabitable or inaccessible for the whole short letting, the contract would be much more likely to be frustrated, subject to any agreed allocation of risk. A lease can in principle be frustrated, although this is rare[29]. If the contract was frustrated either because the shared purpose failed or because the house could not be used, Miss Jones would ordinarily recover the £2,000 paid and would not owe the £3,000 balance. The court can allow Mr Robinson to retain a just sum for proved expenses under section 1(2). None is identified here[26].
Conclusion
The Buildanything contract is likely to be frustrated if the agreed site can no longer be used and the contract did not allocate that risk to the builder. Seating Ltd’s claim depends on how much of its work it performed, the cost of making good the defects and any applicable payment notices. If Mr Robinson’s contract was not frustrated and he kept the house available in accordance with it, he may claim the £3,000 when due. The £2,000 already paid counts towards the price. If he instead accepted Miss Jones’s refusal as ending the contract, he could claim loss caused by her breach, subject to reasonable mitigation and credit for payments already received. He cannot recover the same loss twice[30].
Footnotes
[1] J Poole, Casebook on Contract Law (11th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 513.
[2] Davis Contractors Ltd v Fareham Urban District Council [1956] AC 696, 729 (Lord Radcliffe).
[3] Pioneer Shipping Ltd v BTP Tioxide Ltd (The Nema) [1982] AC 724, 752 (Lord Roskill).
[4] Ocean Tramp Tankers Corporation v V/O Sovfracht, The Eugenia 1964 2 QB 226, per Lord Denning at 239.
[5] E McKendrick, Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (5th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 397; Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 2(3); The Sea Angel [2007] EWCA Civ 547, [111]; RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV [2024] UKSC 18.
[6] Taylor v Caldwell (1863) 3 B & S 826.
[7] E Peel, Treitel: The Law of Contract (13th edn, Sweet and Maxwell 2011) 19-015.
[8] Appleby v Myers (1867) L.R. 2 C.P. 651.
[9] Davis Contractors Ltd. v. Fareham Urban District Council 1956 A.C. 696 per Lord Radcliffe at 729.
[10] Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(2).
[11] The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, section 1(2).
[12] Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(2) and (4).
[13] Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 1126; R Stone, Modern Law of Contract (9th edn, Routledge 2011) 416.
[14] The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, section 2(4).
[15] Herne Bay Steamboat Co v Hutton 1903 2 KB 683
[16] National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (Northern) Ltd [1981] AC 675, 704.
[17] Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, s 13; McKendrick, n 5, 753; The Stork [1955] 2 QB 68.
[18] Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, s 4, as applicable in 2014; Peel, n 7, 17-065.
[19] Bentsen v Taylor [1893] 2 QB 274; Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26.
[20] Teacher v Calder (1899) 1 F (HL) 39; Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850, 855.
[21] Hoenig v Isaacs [1952] 2 All ER 176; Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] 1 WLR 1009.
[22] Phillips v Ward [1956] 1 WLR 471; Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth [1996] AC 344; see also Demarco v Perkins [2006] EWCA Civ 188.
[23] Peel, n7, 20-005.
[24] Herne Bay Steamboat Co v Hutton 1903 2 KB 683
[25] Krell v Henry 1903 2 KB 740.
[26] The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, section 1(2).
[27] Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(3); BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 783, 799–802.
[28] Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, Part II, ss 104–105 and 110A–111; S&T (UK) Ltd v Grove Developments Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 2448.
[29] National Carriers, above; Canary Wharf (BP4) T1 Ltd v European Medicines Agency [2019] EWHC 335 (Ch).
[30] White & Carter (Councils) Ltd v McGregor [1962] AC 413; British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673, 689.
Last updated: 13 November 2026