Offer and Acceptance in the Sale of Goods and Promotions
Example Contract Law Problem Question
Scenario
Part A
Liv advertised in her local newspaper. The advert states “For sale, rare pottery collection, £800. Contact 07557123456”. On Monday, Jamie saw the advertisement and telephoned Liv expressing his interest in the collection. Liv said that as Jamie was obviously a very keen collector, she would let him have the items for £600. Jamie then offered £550. Liv said she would think about it and get back to him the following day. On Tuesday Dan saw the advertisement, and contacted Liv. Dan asked Liv what minimum price she would accept for the collection. Liv replied stating that the minimum she would accept is £575. Dan said that he accepted the offer over the phone and would be in touch later that week to finalise the details.
Law Teacher writing support
Working on a law problem question?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.
On Wednesday, Liv met up with her friend, Charles, who expressed interest in the pottery collection. He offered £600 for the collection and Liv agreed to sell immediately.
That lunchtime a mutual friend, Dora, told Jamie and Dan about the pottery Charles had just bought from Liv. Jamie and Dan are both very cross as the pottery is worth at least £1000, and are demanding that Liv sell them the pottery collection.
Advise Liv.
Part B
Fitness Fitness Fitness places an advertisement on their window stating:
The first 25 people to complete interval training on our brand new treadmill machines within five minutes will be rewarded with one year’s free membership.
Emily notices the advertisement and completes the task within five minutes. Emily is one of the first 25 people. Whilst Emily is completing the interval training, the manager places a notice on the window withdrawing the promotion; the manager is refusing to give Emily her free membership for 12 months, stating that the promotion is no longer valid.
Advise Emily.
Answer
Part A
There are certain components that need to be present in order for a valid contract to be formed. The most basic of these is that there must be a valid offer and an unequivocal acceptance of that offer which form the very basis of a contract. This needs to be accompanied with an intention to create legal relations and valid consideration[1]. Without these there can be no ordinary contract of sale.[2]
The Advertisement
The newspaper advertisement details the pottery for £800. It must be established whether this was an offer by Liv, or a mere invitation to treat. The general presumption is that advertisements will be construed as the latter[3]. Contractual intent is assessed objectively[4]. The advert lists a price and contact number for a single collection, without promising to sell it to the first person to respond. It invites prospective buyers to contact Liv.
Jamie
As it has been established that the advert is not in itself an offer, it is necessary to distinguish an offer from the conversation that takes place between Liv and Jamie. This comes when Liv tells Jamie he can purchase the collection for £600. Liv offers the pottery to Jamie at a reduced rate on the basis that Jamie is an ardent collector. It would appear from the nature of the transaction that there is an intention to be legally bound and thus, the offer is likely to be valid. In order for an offer to be accepted, the rule is that it must be accepted unequivocally and without alteration.[5] However, Jamie does not accept this offer and instead makes a counter-offer of £550. This has the effect of destroying the original offer[6] and as such Jamie will no longer be entitled to go back and accept Liv’s offer for the sale of the pottery for £600. Instead this will act as a fresh offer which Liv can then accept. Jamie is entitled to revoke the offer before Liv accepts it,[7] provided that such revocation is communicated to Liv.[8]
Liv’s promise to think about it and get back to Jamie is not an acceptance. Her sale to Charles does not amount to an acceptance or a revocation of Jamie’s offer, which was his to withdraw. Dora’s account of the sale does not revive Liv’s original offer of £600. There is no contract between Jamie and Liv.
Dan
As it has been established that Liv’s advert will not constitute a valid offer it is first necessary to distinguish whether an offer is made at any point within the communications between Liv and Dan. When Dan contacts Liv regarding the pottery and asks the minimum price she will accept for it, Liv’s reply will not constitute an offer. A reply stating a minimum price in response to an enquiry is ordinarily information, as in Harvey v Facey[9]. Nothing in Liv’s reply indicates a commitment to sell to Dan at that price. The offer here comes in the form of Dan’s attempted acceptance of what he believes to be an offer from Liv. When Dan replies that he is willing to pay the £575 this forms an offer which Liv is open to accept. However the conversation ends without Liv accepting it. Dora’s account of the sale does not give Dan any contractual right to the collection.
Charles
The conversation that takes place between Liv and Charles is more straightforward in terms of distinguishing a clear offer and acceptance. It appears that Charles’ offer to Liv for £600 in return for acquiring the pottery collection is a valid offer to which Liv gives an unequivocal acceptance. Although Liv and Charles are friends, this was a bargain for the sale of goods. The context of an agreement, including its terms and purpose, determines whether the parties intended to create legal relations[10]. A social setting does not prevent a binding agreement[11]. Having successfully established these elements it is necessary to establish valid consideration in order to advise Liv whether she is bound to sell to Charles. Consideration is defined in Currie v Misa (1875) L.R. 10 Ex. 153 as “some right, interest, profit or benefit accruing to one party or some forbearance, detriment, loss or responsibility, given, suffered, or undertaken by the other”.[12] It can be seen here that this is satisfied by Charles’s promise to pay £600 in return for Liv’s promise to transfer the pottery. The general rule is that consideration must be sufficient but need not be adequate[13]. This reflects the self-regulatory foundations of contract law[14]. This means that although Liv has essentially made a bad bargain, the courts will not step in to protect her by insisting that Charles contract for the full value of the goods.
There is a valid contract between Liv and Charles. A sale of goods can be agreed orally. If Liv wrongfully fails to deliver, Charles may claim damages for non-delivery. The usual measure where there is an available market is the difference between the market price at the relevant time and the contract price. He could also ask the court to order delivery of the specific collection if damages would be inadequate, for example if a substitute cannot readily be found[32].
Part B
Introduction
Emily appears to have entered into a contract with FFF, entitling her to free membership for a year. This type of contract does not require a prescribed form[15]. It requires an offer, acceptance of that offer, intention to be legally bound and consideration[16]. Acceptance may be shown by conduct[17].
Offer
An offer is a statement made by a party that they are willing to enter into contractual relations with another party on specified terms.[18] FFF’s advertisement promises free membership to the first 25 people to complete interval training on its new treadmills within five minutes. It is capable of being a unilateral offer. Emily did not have to promise to train. Completing the task as specified would provide consideration for FFF’s promise.
Advertisements in shop windows and shop displays are usually invitations to treat[19]. This lets a shopkeeper decide whether to accept a customer’s offer and avoids contracting to supply more goods than are available[20]. In Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co, the £1,000 bank deposit was evidence that the company intended its advertisement as a binding promise[21]. Advertisements can amount to offers where their wording and circumstances show that intention[22]. In the Minnesota case of Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store, a sufficiently definite first-come, first-served advertisement was held to be an offer[23]. The distinction depends on the intention objectively shown by the advertisement[24]. FFF’s advert mentions no deposit of the kind made in Carlill[25], but specifies the reward, the task, the time limit and the maximum number of successful participants. It requires no further bargain. It is likely to be treated as an offer.
Acceptance
The general rule is that acceptance must be communicated to the offeror. In Carlill, the nature and terms of the unilateral offer showed that doing the required act was sufficient without separate notice of acceptance[26]. In The Satanita, the competitors bound themselves to one another by entering a race on its published rules[27]. Here the advertisement requires no separate notification. Emily knew about the offer and completed the task within five minutes as one of the first 25 people.
Emily therefore fulfilled the conditions for acceptance. The remaining question is whether the manager could withdraw the offer while she was performing.
Withdrawal of Offer
An offer can generally be revoked before acceptance[28], provided that the revocation is communicated[29]. In Byrne v Van Tienhoven, posting a revocation did not take effect before the offeree received it[30]. With an offer made to the public, the adequacy of the publicity given to a withdrawal may matter. There is no indication that Emily saw the new notice before finishing.
There is a further difficulty for FFF even if Emily saw the notice. In Daulia v Four Millbank Nominees, Goff LJ explained that a unilateral offer can ordinarily require full performance before the reward is due, but the offeror may be under an implied obligation not to prevent completion once the offeree has begun the requested performance. The Court of Appeal applied the same principle in Soulsbury v Soulsbury[33]. Emily had already begun the training itself when the notice went up. FFF is unlikely to be able to rely on the notice to deny the reward after she completed the task.
Conclusion
Emily is likely to be entitled to one year’s free gym membership. If FFF refuses to provide it, she can claim damages for the loss of the promised membership, ordinarily measured by the reasonable cost of equivalent membership[31]. Refusing to award a prize described in a promotion or a reasonable equivalent can also be an unfair commercial practice under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, whose relevant provisions apply to practices from 6 April 2025[34].
Footnotes
[1] Murray, Contract Law (2nd edn. Sweet and Maxwell 2011) 5.
[2] Poole, Casebook on Contract Law (11th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 18.
[3] Partridge v Crittenden 1968 1 W.L.R. 1204
[4] Storer v Manchester City Council 1974 1 W.L.R. 1403
[5] Hyde v Wrench (1840) 3 Beav 334.
[6] Hyde v Wrench (1840) 3 Beav 334.
[7] Routledge v Grant (1828) 4 Bing. 653.
[8] Pickfords Ltd v Celestica Ltd 2003 EWCA Civ 1741.
[9] Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552 (PC).
[10] See Balfour v Balfour 1919 2 K.B. 571 and Merritt v Merritt 1970 1 W.L.R. 1211
[11] Simpkins v Pays 1955 1 W.L.R 975
[12] Currie v Misa (1875) LR 10 Ex 153, 162.
[13] See for example Thomas v Thomas (1842) 2 Q.B. 851
[14] Murray, Contract Law (2nd edn Sweet and Maxwell 2011) 73
[15] R Stone, Modern Law of Contract (9th edn, Routledge 2011) 33.
[16] Poole, Casebook on Contract Law (11th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 19.
[17] Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Company (1877) 2 App. Cas. 666, per Lord Blackburn at 691.
[18] E McKendrick, Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (5th edn, Oxford University Press 2012) 44.
[19] Fisher v. Bell 1961 1 QB 394.
[20] McKendrick, above, 68.
[21] Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company 1893 1 Q.B. 256, at 261.
[22] Partridge v Crittenden 1968 2 All E.R. 421
[23] Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store, Inc, 86 NW 2d 689 (1957) (Supreme Court of Minnesota).
[24] Peel E, Treitel: The Law of Contract (13th edn, Sweet and Maxwell 2012) 2:012.
[25] Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company 1893 1 Q.B. 256, at 261.
[26] Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256, 262 (Lindley LJ).
[27] The Satanita [1895] P 248 (CA); affirmed [1897] AC 59 (HL).
[28] Routledge v Grant (1828) 4 Bing 653; Bircham & Co Nominees (No.2) v Worrell Holdings 2001 EWCA Civ 775.
[29] Pickfords Ltd v Celestica Ltd 2003 EWCA Civ 1741.
[30] Byrne & Co v Leon Van Tienhoven & Co (1880) 5 CPD 344.
[31] Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850; Sharp Corp Ltd v Viterra BV [2024] UKSC 14.
[32] Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 4, 51 and 52.
[33] Daulia Ltd v Four Millbank Nominees Ltd [1978] Ch 231, 239; Errington v Errington and Woods [1952] 1 KB 290, 295; Soulsbury v Soulsbury [2007] EWCA Civ 969, [49]–[50].
[34] Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Sch 20, para 21, and s 225(4)(c); SI 2025/272.
Last updated: 13 November 2026