Advising on evidential issues surrounding the Terrorism Act 2000.
Question
Tommy is friends with James and Bill, who are members of an action group called ‘Down with Capitalism’. He speaks to them often as they are old school-friends and they often meet up for drinks in town or at each other’s houses for meals.
James and Bill, as part of their campaign for ‘Down with Capitalism’, break into the National Bank of Britannia and place a bomb which detonates an hour later. James and Bill are caught and face conviction for terrorism-related offences. After investigation, the police discover Tommy’s links with James and Bill and believe he is connected directly with ‘Down with Capitalism’.
Law Teacher writing support
Working on a law problem question?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us the scenario and any marking criteria. We’ll write an answer to your instructions, identifying the legal issues and applying the law to the facts.
The police have covertly been carrying out surveillance at James’ house as they are aware of ‘Down with Capitalism’ and the group’s agenda. They have a recording from a bugging device which the police believe to be Tommy’s voice actively discussing the group’s future plans.
PC Michelin, who is leading the investigation, calls in Joyce, a phoneticist, who compares the telephone conversation with recordings of Tommy’s voice. Joyce concludes that the recordings are of the same person. Savill has developed a system of comparing voices by meticulous listening to recordings of the suspect and the recordings of the event itself. His article on the technique in the journal, International and Comparative Phonetics, was criticised by other phoneticists for its overly subjective approach and its lack of methodological rigour. The technique has not become generally accepted in the field of phonetics.
When arrested, Tommy is taken to the police station where he is placed in the cells prior to interview. Whilst in the cells, PC Goodyear constantly tells him that he might as well admit that he was involved with ‘Down with Capitalism’ because they will get him to confess anyway. He tells Tommy that if he confesses, they would release him on bail but if he doesn’t confess they will apply for him to be remanded in custody pending the case going to court. Tommy is a single parent with two very young children. During interview, the officers are very aggressive and shout and scream in Tommy’s face in an attempt to get him to confess. He later says in his third interview that he is a member of ‘Down with Capitalism’ as he is desperate to get home to his children.
The police charge him with being a member of a terrorist group contrary to section 11(1) of the Terrorism Act 2000.
Advise Tommy regarding the evidential issues that may arise.
Answer
In England and Wales the prosecution must prove that Tommy belongs or professes to belong to a proscribed organisation under section 11(1) of the Terrorism Act 2000. The question does not state that ‘Down with Capitalism’ is proscribed. In this fictional scenario that must be established independently. Even if the acts of James and Bill amount to terrorism, that does not establish proscription or prove Tommy’s membership. If Tommy adduces evidence that the organisation was not proscribed when he last became or began to profess to be a member and that he did not participate in its activities at any time while it was proscribed, the prosecution must disprove the statutory defence beyond reasonable doubt[19].
Relevant evidence may be admitted subject to the rules governing admissibility. Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible, although a suitably qualified expert may give an opinion on a matter within their expertise. Sections 76 and 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) provide for exclusion in the circumstances set out below[1].
Evidence is relevant if ‘it is logically probative or disprobative of some matter which requires proof[2].’ The prosecution must prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt.
A confession made by a suspect may be given in evidence against them so far as it is relevant and not excluded[3]. If it is represented that the confession was or may have been obtained by oppression, or as a consequence of anything said or done that was likely in the circumstances to render unreliable any confession made in consequence, the court must exclude it unless the prosecution proves beyond reasonable doubt that it was not obtained in that way. This applies even if the confession is true. The court can also require the prosecution to prove admissibility of its own motion[4].
As well as the specific rule relating to confessions, section 78 gives the court a discretion to exclude evidence on which the prosecution proposes to rely[5]. The judge may refuse to admit it if, having regard to all the circumstances including how it was obtained, its admission would have such an adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings that the court ought not to admit it. A breach of a rule in obtaining evidence does not automatically require exclusion[6].
The first piece of evidence relates to the covert recording at James’s house. Recording a private conversation in a home can interfere with the Article 8 right to respect for private life, home and correspondence[7]. In Khan v United Kingdom, the European Court of Human Rights found that covert recording under the regime then in place breached Article 8 because there was no sufficiently clear legal basis. It did not find that use of the recording made the trial unfair under Article 6. The House of Lords in R v Khan (Sultan) treated the circumstances of the recording as relevant to the exercise of the section 78 discretion[8].
Covert recording of conversations inside a home may constitute intrusive surveillance under Part II of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000. The judge would consider whether the police had the required authorisation and any approval, whether the interference was necessary and proportionate, and whether any separate property interference was lawfully authorised[9]. The facts refer both to a device at the house and to a telephone conversation. Recording speech in the room is distinct from intercepting a communication in transmission. If the evidence was obtained by interception, the court must consider the statutory restrictions and exceptions in section 56 and Schedule 3 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016[20].
If the recording is admissible, the prosecution must still show that it was Tommy who was talking. Joyce compared the disputed recording with recordings of Tommy’s voice. The question does not say whether she used Savill’s technique or whether Savill was called as a witness. Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible[10]. Experts can assist the court on matters that require special study or experience[11].
Voice identification can be admitted, but mistakes are possible even where a lay witness confidently recognises a familiar voice[12]. The reliability of any identification depends on the circumstances, including recording quality, the amount and comparability of speech, and the basis for attributing the reference recording to Tommy. Research on earwitness testimony illustrates some of these risks[13]. If admitted, the judge should direct the jury about the risks and limitations relevant to the evidence actually used.
The court must decide whether an opinion concerns a matter on which expert assistance is needed and whether the witness has the necessary expertise. The opinion must also have a sufficiently reliable basis. These matters are reflected in the Criminal Practice Directions[14]. The court can consider the quality of the data, whether the method has been tested, its acceptance in the field, the way it was applied and whether the conclusion properly reflects uncertainty. The expert must give objective evidence, and the report must explain the basis of the opinion and its limitations[15].
Joyce’s description as a phoneticist is relevant but does not by itself establish expertise in forensic speaker comparison. Auditory and acoustic analysis can both be admitted if sufficiently reliable in the case at hand. The prosecution would need to show her qualifications and experience, the method she used and why it supports her conclusion. If Joyce relied on Savill’s technique, or if Savill gave evidence based on it, publication alone would not establish reliability. The criticisms of subjectivity and lack of methodological rigour are material. Lack of general acceptance is a factor, but the court must assess whether the opinion has a sufficiently reliable basis. If it does not, the opinion is inadmissible. If it does, remaining weaknesses may affect weight and section 78 may still apply. The disclosure rules apply to material capable of undermining the prosecution’s case or assisting Tommy’s, subject to the statutory exceptions[21].
Tommy’s admission that he is a member of ‘Down with Capitalism’ is a confession for the purposes of PACE because it is at least partly adverse to him[16]. He has grounds to seek its exclusion under both limbs of section 76(2).
First, PC Goodyear repeatedly tells Tommy that the police will get him to confess. The judge should consider what was said in the cells together with what happened during the interviews, including whether the effect of that pressure continued into the third interview.
Second, PC Goodyear promises bail if Tommy confesses and threatens continued custody if he does not. This is a strong inducement, especially given Tommy’s concern about getting home to his children. If he was arrested under ordinary PACE powers, Code C applies. If he was detained under section 41 and Schedule 8 to the Terrorism Act 2000, Code H applies. The charge alone does not establish the power of arrest. Both codes prohibit using oppression to obtain answers and restrict what interviewers may say about action the police will take in response to a suspect’s answers or silence. The judge can consider whether the exchanges in the cells amounted to questioning outside the safeguards of an interview. Ordinary PACE bail powers do not apply while a person is detained under section 41[17].
Third, shouting and screaming at Tommy to obtain a confession may amount to oppression. In R v Paris, Abdullahi and Miller, persistent bullying in interview was held to be oppressive[18]. Even if the judge finds that the officers’ conduct fell short of oppression, the pressure and the promise of bail were likely in the circumstances to make a resulting confession unreliable. Tommy’s stated reason for admitting membership supports a causal link. The prosecution is unlikely on these facts to discharge its burden under section 76(2). If the confession survives that test, the same conduct remains relevant to exclusion under section 78.
The recorded conversation may be admissible, depending on how it was obtained and the fairness of using it. The prosecution must establish a proper basis for any expert voice comparison. The confession is likely to be excluded. Friendship with James and Bill is not enough to prove membership. Even if either disputed item of evidence is admitted, the prosecution still has to prove that the group was proscribed and that Tommy belonged or professed to belong to it.
Footnotes
[1] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s76 and s78.
[2] DPP v Kilbourne [1973] AC 729 at p756.
[3] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s76(1).
[4] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, s 76(2) and (3).
[5] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s78.
[6] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s78(1).
[7] European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms 1950, Article 8.
[8] Khan v United Kingdom [2000] Crim LR 684; R v Khan (Sultan) [1997] AC 558.
[9] Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, Part II; Police Act 1997, Part III; P G and J H v United Kingdom [2002] Crim LR 308.
[10] Hodge M Malek, Phipson on Evidence, 18th Edition (Sweet and Maxwell 2013).
[11] Folkes v Chadd (1782) 3 Doug. 157.
[12] R v R (David Anthony) [2000] Crim LR 183 (CA); R v Flynn and St John [2008] EWCA Crim 970; Crown Court Compendium, Part I, section 15-7, 15-28 to 15-32.
[13] Bull and Clifford, ‘Earwitness Testimony’ in Heaton-Armstrong, Shepherd and Wolchover (eds), Analysing Witness Testimony (1999 OUP).
[14] R v Bonython (1984) 38 SASR 45 (Supreme Court of South Australia); Criminal Practice Directions 2023, para 7.1.
[15] R v Bonython (1984) 38 SASR 45; R v Brecani [2021] EWCA Crim 731; Criminal Procedure Rules 2025, rr 19.2–19.4.
[16] Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s82.
[17] PACE Code C, paras 11.1A and 11.5; PACE Code H, paras 1N, 11.1 and 11.6.
[18] R v Paris, Abdullahi and Miller (1992) 97 Cr App R 99; R v Fulling [1987] QB 426; Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, s 76(8).
[19] Terrorism Act 2000, ss 1, 3 and 11, and Sch 2; Attorney General’s Reference (No 4 of 2002) [2004] UKHL 43.
[20] Investigatory Powers Act 2016, s 56 and Sch 3.
[21] Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996, s 3, and ss 7A and 8.
Last updated: 13 November 2026