Legal Case Summary
Bolton v Stone [1951] UKHL 2; [1951] AC 850
TORT OF NEGLIGENCE – FACTORS RELEVANT TO BREACH OF DUTY
Facts
The claimant was injured after a ball from a neighbouring cricket pitch flew into her outside her home. The field was enclosed by a seven-foot fence. Because the ground sloped upwards, the top of the fence stood about 17 feet above the level of the cricket pitch. Balls had been known to get over the fence and land in people’s yards, but this was rare, making the strike which hit the claimant exceptional. The claimant sued the club’s committee and members in negligence for her injuries.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issue
Establishing the tort of negligence involves establishing that the defendant owed the claimant a duty of care, which they breached in a manner which caused the claimant recoverable harm. To establish a breach of any duty owed, the claimant must establish that the defendant failed to act as a reasonable person would in their position.
The issue in this case was what factors were relevant to determining how the reasonable person would behave, and therefore when the defendant would be in breach of their duty of care.
Decision / Outcome
The House of Lords held that the cricket club was not in breach of its duty. It allowed the defendants’ appeal and restored the trial judge’s decision in their favour.
The mere possibility of a ball leaving the ground and causing injury did not itself establish negligence. The court considered how rarely balls reached the road and the further chance that a ball would strike someone there. A reasonable person would assess the degree of risk, including the likelihood and potential seriousness of injury.
In this case, the risk of injury was extremely small. The hit was exceptional, the road was not busy and no previous injury had been proved. A reasonable person in the defendants’ position would not have considered further precautions necessary.
Lord Reid emphasised that the result depended on the very small risk on these facts. If cricket could not be played on a ground without creating a substantial risk, it should not be played there at all; the difficulty of remedial measures would not justify that risk.