Euro Brokers Holdings Ltd v Monecor (London) Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 105; [2003] 1 BCLC 506; [2003] BCC 573
The Court of Appeal upheld an order requiring Monecor to sell its shares in a joint venture after it failed to meet an agreed capital call. Although the company’s board lacked a quorum, both shareholders had agreed to treat the funding request as a valid call under their shareholders’ agreement. Monecor could not avoid the consequences by later insisting on board formalities which the shareholders had agreed to dispense with.
Facts
Euro Brokers and Monecor each owned half of Euro Brokers Finacor Ltd (EBFL), a financial brokerage business regulated by the Financial Services Authority. Their shareholders’ agreement provided for further funding to be supplied equally. Neither shareholder was obliged to provide additional capital, but clause 11(2) specified the consequences of declining a qualifying capital call: the other shareholder could provide the funding and exercise a right to buy the declining shareholder’s entire holding.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
A call under clause 11(2) was normally to be made by notice from EBFL’s board, specifying the amount, reasons and payment deadline. However, both directors appointed by Monecor had resigned. Without at least one director appointed by each shareholder, the board lacked a quorum. Monecor did not use its power to appoint replacements because it misunderstood its entitlement to do so.
On 31 October 2000, EBFL’s finance director requested £250,000 from each shareholder. The purpose was to maintain sufficient capital for the business, including an agreed £500,000 buffer above the regulatory minimum. After requesting financial information, Monecor agreed to contribute £250,000. It paid £100,000 but failed to pay the remaining £150,000 by the extended deadline of 4 December.
Euro Brokers exercised its right to acquire Monecor’s shares. Monecor later paid the outstanding £150,000, which EBFL accepted without prejudice to the exercise of that right. The High Court ordered specific performance of Monecor’s obligation to transfer its shares. Monecor appealed.
Issues
The main question was whether the funding request could be a valid capital call despite the absence of a notice issued by a properly constituted board. The court also considered whether clause 11(2) permitted funding to maintain the agreed buffer, whether Monecor knew that the request was made under the shareholders’ agreement, and whether specific performance should be refused because of Euro Brokers’ conduct.
Decision
The Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed the appeal on 11 February 2003. Mummery LJ gave the principal judgment, with Waller and Pill LJJ agreeing. The order requiring Monecor to transfer its shares remained in place.
Why the informal agreement was effective
The court accepted that EBFL’s board could not itself issue the required notice while it lacked a quorum. The answer was not to pretend that the board had been properly constituted. Instead, the evidence supported the finding that both shareholders had agreed, through their conduct, to treat the finance director’s request as a capital call under clause 11(2).
This applied the Duomatic principle: unanimous shareholder assent can give effect to a decision without the usual formal procedure where that procedure exists for the benefit of those agreeing to dispense with it. Here, the shareholders’ agreement regulated their relationship in the governance of EBFL. The fact that the notice requirement appeared in a separate contract, rather than solely in the company’s articles, did not prevent the principle from applying.
The court stressed the agreement of all the shareholders. This was not a power for one shareholder or an employee to override the other. Once both shareholders agreed to proceed as if the required notice had been given, the call carried the contractual consequences of non-payment, including the right to acquire the declining shareholder’s shares.
The amount of the call and the remedy
Clause 11(2) was not confined to calls made after EBFL had already fallen below the FSA’s minimum capital requirement. Maintaining a buffer allowed the business to absorb losses and avoid breaching its regulatory obligations. The shareholders had accepted the £500,000 buffer as reasonable, and the clause did not limit calls to a shortfall against the regulatory minimum on a particular date.
The evidence also supported the finding that Monecor knew the request was being made under the shareholders’ agreement. It had received the reasonably necessary financial information, agreed to pay and made the first instalment. Its later objection to the formal procedure did not undo that agreement.
The trial judge had additionally relied on waiver and estoppel. The Court of Appeal expressly found it unnecessary to decide those alternative arguments because the capital call was already valid under its principal reasoning.
Finally, there was no basis for overturning the judge’s decision to order specific performance. The allegation that Euro Brokers had acted unconscionably was rejected. Monecor’s late payment did not prevent the court from upholding the share-transfer order.
Significance of the case
The decision illustrates how unanimous shareholder agreement can make an informal corporate procedure effective. Its focus is the shareholders’ actual assent to a particular capital call and the contractual consequences they accepted, rather than a general entitlement to ignore company formalities.