Law Case Summary
Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd and other appeals [2002] UKHL 22
Material increase in the risk of harm as an exception to the “but for” test.
Facts
The three appeals concerned workers who developed malignant mesothelioma after substantial exposure to asbestos during work for different employers. Mr Fairchild and Mr Fox had died; Mr Matthews was seriously ill. The claims included breaches of duties to protect the workers against asbestos exposure. Waddingtons, a defendant in Mr Fairchild’s claim, was an occupier rather than his employer.
The medical evidence accepted in the appeals described a long latency period and uncertainty about whether a single fibre, a few fibres or many fibres initiated the disease. Greater exposure increased the risk, although further exposure did not aggravate mesothelioma once it had begun. Medical science could not identify, even on the balance of probabilities, which period of exposure had caused the disease. This was why the claims had failed in the Court of Appeal.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Issues
Could the claimants recover compensation without proving which defendant’s wrongful exposure to asbestos caused the mesothelioma?
Decision/Outcome
The House of Lords allowed all three appeals. In the special circumstances of these asbestos cases, a defendant’s breach of its protective duty, materially increasing the worker’s risk of mesothelioma, was sufficient to meet the causal requirement. The disease was known to have resulted from workplace asbestos exposure, but the limits of medical science made it impossible to attribute its onset to a particular period of exposure.
The bench deemed that here it would have been inherently unjust to deny the claimants any remedy. The decision did not permit replacement of the “but for” test whenever proof was difficult or its result seemed unfair: the judges emphasised the exceptional circumstances and the need for restraint in extending the principle.
The appeals proceeded on the basis that a liable defendant would answer for the full damages, with contribution available from other liable parties. No argument for apportioning the claimants’ damages between defendants was addressed to the House.
Reported citations: [2003] 1 AC 32; [2003] AC 32; [2002] 3 WLR 89; [2002] 3 All ER 305; [2002] ICR 798; [2002] PIQR P28; (2002) 67 BMLR 90; [2002] Lloyd’s Rep Med 361.
Source: Original House of Lords decision: appeals allowed 16 May 2002, reasons given 20 June 2002.