Case Summaries
The case summaries below were written by our expert writers, as a learning aid to help you with your studies. If you are looking for help with your case summary then we offer a comprehensive writing service provided by fully qualified academics in your field of study.
Case Summaries & Related Services
Elgizouli v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2020] UKSC 10
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the Home Secretary acted unlawfully by agreeing to share investigative material with the United States for the prosecution of Shafee El Sheikh without considering the Data Protection Act 2018. Much of the material was personal data, and the Act required a specific decision that the conditions for transferring it were […]…
Aspen Underwriting Ltd and others v Credit Europe Bank NV [2020] UKSC 11
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the High Court of England and Wales had no jurisdiction over the insurers’ claims against a Dutch bank to recover sums paid under a settlement of a marine hull policy. The bank, as loss payee and beneficiary, was entitled under article 14 of the Brussels Regulation Recast to be sued […]…
MS (Pakistan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2020] UKSC 9
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that an immigration tribunal hearing a human rights appeal against removal must decide for itself whether the person is a victim of trafficking and is not bound by an earlier National Referral Mechanism decision. It restored the Upper Tribunal’s conclusion that removing MS to Pakistan would breach article 4 of the […]…
R v Copeland (AP) (Appellant) [2020] UKSC 8
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A man who made a small quantity of homemade explosive said that he did so only to experiment and to teach himself how explosives worked. The trial judge and the Court of Appeal ruled that this could not be a “lawful object” under section 4(1) of the Explosive Substances Act 1883, so a jury could […]…
Serafin v Malkiewicz and others [2020] UKSC 23
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that a High Court judge’s hostile and intimidatory interventions towards an unrepresented claimant had made a libel trial unfair, so that no findings from it could stand. The Court of Appeal had rightly identified the unfairness but had wrongly treated liability as concluded and limited the case to an assessment of […]…
Fowler v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2020] UKSC 22
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A South African resident diver who worked on the UK Continental Shelf argued that a UK rule treating certain employed divers as if they were carrying on a trade also changed how the UK–South Africa double tax treaty applied to his pay. The Supreme Court disagreed. On the assumption that he was an employee, the […]…
Cardtronics UK Ltd and others v Sykes and others [2020] UKSC 21
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The sites of cash machines in shops raised two distinct business-rates questions. Was a particular site a separate unit of property, and if so, who occupied it? Even where an ATM site could be separately identified, the shops in these appeals retained paramount occupation. The banks did not receive separate assessments. The questions before the […]…
Dill v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government and another [2020] UKSC 20
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that inclusion in the statutory list does not by itself decide whether an object is a “building” under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. An inspector hearing an appeal against refusal of listed building consent or a listed building enforcement notice may consider that question, using the planning […]…
R v Adams (Northern Ireland) [2020] UKSC 19
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that an interim custody order made for the appellant in 1973 was invalid because the Secretary of State had not personally decided that he was suspected of involvement in terrorism. A Minister of State could sign such an order, but could not make it. The appellant had therefore not been in […]…
Duval v 11-13 Randolph Crescent Ltd [2020] UKSC 18
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A landlord promised each flat owner that, if asked and put in funds, it would enforce the covenants in the other flats' leases. The Supreme Court held that the landlord of 11-13 Randolph Crescent could not keep that promise and at the same time license one owner to remove part of a load-bearing wall in […]…
R (on the application of DN (Rwanda)) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2020] UKSC 7
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that DN, a recognised refugee, had been unlawfully detained for deportation. The detention depended on a decision to deport him for a conviction which a 2004 Order treated as a particularly serious crime, and that Order was ultra vires. He may pursue damages for false imprisonment, but the Court did not […]…
Zipvit Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (reference to the Court of Justice) [2020] UKSC 15
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Royal Mail and Zipvit had priced postal services on the mistaken assumption that they were VAT-exempt. Could Zipvit nevertheless deduct VAT as input tax when it had received no invoice charging it? In this 2020 judgment the Supreme Court explained why it needed the Court of Justice to interpret the VAT Directive before it could […]…
WM Morrison Supermarkets plc v Various Claimants [2020] UKSC 12
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that Morrisons was not vicariously liable for a senior auditor who copied staff payroll data and published it online in order to harm the company. The courts below had treated a close link in time and causation, and the supposed irrelevance of motive, as enough to make the employer liable. Lord […]…
Micula and others v Romania [2020] UKSC 5
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In February 2020 the Supreme Court had to decide whether enforcement of an ICSID award against Romania should wait for EU state-aid proceedings. Registration had already taken place in England. The dispute was whether the English court could continue to suspend enforcement and require Romania to give security in the meantime. The investment, the treaty […]…
In the matter of an application by Deborah McGuinness for Judicial Review (Northern Ireland) [2020] UKSC 6
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Michael Stone’s prison authorities treated the years he had spent on licence as counting towards the 30-year tariff of his life sentence. Deborah McGuinness, the sister of one of his victims, successfully challenged that calculation in the High Court, but the Supreme Court did not decide whether she was right. It held that the judicial […]…
AM (Zimbabwe) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2020] UKSC 17
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights may prevent the deportation of a seriously ill person who is not already close to death, where removal would create a real risk of a serious, rapid and irreversible decline in health resulting in intense suffering or a substantial reduction in […]…
Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v XX [2020] UKSC 14
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
After the hospital’s admitted negligence left XX unable to carry a pregnancy, she sought the cost of surrogacy as damages. The Supreme Court considered whether using donor eggs could restore part of what she had lost, and whether English public policy barred an award for commercial arrangements lawful abroad. The hospital admitted errors in reporting […]…
A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland of devolution issues to the Supreme Court pursuant to Paragraph 34 of Schedule 10 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 (Northern Ireland) [2020] UKSC 2
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Department for Communities published postcode lists used to introduce universal credit in Northern Ireland. Could those lists provide the basis for referring a human rights challenge to the Supreme Court? The justices declined to accept the Attorney General’s reference. The constitutional question was whether the Department’s part in implementing the policy brought it within […]…
R (on the application of Palestine Solidarity Campaign Ltd and another) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2020] UKSC 16
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held, by a majority, that the Secretary of State acted unlawfully when he told administrators of the local government pension scheme not to pursue investment policies contrary to UK foreign or defence policy. He could guide how they take non-financial considerations into account. He could not use that power to stop investment […]…
R (on the application of Jalloh (formerly Jollah)) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2020] UKSC 4
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
An eight-hour nightly curfew, enforced by an electronic tag and the threat of prosecution or further immigration detention, was imprisonment at common law. The Supreme Court dismissed the Secretary of State’s appeal and refused to narrow that long-standing concept so that it matched deprivation of liberty under article 5 of the European Convention on Human […]…
R (on the application of Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster) and others) v North Yorkshire County Council [2020] UKSC 3
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When North Yorkshire County Council granted permission for a six-hectare extension of a limestone quarry in the Green Belt, objectors said the planning officer had wrongly left visual impact out of the question whether the development would preserve the Green Belt’s openness. The Supreme Court held that openness in the National Planning Policy Framework is […]…
FMX Food Merchants Import Export Co Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2020] UKSC 1
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Could HMRC collect customs duty on Chinese garlic more than three years after importation? The papers wrongly stated that the garlic came from Cambodia. FMX itself was not implicated in the fraud. Under the Customs Code then in force, the decisive question was whether the debt resulted from an act capable of giving rise to […]…
Attorney General v Crosland (appeal against contempt finding and orders) [2021] UKSC 58
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Can a litigant appeal from one Supreme Court panel to another? The question arose because the Court had itself tried Timothy Crosland for contempt after he disclosed an embargoed judgment. Four justices held that an appeal lay to a fresh panel. Every justice concluded that the challenge failed. Mr Crosland, an unregistered barrister, was a […]…
R (on the application of Elan-Cane) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 56
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Christie Elan-Cane challenged the Home Office’s refusal to issue a passport with an “X” marker. The Supreme Court accepted that non-gendered identity fell within private life under article 8. The question was whether, in 2021, that right required the UK to provide a passport reflecting that identity. Elan-Cane identifies as non-gendered and had repeatedly asked […]…
“Maduro Board” of the Central Bank of Venezuela v “Guaidó Board” of the Central Bank of Venezuela [2021] UKSC 57
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Two rival boards claimed authority over Venezuelan central bank assets in England. The first question was whom the UK Government recognised as Venezuela’s interim President at the relevant time. Its express recognition of Juan Guaidó bound the English courts. A separate question remained about the effect of Venezuelan court judgments invalidating appointments made by him. […]…
In the matter of applications by Margaret McQuillan, Francis McGuigan and Mary McKenna for judicial review (Northern Ireland) [2021] UKSC 55
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The cases concerned two different questions about police investigations into events during the Troubles. Did the Human Rights Act require a further investigation decades later? And was the police decision on a particular allegation lawful? The Supreme Court rejected the claims of a Convention duty but upheld the quashing of one decision on ordinary judicial […]…
Fratila and another v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2021] UKSC 53
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
During the period governed by EU free movement law, did pre-settled status alone entitle an EU citizen to claim universal credit on the same terms as a UK national? Applying the Court of Justice’s ruling in CG, the Supreme Court held that it did not. The claimants had domestic permission to stay but did not […]…
A Local Authority v JB [2021] UKSC 52
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In deciding whether someone has capacity to engage in sexual relations, what must that person be able to understand about a partner’s consent? The Supreme Court held that the partner must be able to consent and must actually consent before and throughout the activity. The assessment therefore had to address both people’s participation. The issue […]…
Alize 1954 and another v Allianz Elementar Versicherungs AG and others [2021] UKSC 51
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed shipowners' appeal and held that their container vessel was unseaworthy under article III rule 1 of the Hague Rules because a defective passage plan caused her to ground on leaving Xiamen. The owners could not rely on the nautical fault exception in article IV rule 2(a), and their crew's failure to […]…
Kabab-Ji SAL (Lebanon) v Kout Food Group (Kuwait) [2021] UKSC 48
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed Kabab-Ji’s appeal and refused enforcement in England of a Paris ICC award against Kout Food Group. English law, chosen to govern the franchise agreements, also governed whether KFG had become a party to the arbitration clause. Clauses requiring signed writing meant there was no real prospect that KFG had joined by […]…
Lloyd v Google LLC [2021] UKSC 50
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Richard Lloyd tried to sue Google on behalf of an estimated class of more than four million iPhone users, alleging that Google had secretly tracked their browsing in 2011 and 2012 and that each person should receive the same sum for loss of control of personal data. The Supreme Court held that the Data […]…
Crown Prosecution Service v Aquila Advisory Ltd [2021] UKSC 49
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Directors of Vantis Tax Ltd obtained a secret profit of £4.55 million by misusing the company’s intellectual property in fraudulent tax schemes, in breach of fiduciary duty, and were convicted of cheating the public revenue. The Supreme Court held that the profit was held on constructive trust for the company, whose rights had passed to […]…
Kostal UK Ltd v Dunkley and others [2021] UKSC 47
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that Kostal UK Ltd could not lawfully offer new pay terms directly to Unite members while the collective bargaining procedure agreed with the union was still continuing. Those offers had the “prohibited result” in section 145B of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. The workers’ appeal was allowed, […]…
R (on the application of Majera (formerly SM (Rwanda))) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 46
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A First-tier Tribunal judge granted immigration bail and did not ban unpaid work. The Home Secretary nevertheless prohibited both paid and unpaid employment. The Supreme Court held that she could not lawfully disregard the tribunal’s order, even if it was defective, without first having it varied or set aside. Mr Majera was detained under immigration […]…
FS Cairo (Nile Plaza) LLC v Lady Brownlie [2021] UKSC 45
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Lady Brownlie was seriously injured, and her husband killed, in a road accident in Egypt on a hotel excursion she had booked from England. By a majority, the Supreme Court held that her tort claims against the Egyptian hotel operator passed the English tort gateway because significant damage was sustained in England, not only at […]…
R (on the application of Association of Independent Meat Suppliers and another) v Food Standards Agency [2021] UKSC 54
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
An official veterinarian refused to certify a slaughtered bull as fit for human consumption because pyaemia was suspected. Without that certification, called a health mark, it would have been a criminal offence for the slaughterhouse operator to try to sell the carcass. Applying answers from the Court of Justice of the European Union, the Supreme […]…
Anwar v The Advocate General for Scotland [2021] UKSC 44
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Ms Anwar had already won her workplace harassment claim. Her difficulty was collecting the award. She argued that EU law required the Scottish employment tribunal itself to be able to preserve assets while a claim was pending, rather than requiring a separate application in another court. The claim This appeal arose from Ms Anwar’s petition […]…
Ho v Adelekun [2021] UKSC 43
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
This 2021 decision interpreted the version of CPR 44.14 then in force. A personal injury defendant owed costs to the claimant but had a larger costs order in her own favour. Could she cancel one against the other when payment of the settlement had produced no court order for damages? Qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS) […]…
X v Kuoni Travel Ltd [2021] UKSC 34
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A package-tour organiser had promised more than flights and a hotel room. The issue was whether its promise also covered ordinary assistance by hotel staff, and whether it could rely on an unforeseeable-event defence when a guest was assaulted during that assistance. The contract and the assault X bought a package holiday from Kuoni which […]…
Test Claimants in the Franked Investment Income Group Litigation v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2021] UKSC 31
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
This stage of the Franked Investment Income litigation concerned how to put right the effects of an earlier UK tax regime on overseas dividends. Recovering tax that should never have been charged is different from compensating a company for paying tax before it was due. That difference mattered both to the available interest remedy and […]…
References on the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and European Charter of Local Self-Government (Incorporation) (Scotland) Bills [2021] UKSC 42
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Scottish Parliament passed two Bills to give domestic effect to international commitments concerning children’s rights and local self-government. Before Royal Assent, the UK law officers referred particular clauses to the Supreme Court. The issue was whether the Scottish Parliament could give those clauses their proposed effect on UK legislation. The references On 16 March […]…
R (on the application of TN (Vietnam)) v Secretary of State for the Home Department and another [2021] UKSC 41
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The rules used to fast-track TN’s asylum appeal were later held to be structurally unfair. Did that invalidate every decision made under them, or did TN have to show how the procedure affected the fairness of her own hearing? TN’s asylum appeal was dismissed by the First-tier Tribunal under the 2005 fast-track rules. She later […]…
Pakistan International Airline Corporation v Times Travel (UK) Ltd [2021] UKSC 40
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Times Travel depended on tickets from an airline entitled to end its agency agreement. When the airline insisted on a waiver of disputed commission, the travel agent faced a severe commercial choice. The question was whether a threat to do something lawful could make the resulting waiver voidable for economic duress. The agency and the […]…
R (on the application of A) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 37
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A police disclosure scheme allowed a person concerned about a child to ask whether someone in contact with the child posed a risk. The Supreme Court considered a challenge to the guidance on consulting the person concerned before a disclosure. Its task was to assess the directions given to officers, rather than to review an […]…
Tinkler v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2021] UKSC 39
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
HMRC posted the notice opening an enquiry into Mr Tinkler’s 2003/04 return to a house he had left, and he never received it. His accountants nevertheless dealt with HMRC for years on the shared assumption that a valid enquiry was under way. The Supreme Court held that he was estopped from denying, after the time […]…
R (on the application of BF (Eritrea)) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 38
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The question was whether Home Office age-assessment guidance, as it stood during the period in issue, directed officers to act unlawfully. A mistake about someone’s age could lead to a child being detained under rules for adults. The Supreme Court distinguished that individual risk from a direction in the policy itself. The facts and the […]…
CPRE Kent v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2021] UKSC 36
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
CPRE Kent’s challenge to a local plan stopped at the permission stage. More than one party had already incurred costs responding. The Supreme Court considered whether each could ordinarily recover reasonable costs of taking the procedural step required to participate. CPRE Kent, a charity seeking to protect the Kent countryside, applied for statutory review under […]…
In the matter of T (A Child) [2021] UKSC 35
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The High Court was asked to authorise restrictions on a child’s liberty when the statutory secure-accommodation route could not provide a suitable placement. The Supreme Court considered whether the inherent jurisdiction could protect a child in that gap, and what limits applied to its use. The appeal concerned children whom a local authority considers must […]…
Royal Mail Group Ltd v Efobi [2021] UKSC 33
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Royal Mail did not call the recruiters who had turned down Mr Efobi’s applications. Could their absence supply the evidence needed to shift the burden of proof in a race discrimination claim? The answer turned on what the tribunal could infer from all the evidence it had. The applications and the appeals Mr Efobi, a […]…
Sanambar v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 30
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Sanambar had lawfully spent most of his childhood in the United Kingdom. The Supreme Court considered how that history affected the proportionality of deportation for serious offences committed while he was under 18. In particular, did the Strasbourg requirement for very serious reasons impose an extra test? Mr Sanambar came to the United Kingdom […]…
Tip: If you can’t find what you are looking for, try shortening your search phrase. E.g. “Salomon”