H Parsons (Livestock) Ltd v Uttley Ingham & Co Ltd [1977] EWCA Civ 13; [1978] QB 791
Court of Appeal, 18 May 1977 — fitness for purpose and remoteness of contractual damages.
A defectively installed feed hopper caused food poisoning in a herd of pigs. The supplier was liable for the resulting losses even though the particular disease and severity of the outbreak had not been anticipated. The majority’s reasoning was that physical injury of that type was a serious possibility if the hopper failed to keep the feed suitable for the pigs.
The defective hopper
Parsons operated an intensive pig farm in Derbyshire. Its herd was of a high grade, and the supplier knew that the hopper was needed to store feed in a condition suitable for those pigs. An earlier hopper had worked successfully, so Parsons ordered a second one in 1971.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The supplier agreed to deliver and install a hopper with a ventilated top. During installation, its employee left the ventilator closed. The defect could not be seen without climbing to the top of the 28-foot structure, and Parsons could not reasonably have been expected to discover it.
Feed stored inside became mouldy. The farmers initially did not consider the mould dangerous, but the pigs later became ill. An outbreak of E. coli infection followed, causing 254 deaths and further losses, including expenses and reduced business. The trial judge found that the inadequate ventilation caused the condition of the food and the resulting outbreak.
The dispute on appeal
Swanwick J held the supplier liable and ordered an inquiry to assess damages. On appeal, the central dispute was whether the losses were too remote. The supplier argued that the parties could not reasonably have contemplated that the mouldy feed would cause the serious illness which occurred.
The trial judge had indeed found that the parties would not reasonably have contemplated a serious possibility of illness from feeding mouldy nuts in the condition described. That finding had to be considered alongside the wider contractual obligation: supplying a hopper fit to keep feed suitable for the particular herd.
Scarman LJ, with whom Orr LJ agreed, treated the arrangement as one contract for the sale and delivery of a suitable hopper, rather than separate sale and installation contracts. The hopper as delivered lacked the promised ventilation and was not reasonably fit for its known purpose. In any event, the contractual analysis did not change the parties’ relevant knowledge.
The majority’s approach to remoteness
The Court had to ask what kind of loss the parties would reasonably have contemplated as a serious possibility when contracting, assuming that they had in mind the breach which actually occurred. They did not have to foresee that the supplier would make the mistake; the assessment assumed the breach and considered its likely consequences.
The correct question was therefore broader than whether mouldy nuts would cause this particular disease. It was whether a hopper unfit to keep the feed suitable for the pigs presented a serious possibility of injury to them. Given the purpose of the equipment and the information provided to the supplier, physical injury was within that contemplation.
The precise disease and full scale of the losses did not have to be anticipated. E. coli was not treated as a different type of harm merely because the outbreak was much more severe than an ordinary digestive upset. Once physical injury of the relevant kind was within contemplation, an unexpectedly serious degree of injury did not make it too remote.
This was not a rule that every consequence of supplying unfit goods was recoverable. Liability for breach of the fitness obligation did not depend on whether the defect could have been discovered, but damages still had to satisfy the rules on remoteness.
Lord Denning’s different reasoning
Lord Denning MR agreed that the appeal should be dismissed but proposed distinguishing physical damage from loss of profits. For physical injury and associated expense, he would apply a foreseeability test similar to that used in tort, including a slight possibility that ought reasonably to have been foreseen at the time of breach.
Orr and Scarman LJJ did not adopt that distinction. Their reasoning applied the contractual test to the type of loss in question. Lord Denning’s proposed division between categories of loss should therefore not be presented as the Court’s shared rule.
Outcome
The supplier’s appeal was dismissed with costs. The order for damages to be assessed remained in place; the Court of Appeal did not fix the final sum payable. The decision demonstrates why identifying the relevant type of damage matters: the unusual mechanism and severity of the harm did not place it outside the consequences contemplated from supplying unsuitable feed-storage equipment.