Pilcher v Rawlins (1872) LR 7 Ch App 259
Court: Court of Appeal in Chancery. Date: 29 January 1872. Judges: Lord Hatherley LC and James and Mellish LJJ.
What the case decided
Mortgagees who acquired the legal estate for value, in good faith and without notice of an earlier trust were protected against the beneficiaries’ equitable claims. They did not lose that protection because proving their legal title later required reliance on concealed deeds which disclosed the trust. The court reversed the Master of the Rolls’ decision giving the earlier mortgage priority.
The trust money and the concealed mortgages
Under an 1830 settlement, trustees held £8,373 for Jeremiah Pilcher during his life and afterwards for children of his former marriage. In 1851 they lent the money to Robert Rawlins on mortgage. The mortgage conveyed land to the trustees as security and disclosed that the advance consisted of trust money. Two trustees later died, leaving W H Pilcher as the surviving trustee.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
In 1856, Rawlins and W H Pilcher arranged a further mortgage of part of the land, the Whitchurch property, to Stockwell and Lamb for £10,000. The title information supplied to the new mortgagees concealed the earlier mortgage.
Before the new mortgage was completed, W H Pilcher reconveyed the Whitchurch property to Rawlins by a separate deed. That deed was also concealed. It nevertheless enabled Rawlins to pass the legal estate to Stockwell and Lamb. The new mortgagees learned of it only after proceedings began. Rawlins and W H Pilcher appeared to have shared the money advanced.
A second part of the dispute concerned another settlement and a mortgage of other property to Ward. W H Pilcher and Rawlins used a purported purchase deed and an incomplete account of the title to conceal earlier trust mortgages. Ward took a mortgage from W H Pilcher without notice of those interests. His title had been accepted by conveyancing counsel.
The competing claims
Jeremiah Pilcher and his children sought to establish the priority of their earlier security and prevent the later mortgagees from relying on the legal estates vested in them. The Master of the Rolls held that the 1851 mortgage had priority. Lamb, Stockwell having died, and Ward appealed.
The later mortgagees relied on the defence of purchase for value without notice. Although they were lenders taking security rather than outright buyers, they had acquired legal estates for valuable consideration. The beneficiaries argued that those estates could only be proved through documents which revealed the trust, so the mortgagees should be treated as having notice of it.
Why the later mortgagees were protected
Lord Hatherley accepted that the concealed reconveyance had restored the legal estate to Rawlins before his mortgage to Stockwell and Lamb. The later mortgagees acquired that estate without notice of the prior charge and were entitled to retain it. Had the original mortgage been disclosed, it would have prompted inquiry into the trust; it had instead been concealed.
James LJ treated acquisition of the legal estate for value without notice as a complete defence to the equitable claim. The court could examine the consideration, the purchaser’s good faith and whether there was notice. Once the purchaser established the defence, equity would not take away the legal advantage honestly acquired in the transaction.
Mellish LJ rejected the proposed extension of constructive notice. The later mortgagees had neither knowledge nor means of knowledge of the hidden documents, and they and their advisers had not been negligent in investigating the title. It was not enough that, if subsequently sued at law, they might need those documents to demonstrate how the legal estate had reached them.
There was no inconsistency in relying on a deed to establish legal title while saying truthfully that its contents had been unknown when the mortgage was taken. Mellish LJ applied this reasoning to both groups of later mortgagees. All three judges agreed that the decree should be reversed.
The significance of legal title
The beneficiaries’ interests were earlier in time, but the later mortgagees had acquired the legal estate for value without notice. The court therefore refused to displace their title in favour of the prior equitable claims. The decision concerned the protection of innocent purchasers against trust interests; it did not excuse the trustee’s fraud or treat mere ignorance as sufficient regardless of the purchaser’s conduct.
Original report: (1872) LR 7 Ch App 259–274.