Legal Case Summary
R v Smith and others [2011] EWCA Crim 66; [2011] 1 Cr App R 30
Unlawfully possessed drugs can be stolen: the robbery convictions stood, but all three prison sentences were reduced.
Facts and background
Michael Smith arranged to meet Chesterfield Jordan to obtain £50 worth of heroin. When Jordan arrived, Andrew Plummer and James Haines emerged from an alleyway. Plummer held a knife to Jordan’s throat and Haines punched him and dragged him to the ground. Jordan handed over the heroin to avoid further violence. Smith, Plummer and Haines then kicked and stamped on him, causing injuries including the loss of teeth.
All three were convicted of robbery and sentenced to eight years’ imprisonment. The indictment had originally referred to the taking of cash, but was amended to refer to drugs worth £50. The defence opposed that amendment, arguing that drugs unlawfully possessed by the complainant could not be stolen. Smith appealed against conviction on that ground; Haines and Plummer sought permission to bring the same challenge out of time. All three also appealed against sentence.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The legal issue
Robbery required a theft. Under section 1 of the Theft Act 1968, theft involves the dishonest appropriation of property belonging to another. The defendants argued that Jordan’s unlawful possession of heroin meant that he had no property rights capable of being appropriated. The Court therefore considered both whether the drugs were “property” under section 4 and whether they “belonged to another” under section 5.
Why unlawful possession did not prevent theft
The Court of Appeal rejected the argument. Section 4 defines property broadly and specifies exceptions and restrictions, including those concerning land and certain wild things. It does not exclude objects merely because possessing them is unlawful. Heroin remained property for the purposes of the Act.
Section 5 also treats property as belonging to anyone who has possession or control of it. The Court declined to add a requirement that this possession or control must be lawful. It relied on the interpretation adopted in R v Turner (No 2) and subsequently approved in R v Kelly. Jordan’s actual possession was sufficient; the prosecution did not need to establish that he could successfully enforce a civil property claim to the drugs.
This distinction answered the defendants’ public-policy argument. Rules which might prevent a wrongdoer from enforcing rights in civil proceedings did not create immunity from theft or robbery. Criminal proceedings protect the peace, and the Court rejected an interpretation which would leave those possessing drugs free to steal from one another with impunity.
Decision and sentence appeals
Smith’s conviction appeal was dismissed, and Haines and Plummer were refused extensions of time to challenge their convictions. Smith’s renewed applications on other grounds also failed. Questions about Jordan’s credibility were for the jury, and the trial judge had properly dealt with potentially prejudicial material from an acquitted co-defendant’s police interview.
The sentence appeals succeeded to a limited extent. The Court treated the robbery as falling within the second level of the applicable sentencing guideline, with significant aggravating features, rather than the higher level. Seven years was the upper end of the appropriate range. Each sentence was therefore reduced from eight years to seven.
The victim’s drug dealing and the relatively small value of the heroin did not mitigate the robbery. The planned attack by three men, the knife and the violence remained serious aggravating features. The decision thus separates the unlawfulness of the victim’s conduct from both the defendants’ criminal liability and the seriousness of their attack.
Judgment: R v Smith and others [2011] EWCA Crim 66, Court of Appeal (Criminal Division), 18 January 2011.