Re Martin and Another’s Application [1988] EWCA Civ 1; 57 P & CR 119
LAND LAW – RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS – DISCHARGE – PLANNING PERMISSION – PRACTICAL BENEFIT
Facts
A local authority and a former owner entered into an agreement under s37 Town and Country Planning Act 1962 requiring part of a garden to remain private open space, with limited exceptions for structures such as a garden shed. The applicants later bought the house and garden. They obtained outline planning permission on appeal to build a house on the restricted plot, but the authority refused to release the covenant. They applied to the Lands Tribunal for its discharge or modification.
Issues
S.84 of the Law of Property Act 1925 gave the Lands Tribunal the discretion to alter or completely discharge restrictive covenants in any of four circumstances. One such circumstance is where the continued existence of the covenant would impede some reasonable user and either is contrary to the public interest or does not secure to persons entitled to the benefit of it any practical benefits of substantial value or advantage to them. In either case, money also had to be adequate compensation for the loss or disadvantage caused by the discharge or modification.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
The issue in this case was the impact of the applicants’ planning permission on the court’s discretion to discharge or modify the covenant on this ground.
Decision/Outcome
The Court of Appeal held that the planning permission and restrictive covenant regimes were separate systems of control. Planning permission was a circumstance the Lands Tribunal should consider, but it did not require the covenant to be discharged.
This had two implications. Firstly, the existence of planning permission does not immunise a landowner from liability for breach of a restrictive covenant binding the land. Secondly, the existence of planning permission is a relevant, but not decisive, factor to consider when determining whether the covenant’s existence is contrary to the public interest.
The Court of Appeal also noted that the definition of ‘practical benefit of substantial value’ did not require the benefit to be an economically-valuable asset. Particularly where the beneficiary of the covenant is a local council (and therefore mainly concerned with public interest), non-economic advantages like avoiding high-density developments can count as a relevant, sufficient practical benefit.
The appeal was dismissed. The Tribunal was entitled to find that the restriction’s purpose of preventing excessive building density could still be achieved, that protection of visual amenity was a substantial practical benefit to the council, and that discharge would injure that benefit. On these facts, money would not adequately compensate for its loss. The refusal to discharge or modify the covenant therefore stood.
Judgment: [1988] EWCA Civ 1. Parallel references: 57 P & CR 119; [1988] 3 PLR 45; [1989] 1 EGLR 193.