Facts
MN and KY claimed asylum on the basis that they came from Somalia and would face persecution there. The Home Secretary refused their claims, relying on reports by the Swedish organisation Sprakab that linked their speech to Kenya. The immigration tribunal dismissed their appeals. On further appeal, the Upper Tribunal treated guidance in RB (Somalia) as effectively foreclosing their criticisms of the reports. The Inner House allowed their appeals, and the Home Secretary appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issue
When may an asylum tribunal admit a linguistic report whose individual analysts are unnamed, and what weight should it give such a report?
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Decision
The Supreme Court held that a tribunal could admit a Sprakab report even if the individual analysts were unnamed. Anonymity required justification and the tribunal had to consider the fairness of the proceedings as a whole. Sprakab was identifiable, the analysts’ qualifications had been disclosed, and their names were available to the tribunal and could be disclosed to the parties if needed.
Lord Carnwath explained that a tribunal must examine a report’s reasoning critically in light of all the evidence. An analyst’s confidence in the conclusion cannot replace that assessment. Opinions about cultural or country knowledge also require a demonstrated basis in relevant expertise. The Upper Tribunal was entitled to treat the procedural guidance in RB as persuasive, but it still had to consider the specific criticisms of each report and the first tribunal’s reasoning.
The Court dismissed both of the Home Secretary’s appeals. MN’s case was remitted to the Upper Tribunal. In KY’s case the Court upheld the order allowing her appeal without remittal, as the Home Secretary had accepted.
Reported citations: 2014 SC (UKSC) 183, 2014 SLT 669, 2014 GWD 17-325, [2014] 1 WLR 2064, [2014] Imm AR 981, [2014] 4 All ER 443, [2014] WLR(D) 227, [2014] INLR 590
Source: Full judgment