Disclaimer: This work was produced by one of our expert legal writers, as a learning aid to help law students with their studies.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of LawTeacher.net. Any information contained in this case summary does not constitute legal advice and should be treated as educational content only.

Varga and Others v Hungary ECLI:CE:ECHR:2015:0310JUD001409712

1,306 words (6 pages) Case Summary

07 Mar 2018 Case Summary Reference this LawTeacher

Jurisdiction / Tag(s): International Law Public law

Varga and Others v Hungary ECLI:CE:ECHR:2015:0310JUD001409712

Prison Overcrowding and the European Convention on Human Rights

European Court of Human Rights, Second Section, 10 March 2015. Application nos. 14097/12, 45135/12, 73712/12, 34001/13, 44055/13 and 64586/13.

Introduction

The issues that arose initially in this judgment related to whether prison overcrowding and poor conditions in which prisoners were held constituted a breach of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights[1] in respect of these conditions amounting to degrading treatment and whether Hungarian national remedies available in respect of addressing potentially degrading treatment of prisoners were sufficient to provide an effective remedy for these individuals as required by Article 13 ECHR.

Law Teacher writing support

Writing a law essay?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.

Facts

Mr Varga and a number of other connected applicants[2] were all current or former prisoners within Hungary. During the course of their imprisonment, they were held with other prisoners in cells of varying sizes, often providing less than 3 square metres of gross living space per prisoner.[3] Furthermore, in some of the cells privacy was extremely limited because toilet facilities were within the cell and separated only by a curtain.[4] In addition, Mr Fako asserted that he was only permitted to shower once a week, that the temperature within the cell often rose to 40 degrees centigrade and that the cell was infested with bed bugs, lice and cockroaches.[5] The applicants also asserted that they were permitted very little opportunity to leave their cell for exercise.[6]

National Law

National law was important in this judgment in relation to the application under Article 13 ECHR and provided that, in the first instance, a prisoner who wished to raise concerns regarding the manner of his treatment should refer the complaint either orally or in writing to the head of the prison where he was being held.[7] Additionally, inmates could refer the matter to the public prosecutor in charge of their supervision.[8] Most importantly in this context, the legislation addressed the size of living space each prisoner should have, but the wording in force at the material time required the stated minimum only “in so far as possible”[9] and provided the public prosecutor with powers to rectify any issues that may arise.[10] It was also relevant that under the Civil Code in force at the relevant time, an individual was able to seek compensation from the Government in respect of any infringement of personal rights if they were considered to have caused the individual to suffer damage.[11]

Article 3 ECHR

The Hungarian Government contested the applicants’ assertion that their detention amounted to degrading treatment under Article 3 ECHR.[12] The judgment does not specifically set out any arguments put forward by the Hungarian Government in this respect, save to state that the Government did not dispute the cell dimensions and occupancy figures and did not provide evidence refuting the other alleged conditions.[13] What the judgment does do, is deal with the general principle under which a breach of Article 3 will occur specifically highlighting that the absence of any one of three safeguards—an individual sleeping place, at least 3 square metres of floor space, or sufficient room to move freely between furniture—created a strong presumption of a violation of Article 3.[14] The judgment also stressed the impact of the cumulative effect of the conditions in which a prisoner is held. The presumption could be rebutted by alleviating circumstances, and the duration of detention and the wider prison regime also mattered.[15]

Following these general principles, the Court had little difficulty in finding that the treatment of all of the applicants fell short of the standards required by the Article and as such, found that in the case of all of the applicants the Hungarian Government’s treatment of them constituted a violation of Article 3.

Article 13 ECHR

In dealing with the asserted violation of Article 13, the Court began by setting out the general position in Article 35 ECHR that applicants must exhaust available and effective domestic remedies before bringing the matter before the Court.[16] The Hungarian Government put forward two arguments in respect of asserting that no violation of the Article had occurred.

Damages

In the first instance, the Government asserted that the availability of compensation within the relevant Civil Code provided the applicants with an effective remedy in respect of any harm that they may have suffered.[17] Despite the Government citing authority for when such a remedy had been effective,[18] the Court did not accept that this single example demonstrated a practice that was sufficiently settled to provide an effective remedy.[19] Indeed, it was pointed out that domestic law had previously been held to only provide for a desirable outcome rather than a binding obligation.[20]

Formal Complaints

The Hungarian Government went on to assert that the formal complaints procedure described above, provided sufficient redress to individuals. The court acknowledged that this was theoretically the case, in that individual prisoners could obtain an injunction from the public prosecutor requiring their conditions to be materially improved,[21] but found that this approach would be practically ineffective. This was because, in an already overcrowded prison system, the rectification of individual issues would impact detrimentally on other inmates and ultimately, it would be impossible for the Government to deal with numerous complaints because of the nature of the overcrowding problem itself.[22] In addition, the Court found that the Government’s failure to demonstrate how the complaints procedure on an individual level could be effective, meant that there was a violation of Article 13 read in conjunction with Article 3. The Government’s objection that the applicants had failed to exhaust domestic remedies was rejected.[23]

Article 46

In the light of the nature of the issues raised by the violations, the court found it necessary to instruct the Hungarian Government to put in place measures to rectify the general prison overcrowding problem and provide proper redress to prisoners.[24] Within six months of the judgment becoming final, the Government was required to produce, under the supervision of the Committee of Ministers, a timetable for introducing preventive and compensatory remedies. This was a deadline for producing the timetable, rather than for completing every reform.[25]

Article 41

The Court awarded non-pecuniary damages and costs for the Article 3 violations. The finding of an Article 13 violation was itself sufficient just satisfaction for that violation.[26]

Discussion

Little discussion is required in respect of the substantive violation of Articles 3 and 13 here, the facts being sufficiently clear to demonstrate the reason for the violation. It is of note in respect of Article 13 however, that some degree of remedy is not sufficient to meet the requirements of the Article if it is not effective in practice as well as in law. A favourable outcome need not be certain, and a combination of remedies may suffice. What is most interesting in this judgment however, is the approach taken by the Court under Article 46. In this respect, it was made clear that an individual approach would not be satisfactory and the Government must take steps to address the overcrowding problem as a whole. The Court identified reducing prisoner numbers through greater use of non-custodial measures and less pre-trial detention as the most appropriate response to overcrowding. Separately, it noted that an express and measurable sentence reduction could, under appropriate conditions, compensate for poor detention conditions; it did not prescribe sentence reduction as the only effective solution.[27] The pilot judgment required action on the structural problem, while leaving the State a choice of Convention-compliant means under the supervision of the Committee of Ministers.

Footnotes

[1] ECHR

[2] Mr Lakatos, Mr Tóth, Mr Pesti, Mr Fakó and Mr Kapczár

[3] Paragraphs [7] – [12]

[4] Ibid

[5] Paragraph [11]

[6] Op cit at n 3

[7] Decree no 6/1996 (VII 12) of the Minister of Justice on the Rules Governing the Enforcement of Imprisonment and Pre-trial Detention, s 6

[8] Ibid, s 7

[9] Ibid, s 137

[10] Act no CLXIII of 2011 on the Public Prosecution Service, s 22

[11] Act no IV of 1959 on the [Old] Civil Code, s 84

[12] Paragraph [67]

[13] Paragraph [79]

[14] Paragraph [74]

[15] Paragraph [72]

[16] Paragraph [44]

[17] Paragraph [51]

[18] Ibid

[19] Paragraph [53]

[20] Paragraph [54]

[21] Paragraph [62]

[22] Paragraph [63]

[23] Paragraphs [64] & [65]

[24] Paragraph [106]

[25] Paragraph [113]

[26] Paragraphs [118] – [125]

[27] Paragraphs [104]–[110]

Full judgment

LawTeacher

LawTeacher

LawTeacher.net is the UK’s leading provider of academic legal support, offering both writing services and an extensive collection of law study resources for students in the UK and overseas.

Founded in 2003 by Grey’s Inn graduate Barclay Littlewood, the Company was built on a commitment to excellence, with unique guarantees and a high standard of service from day one.

The team includes over 500 UK legally qualified writing experts, with many practising solicitors and barristers, and several former lecturers.

Areas of Legal Expertise

Contract Law Criminal Law Constitutional and Administrative Law EU Law Tort Law Property Law Equity and Trusts Jurisprudence Company Law Commercial Law Family Law Human Rights Law Employment Law Evidence Public International Law Legal Research and Methods Dispute Resolution Business Law and Practice Civil Litigation Criminal Litigation Professional Conduct Taxation Wills and Administration of Estates Solicitors’ Accounts

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Related Services

View all

Related Content

Jurisdictions / Tags

Content relating to: “International Law”

International law, also known as public international law and the law of nations, is the set of rules, norms, and standards generally accepted in relations between nations. International law is studied as a distinctive part of the general structure of international relations.

Related Articles

Prices from

£ 99

Estimated costs for: Undergraduate 2:2 • 1000 words • 7 day delivery

Place an order

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report