Case Summaries
The case summaries below were written by our expert writers, as a learning aid to help you with your studies. If you are looking for help with your case summary then we offer a comprehensive writing service provided by fully qualified academics in your field of study.
Case Summaries & Related Services
Moreno v The Motor Insurers’ Bureau [2016] UKSC 52
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A UK resident injured on holiday in Greece could seek compensation at home through the Motor Insurers’ Bureau. Did that also entitle her to have her compensation assessed under English law? The Supreme Court held that Greek law governed the Bureau’s liability. Where Ms Moreno could bring her claim and which law fixed the extent […]…
R v Guraj [2016] UKSC 65
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court restored a confiscation order of ÂŁ57,458 against Lodvik Guraj after the Court of Appeal had quashed it for procedural error. The sentencing judge had made forfeiture and deprivation orders too soon, and the Crown had then lost track of the confiscation proceedings for about a year. Those mistakes did not remove the […]…
Habib Khan v General Pharmaceutical Council [2016] UKSC 64
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A review of a professional suspension cannot extend it merely because the original panel thought the longest period it could impose was too short to reflect the gravity of the misconduct. The Supreme Court so held where a Glasgow pharmacist, Habib Khan, had been removed from the register after convictions arising from domestic violence. It […]…
R (Mirza, Iqbal and Ehsan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 63
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Section 3C of the Immigration Act 1971 can continue a person's limited leave to remain if an application to vary that leave is made before it expires. In these three appeals the applications were made in time but were rejected as invalid: two because the fee had not been paid, and one because biometric information […]…
Hesham Ali v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 60
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court explained how article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights applies when a non-British citizen sentenced to at least 12 months’ imprisonment faces deportation. A tribunal must decide for itself whether removal is proportionate, but it must give considerable weight to Parliament’s and the Home Secretary’s view that the public interest […]…
MB v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2016] UKSC 53
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
MB, registered male at birth, had lived as a woman and undergone gender reassignment surgery, but remained married. She was refused a state retirement pension at 60 because, without ending that marriage, she could not obtain a full gender recognition certificate and was still treated as a man for pensionable age. The Supreme Court was […]…
Hastings Borough Council v Manolete Partners Plc [2016] UKSC 50
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In June 2006 Hastings Borough Council used an emergency power to close much of Hastings Pier after engineers warned that crowd-loading might cause a collapse. Stylus Sports Ltd, which ran a bingo hall and an amusement arcade near the entrance, claimed compensation for the business lost during that closure. The Supreme Court held that Stylus […]…
R v Golds (Supreme Court) [2016] UKSC 61
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed Mark Golds’s appeal against his conviction for murdering his partner. He had admitted the killing, and the only issue was whether diminished responsibility reduced the offence to manslaughter because an abnormality of mental functioning substantially impaired specified abilities. The Court held that “substantially” requires an impairment of real weight or importance, […]…
The Christian Institute and others v The Lord Advocate [2016] UKSC 51
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The UK Supreme Court held that the information-sharing provisions of Scotland’s named person scheme were outside the Scottish Parliament’s legislative competence. Part 4 of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 required public bodies to share information about a child’s wellbeing with a named person. Those provisions interfered with the article 8 rights of […]…
R v Docherty [2016] UKSC 62
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Shaun Docherty was sentenced to imprisonment for public protection for serious knife attacks after that sentence had begun to be abolished. He argued that transitional provisions keeping it available for offenders convicted before the commencement date were unlawful under the European Convention on Human Rights and beyond the power conferred by the reforming statute. The […]…
Willers v Joyce and another (No 1) [2016] UKSC 43
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held by a majority that the tort of malicious prosecution can apply to civil proceedings. Mr Willers alleged that a company controlled by Mr Gubay had sued him maliciously and without reasonable cause, causing damage to his reputation, health and earnings and leaving a large shortfall in his legal costs. The claim, […]…
Makhlouf v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 59
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed Mr Makhlouf’s appeal against a decision to deport him following convictions for violence and later offences. Although the best interests of his two children had to be treated as a primary consideration, the Secretary of State already had enough material to assess his article 8 claim and theirs. She was not […]…
Amoena (UK) Limited v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2016] UKSC 41
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that a mastectomy bra designed to hold an artificial breast form in place is an accessory to that form for EU customs classification. It is therefore classified with the breast form under heading 9021 of the Combined Nomenclature and attracts no duty, rather than as a brassière under chapter 62 at […]…
Impact Funding Solutions Limited v AIG Europe Insurance Ltd (formerly known as Chartis Insurance (UK) Ltd) [2016] UKSC 57
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Impact Funding arranged loans to clients of the solicitors Barrington so that disbursements in industrial deafness claims could be paid. Barrington broke its warranty to perform its professional duties, the loans went unpaid, and Impact obtained damages; Barrington was insolvent. The Supreme Court held by a majority that Barrington's professional indemnity insurer need not meet […]…
Secretary of State for the Home Department v Franco Vomero [2016] UKSC 49
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Home Secretary decided in 2007 to deport Franco Vomero, an Italian citizen, after he had served a prison sentence for manslaughter. The Supreme Court held that he had not acquired an EU right of permanent residence before that decision, but it did not decide whether he could still claim the strongest protection against expulsion […]…
Edwards v Kumarasamy [2016] UKSC 40
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Edwards tripped on an uneven paving stone outside his block of flats and sued his landlord for breach of the repairing covenant implied by section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. The Supreme Court held that the landlord was not liable: the paved area was not part of the exterior of the […]…
R (Carmichael, Daly, A and Rutherford) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2016] UKSC 58
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the housing benefit under-occupation rules unlawfully discriminated against Mrs Carmichael, who could not share a bedroom with her husband because of disability, and against the Rutherford family, whose disabled grandson needed an overnight carer. Those cases were not reasonably distinguishable from situations the regulations already exempted. The rules did not […]…
Hayward v Zurich Insurance Company plc [2016] UKSC 48
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Zurich settled Mr Colin Hayward's personal injury claim for ÂŁ134,973.11 while suspecting that he had exaggerated his back injury, but without knowing the full extent of the exaggeration. After neighbours later gave evidence of fraud, the Supreme Court held that the settlement could be set aside even though Zurich had not believed his account. His […]…
R (Public Law Project) v Lord Chancellor [2016] UKSC 39
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the Lord Chancellor could not introduce a residence test for civil legal aid by a statutory instrument amending the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012. The draft order would have removed most civil legal aid from people who failed lawful-residence conditions. That was not a power to […]…
Campbell v Gordon [2016] UKSC 38
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Campbell, an apprentice joiner, was injured by an electric circular saw. His employer's insurance excluded electrically powered woodworking machinery, the company later went into liquidation, and he sued its sole director for the failure to insure. By a majority, the Supreme Court held that the Employers' Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 may impose criminal […]…
R (Johnson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 56
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that it was incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights to treat the appellant as liable to automatic deportation because he lacked British citizenship solely on the ground that his British father and Jamaican mother had never married. He was not responsible for their marital status or for having been […]…
R (Ismail) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 37
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the Home Secretary's proposed service of an Egyptian criminal judgment on Mr Ismail under the Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 did not engage his article 6 rights. Service was a formal administrative step, distinct from enforcement, and did not directly expose him to a breach of fair-trial guarantees, even though […]…
Goluchowski and Sas v Polish judicial authorities [2016] UKSC 36
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed appeals by two men whose surrender to Poland was sought under European arrest warrants so that they could serve prison sentences. The warrants did not set out later Polish summonses or domestic arrest warrants or, in some cases, the decisions which activated a suspended sentence or revoked conditional release. The Court […]…
R v Mitchell (Northern Ireland) [2016] UKSC 55
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When the prosecution relies on a defendant's earlier misconduct to show a propensity to behave in a particular way, the jury must be sure that the propensity itself has been proved. It need not, however, decide each past allegation in isolation and find every one proved beyond reasonable doubt. Angeline Mitchell's conviction for murder was […]…
Lee-Hirons v Secretary of State for Justice [2016] UKSC 46
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court considered what explanation must be given when the Secretary of State recalls a conditionally discharged restricted patient to hospital. Telling Mr Lee-Hirons only that his mental health had deteriorated was legally sufficient at the moment of recall. Later conceded failures to give a fuller explanation within three days, and in writing, breached […]…
R (Ingenious Media Holdings plc and another) v HMRC [2016] UKSC 54
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A senior HMRC official gave Times journalists an “off the record” briefing about tax avoidance and discussed the tax affairs of Patrick McKenna and Ingenious Media, who had promoted film investment schemes. The Supreme Court held that this breached HMRC’s statutory duty of confidentiality. Officials may disclose taxpayer information only so far as is reasonably […]…
Bailey and another v Angove’s PTY Limited [2016] UKSC 47
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that an Australian wine producer effectively ended its insolvent English agent’s authority to collect unpaid customer invoices and was entitled to the proceeds. That authority was not irrevocable merely because the agent could deduct commission, and the money was not held on a constructive trust. The agency and the insolvency Angove’s […]…
R (on the application of Bancoult (No 2)) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2016] UKSC 35
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In 2008 the House of Lords, by a majority, upheld a 2004 Order removing any right of abode in the British Indian Ocean Territory, relying on a 2002 study which said that long-term resettlement of the outer Chagos Islands was likely to be prohibitively expensive. Mr Bancoult later asked the Supreme Court to set that […]…
In the matter of D (A Child) [2016] UKSC 34
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court struck out a father's appeal against the Court of Appeal's refusal to enforce a Romanian custody order in England. Under the Brussels II Revised Regulation, the United Kingdom had notified only one further challenge: a single appeal on a point of law to the Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court therefore had […]…
Versloot Dredging BV and another v HDI Gerling Industrie Versicherung AG and others [2016] UKSC 45
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that an insurer cannot refuse a valid claim merely because the insured told a collateral lie that made no difference to the right to recover. The owners of the DC Merwestone had a good claim for engine damage caused by seawater ingress, despite a manager’s reckless falsehood about a bilge alarm […]…
Willers v Joyce and another (No 2) [2016] UKSC 44
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
An English judge faced a House of Lords decision which required a claim to be struck out and a later Privy Council decision whose reasoning pointed the other way. The Supreme Court held that a decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council is not binding in England and Wales and cannot displace a […]…
MS (Uganda) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 33
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
MS, a Ugandan citizen with limited student leave, was refused asylum while about eleven weeks of that leave remained. The Supreme Court decided when section 83 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 gave a separate appeal against refusal of an asylum claim. It held that the right arose only if, counting from the […]…
MP (Sri Lanka) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 32
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court considered whether a Sri Lankan national whose severe mental illness resulted from past torture by the authorities was entitled to subsidiary protection under the EU Qualification Directive on return, despite no continuing risk of ill-treatment. The Upper Tribunal and Court of Appeal had rejected that claim while allowing his appeal under article […]…
Taiwo v Olaigbe and Onu v Akwiwu [2016] UKSC 31
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that mistreating migrant domestic workers because their immigration status made them vulnerable is not, without more, discrimination because of nationality. Ms Taiwo and Ms Onu, both Nigerian domestic workers, had been exploited by their employers, but the reason was their precarious immigration position, not the fact that they were Nigerian. Their […]…
Brown and another, the Joint Administrators of Loanwell Limited v Stonegale Limited [2016] UKSC 30
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal concerning four Glasgow properties transferred by companies which later entered administration. Stonegale Ltd and Norman Ralph Pelosi received the properties but paid nothing. A sum paid to the bank was the price of a different property, used to obtain the release of securities, and was not consideration for these […]…
In the matter of an application by JR55 for Judicial Review (Northern Ireland) [2016] UKSC 22
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A general practitioner refused to pay ÂŁ10,000 which the Northern Ireland Commissioner for Complaints had recommended to the widow of a patient who died of a heart attack. The Supreme Court dismissed the Commissioner's appeal. He could not properly make that recommendation, or threaten a special report to the Assembly, where the widow had sought […]…
PMS International Group Plc v Magmatic Limited [2016] UKSC 12
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed Magmatic’s appeal and upheld the conclusion that PMS’s Kiddee Case did not infringe Magmatic’s Community registered design for the Trunki ride-on suitcase. The monochrome computer-aided images did not claim a shape alone: they created the overall impression of a horned animal, with the strap, strips, wheels and spokes in a contrasting […]…
Cox v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 10
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A prisoner working in the kitchen at HM Prison Swansea negligently dropped a sack of rice onto the catering manager, Mrs Cox, and injured her. The Supreme Court held that the prison service was vicariously liable, and dismissed the Ministry of Justice’s appeal, even though the prisoner was not an employee and was paid only […]…
Airtours Holidays Transport Limited v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2016] UKSC 21
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Airtours paid VAT on accountants' fees for a report commissioned so that its lenders could assess restructuring proposals and continued facilities. The Supreme Court held by a majority that the services were supplied to the lenders rather than to Airtours, so the VAT could not be reclaimed as input tax. The dispute In October 2002 […]…
BNY Mellon Corporate Trustee Services Limited v LBG Capital No 1 Plc and another [2016] UKSC 29
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided whether Lloyds Banking Group could redeem early ÂŁ3.3 billion of enhanced capital notes carrying interest of more than 10 per cent a year. The notes, issued in 2009, were redeemable if regulatory changes meant they ceased to be taken into account in a stress test of the bank’s core capital ratio. […]…
McDonald v McDonald and others [2016] UKSC 28
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Fiona McDonald faced a possession claim for the home her parents had bought for her and let to her on an assured shorthold tenancy. She argued that the court, as a public authority, had to consider whether eviction would be a disproportionate interference with her right to respect for her home. The Supreme Court held […]…
NYK Bulkship (Atlantic) NV v Cargill International SA [2016] UKSC 20
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Global Santosh was arrested in Nigeria in support of a demurrage claim between parties below the time charter, in a dispute that had nothing to do with the owners. The owners contended that hire continued because the arrest was occasioned by the time charterers’ agents. The Supreme Court held by a majority that it […]…
Knauer v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 9
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided that, when damages are assessed for financial dependency after a wrongful death, the multiplier for future losses should be taken from the date of trial rather than the date of death. Calculating it from death discounts the award for money the dependant has not yet received and therefore under-compensates. The Court […]…
Shop Direct Group v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2016] UKSC 7
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Shop Direct Group received ÂŁ124,963,600 of overpaid VAT after the trades which had generated the overpayments had permanently ceased. The Supreme Court held that section 103 of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 charges such post-cessation receipts on the recipient, and is not limited to the company which originally carried on the trade. On […]…
McBride v Scottish Police Authority [2016] UKSC 27
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A fingerprint officer who had been kept off court work after a disputed identification was unfairly dismissed when she would not move to another role. The Employment Tribunal ordered her reinstatement, but the Inner House treated that order as an unlawful change to her contract. The Supreme Court held that the tribunal had restored the […]…
PJS v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2016] UKSC 26
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court continued, until trial, an interim injunction stopping the Sun on Sunday from identifying PJS, an entertainer, and publishing details of sexual encounters he had had with another couple. The story had already appeared abroad and online, but the majority held that unrestricted newspaper coverage in England and Wales would be a further […]…
R (O) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 19
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
O, a Nigerian woman with serious mental ill-health, was held at Yarl’s Wood for nearly three years while the Home Secretary pursued her deportation. The Supreme Court held that a failure to apply the published policy on detaining mentally ill people can make that detention unlawful, even where the statute says the person “shall” be […]…
Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP [2016] UKSC 6
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Miss Kennedy, a home carer, slipped on snow and ice while walking to a client’s house and injured her wrist. The UK Supreme Court held that her employer had failed to make a suitable assessment of that known risk and to provide anti-slip attachments, and was liable under the Personal Protective Equipment at Work Regulations […]…
Asset Land Investment Plc and another v The Financial Conduct Authority [2016] UKSC 17
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal by Asset Land Investment plc and its principal director, Mr Banner-Eve, and held that their plot sales were a collective investment scheme under section 235 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. Buyers took title to individual plots, but the arrangements were that the company would seek to […]…
The Mayor’s Office for Policing and Crime v Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Co (Europe) Ltd and others [2016] UKSC 18
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
During the August 2011 riots, a fire started by rioters destroyed the Sony DADC warehouse in Enfield and the stock and equipment inside it. Insurers and businesses claimed compensation from the police authority under the Riot (Damages) Act 1886, including for consequential losses such as lost rent and lost profits. The Supreme Court held that […]…
Tip: If you can’t find what you are looking for, try shortening your search phrase. E.g. “Salomon”