Case Summaries
The case summaries below were written by our expert writers, as a learning aid to help you with your studies. If you are looking for help with your case summary then we offer a comprehensive writing service provided by fully qualified academics in your field of study.
Case Summaries & Related Services
AXA Insurance UK PLC and another v Commissioners of Inland Revenue and another [2026] UKSC 24
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
AXA group companies, follower claimants in tax group litigation, sought to rely on a Prudential test case decision later shown to be legally wrong. The Supreme Court held that courts may, exceptionally, order that such a decision does not bind follower claims, and dismissed the appeals. Background The appeal concerned the Controlled Foreign Companies and […]…
Great Asia Maritime Limited v Orion Shipping and Trading LLC [2026] UKSC 23
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Sellers of a ship under the Norwegian Saleform 2012 negligently failed to be ready for delivery, and the buyers cancelled. The Supreme Court held that clause 14 entitles buyers to loss of bargain damages even without a repudiatory breach. Background The appeal concerned the interpretation of clause 14 of the 2012 Norwegian Saleform (NSF), described […]…
R v McCafferty and others [2026] UKSC 20
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Animal Rebellion protesters blocked a private industrial-estate road outside Müller's dairy and were charged with statutory public nuisance under the obstruction limb only. The Supreme Court held that there is no public right over private ways. A mere licence is not a public ‘right’, so the defendants were acquitted. Background Section 78 of the Police, […]…
Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v HFFX LLP [2026] UKSC 17
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Partners in a forex trading LLP deferred part of their profits through a discretionary corporate-member scheme, hoping to pay corporation tax rather than income tax. The Supreme Court held that section 850 ITTOIA did not apply. However, the deferred receipts were taxable as income from a ‘source’ under section 687. Background HFFX LLP was a […]…
A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland of a devolution issue under paragraph 34 of Schedule 10 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 [2026] UKSC 16
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
The Attorney General for Northern Ireland asked whether a revised code could treat adults lacking mental capacity as consenting to their care through positive wishes and feelings. The Supreme Court overruled Cheshire West's 'acid test', restored a multifactorial approach and held the Code lawful. Background The Attorney General for Northern Ireland referred a devolution issue […]…
X and Y (Children: Adoption Order: Setting Aside), Re [2026] UKSC 13
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
An adoptive mother, supported by her adopted daughters and their natural mother, sought revocation of valid adoption orders after the adoption broke down. The Supreme Court held that the High Court has no inherent (parens patriae) jurisdiction to revoke a validly made adoption order. Background X and Y, then aged five and four, were placed […]…
The Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.À.R.L. and another [2026] UKSC 9
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Spain and Zimbabwe, facing ICSID investment arbitration awards, sought to set aside their registration in the High Court on grounds of state immunity. The Supreme Court held that article 54(1) of the ICSID Convention constitutes a clear submission to jurisdiction under section 2(2) of the State Immunity Act 1978. Background These conjoined appeals concerned whether […]…
In the matter of the applications by Martina Dillon, John McEvoy, Brigid Hughes and Lynda McManus for judicial review (Nos 1 and 2) [2026] UKSC 15
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Troubles victims challenged the Legacy Act 2023. The Supreme Court held that the Windsor Framework did not require courts to disapply the Act's immunity provisions. It also rejected the abstract finding that the ICRIR could never lawfully replace inquests, while unappealed incompatibility declarations stood. Background The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 replaced […]…
Skatteforvaltningen (The Danish Customs and Tax Administration) v MCML Ltd (previously known as ED&F Man Capital Markets Ltd) [2026] UKSC 19
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
SKAT's 2018 negligent misrepresentation claim against broker EDFM failed under the Revenue Rule. SKAT later sued EDFM for fraud. The Supreme Court held that no issue estoppel barred the fraud claim, because issue estoppel is narrowly confined to the immediate foundation of the earlier decision. Background SKAT, the Danish Customs and Tax Administration, paid refunds […]…
Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v BlueCrest Capital Management (UK) LLP [2026] UKSC 18
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
HMRC treated most members of BlueCrest, a hedge fund management LLP, as salaried members taxable as employees. The Supreme Court held that only influence derived from members' legally enforceable rights and duties counts under Condition B. It also held that profit-related bonuses based on personal performance are 'disguised salary' under Condition A. Background The appeal […]…
Gatwick Investment Ltd and others v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE; Bath Racecourse Company Ltd and others v Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE and others [2026] UKSC 14
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Hotel and racecourse operators claimed Covid-19 business interruption losses. The Supreme Court held that furlough payments under the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme 'reduced' their employment costs in consequence of the insured peril, so must be deducted under the policies' savings clauses. Background These conjoined appeals concerned the effect of payments made under the Coronavirus Job […]…
Orsted West of Duddon Sands (UK) Limited (now named Orsted Schroders Greencoat WODS Holdco Limited) and others v Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2026] UKSC 12
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Orsted claimed capital allowances for the cost of environmental, metocean, geophysical and geotechnical studies used to design offshore windfarms. The Supreme Court held that such studies were not expenditure 'on the provision of plant', because the phrase requires a close connection between the expenditure and the plant itself. Background The respondents, members of the Orsted […]…
Kession Capital Ltd (in Liquidation) v KVB Consultants Ltd and others [2026] UKSC 11
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Kession, an authorised firm restricted to professional clients, appointed JHM as its appointed representative on terms excluding retail clients. JHM sold failed property schemes to investors who claimed to be retail clients. The Supreme Court held that Kession was not responsible under section 39(3) FSMA for JHM's retail dealings. Background This appeal concerned the appointed […]…
R v ABJ; R v BDN [2026] UKSC 8
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Two protesters faced charges under section 12(1A) of the Terrorism Act 2000 for speeches allegedly supporting Hamas. The Supreme Court held the offence compatible with article 10. It set out the offence's seven ingredients and ruled that juries need not conduct a separate proportionality assessment. Background These conjoined appeals arose from preparatory hearings in two […]…
Boyd v Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland [2026] UKSC 7
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Boyd was sentenced for criminal damage without a compensation order; nearly two years later a District Judge added one under article 158A. The Supreme Court held the power covers the whole sentencing package and permits additions, but the delay was fatal. Background This appeal concerned the scope of the power of a District Judge […]…
THG Plc v Zedra Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2026] UKSC 6
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Zedra, a minority shareholder in THG plc, sought to add an unfair prejudice complaint about a 2016 bonus share issue more than six years later. By a 4–1 majority, the Supreme Court held that sections 8 and 9 of the Limitation Act 1980 do not apply to section 994 petitions, so no statutory limitation period […]…
CCC v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2026] UKSC 5
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
A girl suffered catastrophic brain injury at birth through admitted NHS negligence, reducing her life expectancy to 29. The Supreme Court, by a majority, overruled Croke v Wiseman, holding that young children can recover damages for pecuniary losses during the 'lost years'. Background The claimant, CCC, suffered a severe hypoxic brain injury during her birth […]…
Dairy UK Ltd v Oatly AB [2026] UKSC 4
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Oatly registered POST MILK GENERATION as a trade mark for oat-based foods and drinks. The Supreme Court held it invalid because 'designation' in the 2013 Regulation covers any use of 'milk' for non-dairy products, not merely naming them, and the characteristic-quality exception did not apply. Background Oatly AB, a Swedish manufacturer of oat-based alternatives to […]…
Emotional Perception AI Limited v Comptroller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks [2026] UKSC 3
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Emotional Perception sought to patent an artificial neural network system recommending media files by emotional similarity. The Supreme Court held that an ANN is a computer program, but abandoned the Aerotel test in favour of the EPO's G1/19 'any hardware' approach. The claims were therefore not excluded, and the application returns to the Hearing Officer. […]…
R (on the application of Jwanczuk) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2025] UKSC 42
Example case summary. Last modified: November 4, 2026
Mr Jwanczuk was refused a bereavement support payment because his severely disabled late wife had never paid national insurance contributions. The Supreme Court held that the contribution condition was justified, not discriminatory, and that appellate courts need not follow cross-jurisdictional decisions they consider wrong. Background Bereavement Support Payment (BSP), introduced by the Pensions Act 2014, […]…
Candey Ltd v Crumpler & Anor, Re Peak Hotels and Resorts Ltd [2022] UKSC 35
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Candey Ltd, solicitors for Peak Hotels and Resorts Ltd, claimed an equitable lien over litigation settlement proceeds. The Supreme Court held Candey had waived the lien by entering into a new fixed fee agreement and deed of charge without expressly reserving it, as the new security arrangements were inconsistent with the lien’s continuation. Background Candey […]…
Stanford International Bank Ltd v HSBC Bank PLC [2022] UKSC 34
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
SIB, a company operating a Ponzi scheme now in liquidation, claimed HSBC breached its Quincecare duty by paying £116m to investors from SIB’s accounts. The court assumed a breach for the purposes of the appeal. It held that SIB suffered no recoverable loss because the payments discharged equivalent liabilities, leaving its net asset position unchanged. […]…
DB Symmetry Ltd & Anor v Swindon Borough Council [2022] UKSC 33
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Swindon Borough Council argued that planning condition 39 required a developer to dedicate access roads as public highways. The Supreme Court held that a planning condition cannot lawfully require dedication of land as a public highway without compensation, and that condition 39 addressed only road construction standards, not dedication. Background The development site formed part […]…
Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland (Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Bill) [2022] UKSC 32
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Attorney General for Northern Ireland referred the Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Bill to the Supreme Court, questioning whether criminalising acts intended to influence persons near abortion clinics without a reasonable excuse defence was a disproportionate interference with Convention rights. The Court unanimously held the provision was within the Assembly’s legislative competence. Background The […]…
Reference by the Lord Advocate of devolution issues under the Scotland Act 1998 [2022] UKSC 31
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Lord Advocate referred the question whether a proposed Scottish Independence Referendum Bill related to reserved matters under the Scotland Act 1998. The Supreme Court unanimously held that such a Bill did relate to the reserved matters of the Union and the UK Parliament, meaning the Scottish Parliament lacked legislative competence to enact it. Background […]…
Hillside Parks Ltd v Snowdonia National Park Authority [2022] UKSC 30
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Hillside Parks Ltd sought to rely on a 1967 planning permission for 401 dwellings despite decades of development departing from the original Master Plan under separate permissions. The Supreme Court held that subsequent inconsistent development rendered the 1967 permission physically impossible to implement, and dismissed the appeal. Background The appeal concerned a 29-acre site known […]…
The Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and Families Association – Forces Help & Anor v Allgemeines Krankenhaus Viersen GmbH [2022] UKSC 29
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court considered whether the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978 has mandatory overriding effect applying to all contribution claims in England and Wales regardless of choice of law rules. The Court held it does not, meaning ordinary choice of law rules apply. German law therefore governed the contribution claim, rendering it time-barred. Background The […]…
Revenue and Customs v NHS Lothian Health Board (Scotland) [2022] UKSC 28
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
NHS Lothian pursued a historic input VAT claim of about £900,000 for laboratory services from 1974 to 1997. The Supreme Court held the First-tier Tribunal was entitled to reject the claim due to insufficient evidence substantiating the amount, reversing the Inner House’s decision that had remitted the case. Background NHS Lothian Health Board submitted a […]…
Guest and another v Guest [2022] UKSC 27
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Andrew Guest worked on his parents’ farm for over 30 years at low wages, relying on promises he would inherit a share. After a family falling-out, his parents disinherited him. The Supreme Court considered the correct principles for remedying proprietary estoppel, holding the aim is to prevent unconscionability, starting from the claimant’s expectation but subject […]…
DCM (Optical Holdings) Ltd v Revenue and Customs (Scotland) [2022] UKSC 26
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
DCM challenged HMRC’s VAT output tax assessment as time-barred and disputed HMRC’s power to reduce self-assessed VAT credit claims. The Supreme Court upheld the assessment as timely. It confirmed that HMRC could withhold a VAT credit while verifying the claim and refuse payment to the extent the credit was not due. Background DCM (Optical Holdings) […]…
BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA & Ors [2022] UKSC 25
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
BTI 2014 LLC, as assignee of AWA’s claims, sought to recover from AWA’s directors a dividend paid to the parent company Sequana SA, alleging breach of a duty to consider creditors’ interests when there was a real risk of future insolvency. The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the appeal, holding that while a common law duty […]…
R v Andrewes [2022] UKSC 24
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Mr Andrewes obtained senior positions at a hospice and two NHS trusts using fabricated qualifications and experience. He performed the roles competently for over ten years. The Supreme Court held that confiscation of all net earnings was disproportionate, but confiscating the profit from the fraud (the difference between earnings obtained and earnings he would otherwise […]…
R v Luckhurst [2022] UKSC 23
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court determined that section 41(4) of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 does not preclude exceptions to restraint orders for reasonable legal expenses in civil proceedings, even where those proceedings involve the same or similar facts as the criminal offence giving rise to the restraint order. Background Andrew Luckhurst, a former professional sportsman […]…
HA (Iraq) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2022] UKSC 22
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Three conjoined appeals concerning deportation of foreign criminals under section 117C of the 2002 Act. The Supreme Court clarified the ‘unduly harsh’ test, rejecting the Secretary of State’s ‘notional comparator’ approach, and addressed rehabilitation and offence seriousness in the ‘very compelling circumstances’ test. All three appeals by the Secretary of State were dismissed. Background These […]…
The Harpur Trust v Brazel [2022] UKSC 21
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Mrs Brazel, a part-year visiting music teacher on a permanent contract, claimed her employer underpaid holiday pay by pro-rating her entitlement. The Supreme Court held that part-year workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks’ statutory paid leave without reduction for weeks not worked, rejecting the employer’s percentage-based calculation method. Background The respondent, Mrs Brazel, was a […]…
Basfar v Wong [2022] UKSC 20
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
A migrant domestic worker alleged she was trafficked and exploited by a Saudi diplomat in the UK, working in conditions of modern slavery. The Supreme Court held (3-2) that exploiting a domestic worker for profit in circumstances of modern slavery constitutes a ‘commercial activity’ under the Vienna Convention, removing diplomatic immunity from civil claims. Background […]…
Hastings v Finsbury Orthopaedics Ltd and another [2022] UKSC 19
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Mr Hastings claimed his metal-on-metal hip prosthesis (MITCH-Accolade product) was defective under the Consumer Protection Act 1987. The Supreme Court upheld lower court findings that he failed to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the product’s safety fell below entitled expectations, as statistical evidence undermined his prima facie case. Background In 2009, the appellant, […]…
Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Ltd v Compton Beauchamp Estates Ltd [2022] UKSC 18
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court considered whether telecoms operators with equipment already installed on land are precluded from applying for new code rights under the Electronic Communications Code because they are the ‘occupier’ of the site. The Court held that an operator seeking code rights is not the ‘occupier’ for para 9 purposes merely because its equipment […]…
In the matter of H-W (Children) [2022] UKSC 17
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court allowed appeals against care orders removing three children from their mother’s care into separate foster placements. The trial judge failed to conduct the required side-by-side analysis of competing options and their proportionality, instead proceeding too directly from finding risk of sexual harm to ordering removal without evaluating less interventionist alternatives. Background The […]…
AIC Ltd v Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria [2022] UKSC 16
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court considered when a judge may reopen a judgment before the order is sealed. AIC obtained an enforcement order for a Nigerian arbitration award after FAAN failed to provide a required bank guarantee on time, but the guarantee arrived hours later. The Court partially allowed FAAN’s appeal, balancing finality against the windfall to […]…
SC (Jamaica) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2022] UKSC 15
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
SC, a Jamaican national and foreign criminal facing deportation, successfully argued his removal would breach articles 3 and 8 ECHR. The Supreme Court held that a person’s criminality cannot make otherwise unreasonable internal relocation reasonable, and reinstated the First-tier Tribunal’s decision allowing his appeal. Background SC, a Jamaican national born in 1991, came to the […]…
Competition and Markets Authority v Flynn Pharma Ltd; Competition and Markets Authority v Pfizer Inc [2022] UKSC 14
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court held there is no general principle requiring courts or tribunals to adopt a 'no order as to costs' starting point against unsuccessful public bodies. The Competition Appeal Tribunal was entitled to apply a 'costs follow the event' starting point in Competition Act appeals, having properly considered chilling effect concerns. Background The Competition […]…
R v Maughan [2022] UKSC 13
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The appellant challenged his reduced guilty plea discount, arguing the sentencing judge erred by considering his refusal to admit guilt at police interview and being caught red-handed. The Supreme Court held the sentencing practices applied were lawful, dismissed the appeal, and clarified that 'proceedings' in Article 33 excludes the police investigative stage. Background The appellant […]…
Zipvit Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (No 2) [2022] UKSC 12
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Zipvit claimed input VAT deductions for Royal Mail postal services mistakenly treated as VAT-exempt. The Supreme Court, following the Court of Justice's ruling, held no VAT was 'due or paid' under the Directive, so Zipvit had no right to deduct input VAT. Appeal dismissed. Background Zipvit Ltd, a mail-order vitamins and minerals business, used Royal […]…
R (Coughlan) v Minister for the Cabinet Office [2022] UKSC 11
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The appellant challenged Pilot Orders requiring voter identification at local elections, arguing they exceeded powers under section 10 of the Representation of the People Act 2000. The Supreme Court held that 'how voting at the elections is to take place' was broad enough to encompass voter identification requirements, and the Orders were lawful. Background The […]…
Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme Trustees Ltd [2022] UKSC 10
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
A tax-exempt pension fund trustee claimed repayment of over £8.8m in manufactured overseas dividend withholding tax credits, arguing the UK's stock lending tax regime restricted free movement of capital contrary to article 63 TFEU. The Supreme Court held there was no breach of article 63 and, alternatively, the remedy claimed was disproportionate. Background The respondent, […]…
Barclays Bank plc v Various Claimants [2020] UKSC 13
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Barclays Bank was not vicariously liable for sexual assaults allegedly committed by Dr Bates during medical examinations of prospective employees. Dr Bates was an independent contractor running his own medical practice, not in a relationship akin to employment with the Bank. The Supreme Court allowed Barclays' appeal. Background Between 1968 and approximately 1984, Dr Gordon […]…
Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v NCL Investments Ltd and another [2022] UKSC 9
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
HMRC challenged whether accounting debits arising from employee share options granted to subsidiary companies' employees could reduce trading profits for corporation tax. The Supreme Court held the debits were deductible, being properly recognised expenses under IFRS2 and generally accepted accounting practice, not disallowed by any statutory provision. Background The respondent companies, NCL Investments Ltd and […]…
Bott & Co Solicitors Ltd v Ryanair DAC [2022] UKSC 8
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
Bott & Co solicitors claimed an equitable lien over flight delay compensation payable by Ryanair to their clients. Ryanair began paying clients directly, bypassing the solicitors. The Supreme Court (3-2 majority) held the lien applied, holding that work within the solicitor’s retainer that significantly contributes to recovering a fund can give rise to the lien […]…
R (Munir) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] UKSC 32
Example case summary. Last modified: November 10, 2026
The Supreme Court considered whether the Secretary of State’s concessionary immigration policy DP5/96, granting discretion outside the immigration rules regarding families with children with long residence, constituted a ‘rule’ requiring laying before Parliament under section 3(2) of the Immigration Act 1971. The Court held it did not, dismissing both appeals. Background The appellants, Mr Rahman […]…
Tip: If you can’t find what you are looking for, try shortening your search phrase. E.g. “Salomon”