Case Summaries
The case summaries below were written by our expert writers, as a learning aid to help you with your studies. If you are looking for help with your case summary then we offer a comprehensive writing service provided by fully qualified academics in your field of study.
Case Summaries & Related Services
R (Kiarie and Byndloss) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2017] UKSC 42
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A right of appeal against deportation could mean little if the appellant had to leave before giving evidence. The question for the Supreme Court was whether Mr Kiarie and Mr Byndloss could effectively present their human-rights appeals from Kenya and Jamaica. It examined what participation would actually require, including legal advice, evidence and a workable […]…
R (A and B) v Secretary of State for Health [2017] UKSC 41
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In 2012 a girl from Northern Ireland travelled to England for an abortion that was lawful there. She and her mother had to raise the cost privately. Their case asked whether the Secretary of State for Health had a duty to make that treatment available free on the English NHS. It concerned the funding arrangements […]…
R (Coll) v Secretary of State for Justice [2017] UKSC 40
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
There were enough approved-premises places for women leaving prison. The difficulty was where those places were. With only six women’s premises across England and Wales, a woman required to live in one faced a much greater risk than a man of being sent far from home. Could a public service discriminate because of that difference […]…
The Joint Administrators of LB Holdings Intermediate 2 Limited v The Joint Administrators of Lehman Brothers International (Europe) and others [2017] UKSC 38
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When Lehman Brothers’ European trading company entered administration, few expected it to pay ordinary creditors in full. Once a surplus appeared, a different question mattered. Who was entitled to the money left over? The seven issues in the “Waterfall I” appeals concerned creditors who had agreed to be paid last, creditors owed foreign currency, and […]…
Hartley and others v King Edward VI College [2017] UKSC 39
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
How much of an annual salary can a college withhold for a day on strike? The college counted the weekdays in the year. The teachers counted all 365 days. Their dispute turned on what their annual salary bought, including work the college could not timetable. The disputed deduction The appellants were teachers at the respondent’s […]…
Suffolk Coastal District Council v Hopkins Homes Ltd and another [2017] UKSC 37
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Two councils lacked a five-year supply of housing land. Did that make every policy restricting housing out of date, including policies protecting the countryside? The Supreme Court considered that question under the 2012 National Planning Policy Framework. Its answer explains why the same housing shortage could leave a planning permission intact in one village and […]…
Poshteh v Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea [2017] UKSC 36
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When deciding whether a homeless applicant could reasonably accept a particular home, how should a reviewing officer weigh the applicant’s fears and the medical evidence? Ms Poshteh’s appeal raised that question and a second one about the right to a fair hearing under article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Ms Poshteh had […]…
Gard Marine and Energy Limited v China National Chartering Company Limited and another [2017] UKSC 35
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Two hazards threatened the Ocean Victory at the same time. Long swell made it dangerous to stay at the berth, while a northerly gale made it dangerous to leave. Whether that combination was a normal characteristic of Kashima determined who bore the loss of the ship. The Ocean Victory, a bulk carrier, grounded while trying […]…
Nuclear Decommissioning Authority v EnergySolutions EU Ltd [2017] UKSC 34
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided preliminary issues on damages for breach of the public procurement rules in the award of a contract to decommission Magnox power stations. It held that European Union law requires a breach to be sufficiently serious before damages are recoverable and that the Public Contracts Regulations 2006 implement that minimum without going […]…
Times Newspapers Ltd v Flood and related appeals (costs) [2017] UKSC 33
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Three newspaper publishers challenged orders to pay the extra costs of their opponents’ litigation funding. The question was how to protect freedom of expression when claimants had already incurred costs in reliance on a scheme approved by Parliament and the House of Lords. Times Newspapers Ltd v Flood and Miller v Associated Newspapers Ltd were […]…
Lowick Rose LLP v Swynson Ltd and another [2017] UKSC 32
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
An accountant’s negligence exposed Swynson Ltd to losses on a loan. When the borrower repaid that loan and a second advance, it used money lent by Swynson’s owner personally. The issue was whether the owner could pursue the accountants for money the company itself had now recovered. Swynson Ltd, controlled and beneficially owned by Mr […]…
McCann v The State Hospitals Board for Scotland [2017] UKSC 31
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the State Hospital's comprehensive smoking ban was an exercise of management powers, but the linked prohibition on possessing tobacco and the powers to search for and confiscate it had to be exercised under the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 and had not been. The ban interfered with […]…
Globalia Business Travel S.A.U. (formerly TravelPlan S.A.U.) of Spain v Fulton Shipping Inc of Panama [2017] UKSC 43
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
After the charterers repudiated an agreed extension of a time charter of the cruise ship New Flamenco, the owners sold her in October 2007 for US$23,765,000. By the date on which she would have been redelivered in November 2009, her value had fallen to US$7,000,000. The Supreme Court held that this difference in capital value […]…
SXH v The Crown Prosecution Service [2017] UKSC 30
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that a prosecutor’s decision to charge someone does not, of itself, fall within article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights where there is reasonable cause to believe the person guilty and the offence is compatible with article 8. SXH, a young Somali woman who claimed asylum on arrival in […]…
Isle of Wight Council v Platt [2017] UKSC 28
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A parent commits an offence under section 444(1) of the Education Act 1996 if a registered pupil of compulsory school age does not attend in accordance with the school’s rules, unless a statutory exception applies. The Supreme Court rejected the view that “regularly” means sufficiently often, so a high percentage attendance cannot excuse an unauthorised […]…
The Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v The Investment Trust Companies [2017] UKSC 29
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Investment trust companies paid VAT on investment management services that were in fact exempt under EU law. They sought restitution from HMRC of sums not recovered through their managers under the statutory scheme. The Supreme Court held that they had no claim in unjust enrichment against HMRC, and that the statutory bar on such a […]…
Essop and others v Home Office [2017] UKSC 27
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
A promotion test and a prison chaplains’ pay scale raised the same question about indirect discrimination. Did employees need to explain why a neutral rule disadvantaged their group? The Supreme Court held that the rule had to cause the disadvantage, but the employees did not have to establish why it did so. The two appeals […]…
R (Hicks and others) v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis [2017] UKSC 9
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Four people arrested in central London on the day of the royal wedding were held for a few hours to prevent an imminent breach of the peace and released without charge once that risk had passed. They said this purely preventive detention breached article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights because they were […]…
Volkswagen Financial Services (UK) Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2017] UKSC 26
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When Volkswagen Financial Services supplied cars on hire purchase, it paid VAT on general overheads that could not be tied to a particular supply. The Supreme Court did not decide whether any of that VAT was deductible against the output tax on the taxable supply of the cars, because it considered a reference to the […]…
Gordon v Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission [2017] UKSC 20
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal against the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission’s refusal to refer a 2002 rape conviction following Cadder v HM Advocate. The Commission accepted that a miscarriage of justice might have occurred because the appellant’s admission of sexual intercourse, made in a police interview without access to a solicitor, was the […]…
R (on the application of MM (Lebanon)) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2017] UKSC 10
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
These five appeals concerned the minimum income rule for a non-European Economic Area partner applying to join a British or settled partner in the UK. In 2017 the Supreme Court upheld the threshold in principle, but found defects in how the rules and guidance dealt with children’s interests and how decision-makers considered other sources of […]…
Financial Conduct Authority v Macris [2017] UKSC 19
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Following major trading losses, the Financial Conduct Authority issued notices recording failings by the bank. The notices criticised “CIO London management” without naming Mr Macris. The question was whether that description identified him for the purpose of section 393 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 and entitled him to the protections it gave […]…
AB v Her Majesty’s Advocate [2017] UKSC 25
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Scottish legislation prevented an accused person from relying on a reasonable belief about a young person’s age if the police had previously charged the accused with a relevant sexual offence. AB argued that the earlier charges against him had given him no warning that consensual sexual activity with an older child was itself an offence. […]…
In the matter of an application by Denise Brewster for Judicial Review (Northern Ireland) [2017] UKSC 8
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Lenny McMullan died two days after becoming engaged to Denise Brewster, his partner of some ten years. She was refused a survivor’s pension from his Northern Ireland local government scheme because an unmarried partner had to be nominated, and the appeal proceeded on the basis that no nomination had been made. The Supreme Court held […]…
DB v Chief Constable of Police Service of Northern Ireland [2017] UKSC 7
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In late 2012 and early 2013, weekly loyalist marches passed through Belfast’s Short Strand without notice to the Parades Commission, and the police did not stop them. The Supreme Court held that this rested on a misunderstanding of the law. Organising or taking part in an unnotified parade was a criminal offence, so the police […]…
AIG Europe Limited v Woodman and others [2017] UKSC 18
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided how far claims by investors in two failed property developments against their solicitors could be aggregated under the compulsory professional indemnity insurance terms. It held that claims arising from similar acts or omissions may be treated as one claim where the underlying transactions have a real connection and fit together. On […]…
Ilott v The Blue Cross and others [2017] UKSC 17
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
After a 26-year estrangement, Mrs Jackson left her estate of about £486,000 to charities and nothing to her adult daughter, Mrs Ilott. The Supreme Court held that a district judge had been entitled to find that the will failed to make reasonable financial provision for Mrs Ilott’s maintenance under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and […]…
Wood v Capita Insurance Services Limited [2017] UKSC 24
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court dismissed Capita’s appeal about an indemnity in a share sale agreement. It held that the sellers’ promise to cover losses from pre-completion mis-selling of insurance was triggered only by a claim against the company, a seller or a relevant person, or by a complaint registered with a regulator against one of them. […]…
In the matter of EV (A Child) (Scotland) [2017] UKSC 15
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
West Lothian Council asked for a permanence order, with authority to adopt, for EV, who had been in care since birth. The Supreme Court held that such an order can be made only if the court itself finds, from facts proved on the balance of probabilities, that living with each parent is likely to be […]…
Newbigin v S J & J Monk [2017] UKSC 14
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided that a commercial building in the course of redevelopment does not have to be valued for business rates as if it were still a usable office. On the day that mattered, the first floor of Avalon House in Sunderland had been stripped out and was incapable of beneficial occupation. The statutory […]…
IPCO (Nigeria) Limited v Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation [2017] UKSC 16
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation did not have to provide a further 100 million US dollars of security before the English courts would decide its challenge to enforcement of a Nigerian arbitration award. IPCO had sought enforcement in England since 2004, while NNPC said that the award had been obtained in […]…
Akers and others (Respondents) v Samba Financial Group (Appellant) [2017] UKSC 6
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that a trustee’s transfer of legal title to shares held on Cayman Islands trusts for a company in liquidation was not a “disposition” of the company’s property under section 127 of the Insolvency Act 1986. The company’s rights continued after the transfer unless overridden under the law of the shares’ situs, […]…
FirstGroup Plc v Paulley [2017] UKSC 4
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
When a passenger with a pushchair would not leave the wheelchair space, Doug Paulley could not board a FirstGroup bus. The Supreme Court held that simply asking her to move, and doing nothing if she refused, was not enough: where she could reasonably move elsewhere on the bus, drivers should insist and sometimes wait briefly. […]…
BPE Solicitors and another v Hughes-Holland [2017] UKSC 21
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Mr Gabriel lost the £200,000 he lent in connection with the development of a disused building. The Supreme Court held that solicitors who negligently confirmed his belief that the money would be spent on the development were not liable for that loss. The project would have failed even if the money had been spent as […]…
Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Ltd (costs) [2017] UKSC 23
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
After the Supreme Court had ordered Paragon to pay Mrs Plevin’s costs, those costs were assessed at £751,463.84, including a solicitors’ success fee and a £531,235 after-the-event insurance premium. The Court confirmed that assessment. Funding arrangements made before 1 April 2013 could still support recovery of those items when later extended for appeals in the […]…
R (on the application of Miller and another) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In January 2017 the Supreme Court held that ministers needed an Act of Parliament before they could give notice of the United Kingdom’s intention to leave the EU under article 50. The referendum had produced a political mandate to leave. The legal question was who had authority to take the step that, on the assumptions […]…
N v ACCG and others [2017] UKSC 22
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the Court of Protection may decide only between options available to a person lacking capacity and cannot require care providers or funders to supply services they are unwilling to provide. Where a clinical commissioning group and care home refused to facilitate or fund the contact arrangements sought by the parents […]…
AMT Futures Limited v Marzillier, Dr Meier & Dr Guntner Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH [2017] UKSC 13
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the English courts had no jurisdiction under article 5.3 of the Judgments Regulation to hear a London broker’s claim that a German law firm had induced clients to sue in Germany in breach of exclusive English jurisdiction clauses. The direct harm was the expenditure caused by those German proceedings, so […]…
Belhaj and another v Straw and others [2017] UKSC 3
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that claims alleging United Kingdom complicity in torture, unlawful detention and rendition by foreign states are not barred by state immunity or the foreign act of state doctrine. The proceedings brought by Mr Belhaj, Mrs Boudchar and Mr Rahmatullah against British officials and government departments may therefore continue to trial on […]…
Homes and Communities Agency v J S Bloor (Wilmslow) Ltd [2017] UKSC 12
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court restored the Upper Tribunal’s award of £746,000 for grazing land compulsorily acquired for the Kingsway Business Park, holding that the tribunal had lawfully assessed its hope value for residential development in a world without that scheme. Underlying planning policies could properly be weighed when judging the prospects of permission apart from the […]…
R (Agyarko) and R (Ikuga) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2017] UKSC 11
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
These appeals concerned whether the Secretary of State lawfully refused leave to remain to two women who had formed relationships with British citizens while living unlawfully in the United Kingdom. The Supreme Court held that the Immigration Rules’ requirement of “insurmountable obstacles” to family life continuing abroad, and guidance that leave outside the Rules requires […]…
Abd Ali Hameed Al-Waheed (Appellant) v Ministry of Defence (Respondent) [2017] UKSC 2
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
By a majority, the Supreme Court held that United Nations Security Council resolutions gave British forces in Iraq and Afghanistan power to detain people when that was necessary for imperative reasons of security, and that article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights should be read so as to allow that power. Detention solely […]…
Rahmatullah v Ministry of Defence and another [2017] UKSC 1
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that the doctrine of Crown act of state can bar foreign-law tort claims by foreign nationals for detention by British forces abroad, where the detention was an inherently governmental act done pursuant to deliberate United Kingdom policy in military operations that are themselves lawful in international law. The Ministry of Defence […]…
UKI (Kingsway) Limited v Westminster City Council [2018] UKSC 67
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
Westminster City Council handed a completion notice, addressed only to the owner, to a receptionist at a newly developed office building. She scanned it and emailed it to the owner, UKI (Kingsway) Limited. The Supreme Court held that this was valid service: the council caused the notice to be received, and an electronic copy was […]…
THE UK WITHDRAWAL FROM THE EUROPEAN UNION (LEGAL CONTINUITY) (SCOTLAND) BILL – A Reference by the Attorney General and the Advocate General for Scotland [2018] UKSC 64
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court was asked whether the Scottish Parliament could pass its own Bill to keep law operating in devolved areas after the United Kingdom left the European Union. It held that the Bill as a whole did not enter the reserved field of relations with the EU, and that the Parliament could legislate in […]…
Secretary of State for Justice v MM [2018] UKSC 60
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In 2018 the Supreme Court considered whether a restricted patient could be conditionally discharged from hospital on terms that would deprive him of liberty. The patient agreed to the proposed restrictions. The appeal turned on whether the Mental Health Act 1983, as it then stood, authorised the tribunal or the Secretary of State to impose […]…
R (Stott) v Secretary of State for Justice [2018] UKSC 59
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
In 2018 the release rules for an extended determinate sentence required Mr Stott to serve two-thirds of his custodial term before he could be considered for parole. He challenged the difference between that threshold and those for other sentences under articles 14 and 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Mr Stott’s sentence comprised […]…
Welsh Ministers v PJ [2018] UKSC 66
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that a responsible clinician cannot attach conditions to a community treatment order which in practice deprive the patient of liberty. The Mental Health Act 1983 permits conditions supporting treatment in the community, but it contains no express or necessarily implied power to authorise detention outside hospital. The Court allowed PJ’s appeal […]…
London Borough of Southwark and another v Transport for London [2018] UKSC 63
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court decided how much of a London road passes to Transport for London when it becomes the highway authority. The words transferring “the highway, in so far as it is vested in the former highway authority” carry all rights in the vertical plane held by the former authority in that capacity, and are […]…
Williams v The Trustees of Swansea University Pension & Assurance Scheme and another [2018] UKSC 65
Example case summary. Last modified: November 3, 2026
The Supreme Court held that Mr Williams was not treated unfavourably under section 15 of the Equality Act 2010 when the enhancement to his ill-health early retirement pension was calculated using his part-time salary. He was entitled to that immediate pension only because of his disabilities; without them he would have had no pension until […]…
Tip: If you can’t find what you are looking for, try shortening your search phrase. E.g. “Salomon”