Why was Article 18 introduced?
Article 18 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) was introduced to prohibit ‘any discrimination on grounds of nationality’ so that nationals of the Member States could be treated equally within the scope of the Treaties. Its predecessor was Article 7 EEC, subsequently Article 6 EC and then Article 12 EC. Article 18 is to be applied in instances where the situation is governed by EU law and no more specific rule prohibiting nationality discrimination applies.[1] For example, access to vocational training, including qualifying university courses, falls within the scope of Article 18 so that nationals of other Member States cannot be charged additional enrolment fees solely because of their nationality.[2] This can be seen in Case 293/83, Gravier[3] where additional fees for students from other Member States were prohibited by Article 7 EEC (now Article 18 TFEU). Access to vocational training fell within the Treaty’s scope in light of Article 128 EEC and the Community’s developing vocational training policy. Union citizens lawfully residing in another Member State can invoke the principle within the scope of EU law, subject to applicable Treaty and legislative conditions; the situations compared must be objectively comparable.[4] The prohibition also covers indirect nationality discrimination: an apparently neutral condition may be unlawful where it disadvantages nationals of other Member States, unless objectively justified and proportionate. Article 18’s second paragraph permits the European Parliament and Council to adopt rules prohibiting nationality discrimination through the ordinary legislative procedure.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
What was the aim of Article 18?
The aim of Article 18 was to ensure that the principle of equal treatment was being upheld so as to allow the free movement of individuals to be effectuated. This is because the free movement of workers (as provided for under Article 45) is one of the most important rights that is provided to individuals within the European Union. Thus, as Nozick wrote, in the passage quoted by Morris: ‘individuals have rights, and there are things no person or group may do to them (without violating their rights). So strong and far-reaching are these rights that they raise the question of what, if anything, the state and its officials may do.’[5] Article 18 was thereby implemented to support the right to free movement with its main function being to prohibit any discrimination on the grounds of nationality and thus afford appropriate protection to individuals.[6] In Case C-300/04 Eman and Sevinger[7] the court applied the general principle of equal treatment, which requires that ‘comparable situations must not be treated differently and that different situations must not be treated in the same way unless such treatment is objectively justified’. That case concerned different treatment of Dutch citizens depending on their place of residence, rather than discrimination between different nationalities under Article 18.
What legal changes did Article 18 make?
Article 18 does not guarantee equal treatment for all residents regardless of nationality or residence status. The applicable rules depend on the situation governed by EU law. For example, in Case 39/86 Lair[8], a grant for maintenance and training for university studies leading to a professional qualification was a social advantage under Article 7(2) of Regulation 1612/68. A former migrant worker’s entitlement depended on retaining worker status, normally through a link between the studies and previous employment, with an exception for necessary retraining following involuntary unemployment. More generally, ‘the cases must have a factor linking them with any of the situations governed by community law.’[9] Article 18 can also apply to certain bodies other than the State. In Ferlini (C-411/98), the court applied its predecessor to hospital fees set by a group of healthcare providers exercising power over individuals in a way that affected their Treaty freedoms. It relied on cases including Case 36/74, Walrave and Koch.[10] In Rudy Grzelczyk v Centre public d’aide sociale d’Ottignies-Louvain-la-Neuve[11] it was shown that the Article’s predecessor could be relied upon by the courts so as to ensure that individuals were not being discriminated against on the basis of their nationality.[12] Here, a French student lawfully resident in Belgium was refused the minimum subsistence benefit, the minimex, because he was not a Belgian national or a worker covered by Regulation 1612/68. A Belgian student in the same circumstances did not have to satisfy the worker condition. In view of this decision, it was stated in the Annual of German & European Law that: ‘where the free movement of persons is at issue, argumentation can mainly or exclusively make use of Article 18 EC for reasons of simplification.’[13] Article 18 EC in that quotation is the free-movement and residence provision now found in Article 21 TFEU; it is distinct from Article 18 TFEU. The nationality-discrimination principle also operated alongside the specific rules protecting migrant workers in Netherlands v Reed.[14] The host State could not refuse migrant workers the residence advantage for an unmarried companion which it allowed its own nationals.
Why were the Exceptions introduced?
The free movement of persons is an integral right that is provided to individuals within the EU, yet the Treaties provide narrowly defined derogations. Two important categories concern access to certain posts and restrictions on entry or residence. The first permits Member States to reserve certain public-service posts for their nationals (Article 45(4)) and to exclude activities connected with ‘the exercise of official authority’ from the freedom of establishment (Article 51).[15] The second exception allows restrictions to be placed upon the free movement of persons on the grounds of public policy, public security and public health, under the relevant Treaty provisions and Directive 2004/38/EC.[16] The first category concerns access to particular employment or activities; the second concerns restrictions on movement and residence. Neither gives Member States a general discretion to exclude non-nationals.
What was the aim of the Exceptions?
The aim of the exceptions was to ensure that the interests of Member States could be safeguarded, yet it has been said that such exceptions ‘represent a barrier to promotion of non-nationals.’[17] Nevertheless, these exceptions have been construed narrowly by the courts so as to ensure that the right to free movement is preserved, whilst also ensuring public security protection. In order to ensure that the exceptions are only being used for their intended purpose, it has been specifically expressed in Article 27(1) of the Citizens’ Rights Directive that these grounds ‘shall not be invoked to serve economic ends’.[18]
What Legal changes did the Exceptions make?
The courts have interpreted the two exceptions narrowly so that the free movement principle is not being completely undermined.[19] For example, in Case 149/79 Commission v Belgium[20] it was held by the ECJ that ‘employment in the public service’ under what is now Article 45(4) concerned posts involving the exercise of powers conferred by public law and responsibility for safeguarding the general interests of the State or other public authorities. The nature of the duties and responsibilities of each post determines whether the exception applies; employment by a public body is not enough. Furthermore, in Case 2/74 Reyners v Belgium[21] it was held by the Court that the exception now found in Article 51 was to be restricted to activities that involve a direct and specific connection with the exercise of official authority. Public security covers the ‘internal and external security of a Member State and threats to the functioning of the institutions and public services and the serious disturbance to foreign relations or peaceful co-existence of nations’[22] as identified in Case C-145/09 Tsakouridis.[23] The court also held that combating organised drug trafficking could fall within public security, subject to an individual assessment of necessity and proportionality.
Under Article 27(2) of Directive 2004/38, public policy or public security measures must be proportionate and based on personal conduct representing a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat to a fundamental interest of society. A previous conviction alone is insufficient. Article 28 provides enhanced protection against expulsion for permanent residents and, subject to its conditions, long-term residents and minors. Public health restrictions are limited by Article 29; a disease arising more than three months after arrival cannot justify expulsion.
2026 update
Article 18 TFEU remains part of EU primary law and continues to prohibit discrimination on the grounds of nationality within the scope of the EU Treaties. However, it operates mainly as a general or “gap-filling” provision, meaning it applies independently only where the situation is governed by EU law and no more specific rule prohibiting nationality discrimination applies. In practice, many cases concerning equal treatment of EU citizens are instead determined under specific provisions such as Article 45 TFEU (free movement of workers) or under secondary legislation such as the Citizens’ Rights Directive 2004/38/EC, which gives concrete effect to the principle of equal treatment for EU citizens exercising free movement rights.
Equal treatment under Article 24(1) of Directive 2004/38 depends on residence on the basis of that Directive and also extends to qualifying family members who are not EU nationals. Students and other economically inactive citizens relying on Article 7(1)(b) or (c) for residence beyond three months must meet its resource and sickness-insurance conditions. Under Article 24(2), the host State may withhold social assistance from people whose residence rests solely on the initial three-month right or the jobseeking right specified in Article 14(4)(b); separate rights of workers and their families remain relevant. Before permanent residence is acquired, it may also withhold student maintenance grants or loans, except from workers, self-employed persons, those retaining that status and their family members.[24]
For UK law, the relevance of Article 18 has changed significantly since Brexit. The general free-movement regime ended when the transition period expired on 31 December 2020, and section 4 of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, which retained directly effective EU rights, was repealed at the end of 2023. Historical cases remain subject to the applicable transitional rules.[25]
However, Article 12 of the Withdrawal Agreement expressly preserves nationality non-discrimination within Part Two’s scope for the people covered by Article 10, in their host State and State of work, subject to the Agreement’s specific provisions. These rights have effect in UK law through section 7A of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. Article 18’s principle therefore remains relevant to enforceable Withdrawal Agreement rights, as well as to EU law and historical UK cases.[26]
Last updated: 11 November 2026
Bibliography
Textbooks
Alina Kaczorowska. European Union Law (Routledge, 2013)
Catherine Barnard. EU Employment Law (OUP Oxford, 2012)
Court of Justice of the European Union. The Court of Justice and the Construction of Europe: Analyses and Perspectives on Sixty Years of Case Law (Springer Science & Business Media, 2012)
Friedl Weiss and Clemens Kaupa. European Union Internal Market Law (Cambridge University Press, 2014)
Richard Ball. The Legitimacy of the European Union Through Legal Rationality: Free Movement of Third Country Nationals (Routledge, 2013)
Russell A Miller and Peer Zumbansen (eds). Annual of German & European Law (Berghahn Books, 2006)
Journal Articles
Christopher W Morris. ‘Natural Rights and Political Legitimacy’ (2005) 22(1) Social Philosophy and Policy 314, Printed in the USA, accessed 25 February 2016
Hildur Hallgrimsdottir. ‘Restricting EU Free Movement: Public Security Reasoning’ (2014) Gherson accessed 25 February 2016
Miriam De Mol. ‘The Novel Approach of the CJEU on the Horizontal Direct Effect of the EU Principle of Non-Discrimination’ (2011) 18 MJ 1-2 accessed 25 February 2016
Case Law
Case 149/79 Commission v Belgium[1982] ECR 1845, paras 7 and 9
Case C-300/04 Eman and Sevinger[2006] ECR I-8055
Case 293/83, Gravier[1985] ECR 593
Case 39/86 Lair[1988] ECR 3161
Case 2/74 Reyners v Belgium [1974] ECR 631
Case C-145/09 Tsakouridis [2010] ECR I-11979
Case 36/74, Walrave and Koch [1974] ECR 01405
Case C-411/98, Ferlini [2000] ECR I-8081
Netherlands v Reed Case 59/85, [1986] ECR 1283
Rudy Grzelczyk v Centre public d’aide sociale d’Ottignies-Louvain-la-NeuveCase C-184/99 of 20 September 2001, ECR 2001, I-6193
Legislation
Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union
[1] Friedl Weiss and Clemens Kaupa. European Union Internal Market Law (Cambridge University Press, 2014) 98
[2] Ibid
[3] [1985] ECR 593
[4] Friedl Weiss and Clemens Kaupa. European Union Internal Market Law (Cambridge University Press, 2014) 98
[5]Christopher W Morris. ‘Natural Rights and Political Legitimacy’ (2005) 22(1) Social Philosophy and Policy 314, Printed in the USA, accessed 25 February 2016
[6] Richard Ball. The Legitimacy of the European Union Through Legal Rationality: Free Movement of Third Country Nationals (Routledge, 2013) 238
[7] [2006] ECR I-8055
[8] [1988] ECR 3161
[9] Court of Justice of the European Union. The Court of Justice and the Construction of Europe: Analyses and Perspectives on Sixty Years of Case Law (Springer Science & Business Media, 2012) 436
[10] Walrave and Koch (36/74) [1974] ECR 01405; Ferlini (C-411/98) [2000] ECR I-8081, paras 39–62
[11] Case C-184/99 of 20 September 2001, ECR 2001, I-6193
[12] Miriam De Mol. ‘The Novel Approach of the CJEU on the Horizontal Direct Effect of the EU Principle of Non-Discrimination’ (2011) 18 MJ 1-2 accessed 25 February 2016
[13] Russell A Miller and Peer Zumbansen (eds). Annual of German & European Law (Berghahn Books, 2006) 305
[14] Case 59/85, [1986] ECR 1283
[15] Alina Kaczorowska. European Union Law (Routledge, 2013) 740
[16] Ibid
[17] Catherine Barnard. EU Employment Law (OUP Oxford, 2012) 180
[18] Hildur Hallgrimsdottir. ‘Restricting EU Free Movement: Public Security Reasoning’ (2014) Gherson accessed 25 February 2016
[19] Alina Kaczorowska. European Union Law (Routledge, 2013) 740
[20] [1982] ECR 1845, paras 7 and 9
[21] [1974] ECR 631
[22] Alina Kaczorowska. European Union Law (Routledge, 2013) 746
[23] [2010] ECR I-11979
[24] Directive 2004/38/EC, Articles 7, 24 and 27–29.
[25] Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023, section 2.
[26] EU–UK Withdrawal Agreement, Articles 10 and 12; European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, section 7A.