Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1997] UKHL 46
Report citations: [1998] AC 232; [1997] 4 All ER 771; [1997] 3 WLR 1151. Court: House of Lords. Decision: 13 November 1997.
The House of Lords unanimously dismissed a medical-negligence appeal. Although the failure to attend the patient was an admitted breach of duty, the claimant had not proved that it caused his injury. The judgment also explained why a body of medical opinion must have a defensible logical basis to satisfy the Bolam standard.
Facts
Two-year-old Patrick Bolitho was readmitted to St Bartholomew’s Hospital with breathing difficulties after an earlier admission for croup. On 17 January 1984 he experienced two episodes of severe respiratory distress but recovered quickly and appeared active between them.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
A senior nurse twice contacted Dr Horn, the senior paediatric registrar, asking her to attend. Neither Dr Horn nor Dr Rodger, the senior house officer whom Dr Horn said she had asked to attend, came to examine him. Dr Rodger’s evidence was that the batteries in her bleep were flat and she had not received the message.
Patrick then suffered a complete respiratory obstruction and cardiac arrest. He was resuscitated but sustained severe brain damage. He later died, and his mother continued the proceedings as administratrix of his estate.
What remained in dispute?
The health authority accepted that Dr Horn had breached her duty by failing to attend or arrange a suitable deputy. It was also accepted that intubation before the final collapse would have prevented the cardiac arrest. Intubation would have secured an airway through a tube.
The remaining question was whether proper attendance would have resulted in intubation. The trial judge accepted Dr Horn’s evidence that she would not have intubated. He also accepted expert evidence that a decision not to intubate could meet a proper professional standard. He therefore found that causation had not been proved. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision by a majority.
Causation: what would and should have happened
Lord Browne-Wilkinson distinguished two questions. First, what would the doctor actually have done had she attended? That was a factual question, answered from the evidence. The Bolam test did not determine it.
Second, if she would not have intubated, would that decision itself have been negligent? The professional standard was relevant to that question. A defendant could not defeat causation by saying that attendance would have made no difference because another negligent failure would then have followed.
The claimant could therefore establish causation by showing either that the doctor would have intubated or that proper care required her to do so. On the findings made, neither route succeeded.
The logical basis of medical opinion
Under Bolam, a practice accepted by a responsible body of appropriately skilled professionals could satisfy the required standard even where other professionals disagreed. But the court was not obliged to accept an opinion simply because distinguished experts honestly held it.
The experts had to be able to demonstrate a logical basis for their view. Where treatment involved competing risks and benefits, their assessment had to address that comparison and reach a defensible conclusion. In the exceptional case where the opinion could not withstand logical analysis, the court could reject it as unreasonable or irresponsible.
This did not permit judges simply to choose whichever of two defensible medical views they preferred. Lord Browne-Wilkinson stressed that rejecting competent expert opinion on this basis would be rare.
Application and outcome
The defence expert, Dr Dinwiddie, considered that Patrick’s rapid recovery between episodes did not indicate a progressive respiratory collapse. In his view, the risk of complete failure was small. Intubation itself was an invasive procedure requiring anaesthesia and ventilation, with risks of its own.
The House held that weighing those risks as Dr Dinwiddie had done was logically defensible. The trial judge was entitled to accept that opinion. The appeal was dismissed: the admitted failure to attend remained a breach, but its causal connection to the injury had not been established.
Source: Original House of Lords judgment.