R (Sandiford) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2014] UKSC 44; [2014] 1 WLR 2697; [2014] 4 All ER 843; [2014] WLR(D) 315
Judgment handed down: 16 July 2014
At the time of the appeal, Mrs Sandiford, a British national aged 57, was imprisoned in Bali, Indonesia, awaiting execution by firing squad following her conviction for drug offences. Mrs Sandiford was arrested in May 2012 and admitted to the offences she was accused of. Mrs Sandiford struggled to cover the legal costs for her appeal to the High Court of Indonesia. The consulate put her in touch with an experienced local lawyer, who agreed to assist Mrs Sandiford on an expenses-only basis. However, the Foreign and Commonwealth Office refused to make any financial contribution to her legal costs. They relied on their published policy, under which the government was willing to provide consular support and assistance in finding suitable legal representation, but would not pay their fees. They sought to rely on their rigid policy, as stated in its publication Support for British Nationals Abroad: A guide (first published in June 2007) stating:
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
“Although we cannot give legal advice, start legal proceedings, or investigate a crime, we can offer basic information about the local legal system, including whether a legal aid scheme is available. We can give you a list of local interpreters and local lawyers if you want, although we cannot pay for either.”
The issue that was raised in this Supreme Court appeal case is regarding the blanket policy of refusing to fund legal representation in such cases. Mrs Sandiford began judicial review proceedings to challenge the legality of the policy under the European Convention on Human Rights and domestic law. This claim was rejected by the Divisional Court in January 2013 and her appeal to the Court of Appeal was dismissed in May 2013.
In the meantime, donations funded legal representation for Mrs Sandiford’s unsuccessful appeal to the Indonesian High Court and her subsequent unsuccessful appeal to the Indonesian Supreme Court. Her UK appeal challenged the January 2013 refusal to fund representation in Indonesia; it did not ask the UK Supreme Court to overturn her conviction or sentence.
The Supreme Court unanimously decided in this case that the appeal should be dismissed. The court stated that Mrs Sandiford is not within the jurisdiction of the UK for the purposes of article 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Such jurisdiction is territorial with only limited recognised exceptions. One such exception is in relation to the acts of diplomatic and consular agents which may amount to an exercise of jurisdiction when the agents exert authority and control over others. The courts concluded that it was not possible to identify any relevant acts of diplomatic or consular agents or any relevant exercise of authority or control by such agents over Mrs Sandiford which could bring such exception into play. The court explained that refusal to instruct or fund legal representation on behalf of Mrs Sandiford cannot constitute an exercise of authority or control over her.
The court further stated that the existence of a prerogative power did not itself require a policy for its exercise to allow exceptions, unlike the rule against fettering a statutory discretion. This did not make the policy immune from review for irrationality or breach of other judicial review principles.
The challenge failed because the department had considered whether to change the policy in light of Mrs Sandiford’s circumstances, and its reasons for refusing an exception were not irrational as matters stood in January 2013. The later donations had secured competent representation; the apparent failure of the Indonesian court to take notice of it could not be attributed to the Secretary of State.
The Supreme Court nevertheless called for an urgent review in light of the subsequent developments, including the Indonesian courts’ treatment of her case and her lawyer’s serious illness, which deprived her of his assistance. It did not prescribe the outcome of that review. The appeal was dismissed without prejudice to it.
Full judgment found here: https://supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_2013_0170_judgment_1ad9ac9fb6.pdf
Press summary found here: https://supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_2013_0170_press_summary_5f2edcd97b.pdf