1. APPROPRIATION
Lawrence v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [1972] AC 626
Mr Occhi, an Italian visitor who spoke little English, offered a taxi driver £1 for a journey from Victoria Station to Ladbroke Grove. The driver took a further £6 from his open wallet before driving him there. The lawful fare was about 10 shillings and sixpence. The driver was convicted of stealing the additional £6 and argued that the passenger had consented to its being taken.
The House of Lords unanimously dismissed the appeal. Viscount Dilhorne considered that informed agreement to pay so much more than the lawful fare had not been established. More fundamentally, the Theft Act 1968 did not require the prosecution to prove a taking without the owner’s consent: appropriation could occur even with permission. A belief that the owner had agreed with full knowledge of the circumstances was relevant to dishonesty, rather than to whether appropriation had occurred.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Theft and obtaining property by deception under section 15 were not mutually exclusive. The possibility of a deception charge did not invalidate the theft conviction.
R v Morris; Anderton v Burnside [1984] AC 320
Both defendants switched supermarket price labels to make goods appear cheaper. Morris paid the lower prices before being arrested. Burnside was stopped at the checkout before paying. Both were convicted of theft, and the House of Lords dismissed their appeals.
Lord Roskill held that appropriation did not require the assumption of every right of an owner. Assuming any one of those rights could suffice. Removing and relabelling the goods interfered with the supermarket’s right to have them sold and paid for at their correct prices. The order in which the goods were moved and their labels switched did not matter.
He described appropriation as adverse interference with, or usurpation of, an owner’s rights. On these facts, theft was complete before a successful purchase at the lower price. In Morris’s case the earlier theft and later obtaining by deception were separate offences, rather than alternative descriptions of the same act.
Read the Morris and Burnside judgment.
2. PROPERTY
Oxford v Moss [1979] Crim LR 119
A student borrowed an advance copy of an examination paper, copied the questions and then returned the paper. The Divisional Court held that he was not guilty of theft on the basis that information could not be stolen. Clearly the paper on which the exam questions were typed was property belonging to Liverpool University, but there was no evidence that the defendant intended to permanently deprive the University of it.
3. BELONGING TO ANOTHER
R v Turner (No 2) [1971] 1 WLR 901
The defendant removed his car from outside the garage at which it had been repaired, intending to avoid having to pay for the repair. The Court of Appeal held that the car could be regarded as ‘property belonging to another’ as against the owner, since it was in the possession and control of the repairer.
Williams v Phillips (1957) 41 Cr App R 5
A householder put refuse out for collection by the local authority refuse workers. It was held by the Divisional Court that such refuse remained property belonging to the householder until collected, whereupon property passed to the local authority. Hence, refuse workers helping themselves to such property could be convicted of theft, on the basis that the property never became ownerless.
R v Woodman [1974] QB 754
English China Clays sold scrap metal at its disused factory to another company, which removed most of it but left material that was uneconomic to collect. Woodman later entered the site and took some of the remaining scrap. The site owner had erected a barbed-wire fence and displayed notices excluding trespassers, although its representative did not know that scrap remained.
The Court of Appeal dismissed Woodman’s appeal against his theft conviction. Under section 5(1), property could belong to a person through possession or control even without ownership. There was ample evidence for the jury to find that English China Clays controlled the scrap. In an ordinary case, control of a site and exclusion of others were prima facie evidence of control over articles on it; knowledge of each individual article was unnecessary. The court did not treat that inference as an absolute rule covering every possible item brought onto land.
R v (Adrian) Small [1987] Crim LR 778
The defendant was charged with theft of a car. He claimed that he thought that it had been abandoned by the owner because it had been left for over a week with the keys in it. The Court of Appeal ruled that he could not be guilty of theft if he had an honest belief to that effect, as if the car had been abandoned, the owner would not be ‘deprived’ of it.
R v Hall [1973] QB 126
Hall operated a travel agency and received payments for flights to America. The flights covered by seven theft counts did not take place and the customers received no refunds. Hall said that the payments had gone into the firm’s general trading account and had been spent on its business. He was convicted of theft.
The Court of Appeal allowed his appeal and quashed the convictions. Section 5(3) applied where a recipient was obliged to retain and deal with particular property or its proceeds in a particular way. A contractual obligation to arrange travel did not, on these facts, establish that additional obligation concerning the customers’ payments.
Edmund-Davies LJ stressed that each case depended on its facts: a special arrangement could impose the necessary obligation on a travel agent. Payment into a general bank account was not itself decisive either way. The decision therefore did not give travel agents a general exemption from theft liability or make mixing funds sufficient to defeat section 5(3).
R v Brewster (1979) 69 Cr App R 375
It was held that an insurance broker could be guilty of theft of insurance premiums collected by him for which he had to account to the insurance company.
A determining factor was that the contract between the defendant and the insurance company stated that at all times the premiums were to be the property of the company.
Davidge v Bunnett [1984] Crim LR 297
The defendant shared a flat with several other people who gave her cheques on the understanding that a communal gas bill would be paid with the proceeds. In fact, the defendant spent the proceeds on Christmas presents and left the flat without giving notice. The Divisional Court held that the defendant was under a legal obligation to use the proceeds of the cheques in a particular way (for the discharge of the gas bill) and therefore they were property belonging to another by virtue of s5(3). This was therefore theft.
R v Wain [1995] 2 Cr App Rep 660
The defendant, by organising events, raised money for a company which distributed money among charities. He paid what he had raised into a special bank account and thereafter, with the consent of the company, into his own bank account. He then dishonestly dissipated the credit in his account. The Court of Appeal held that he thereby appropriated property belonging to another because the jury were entitled to find that he was a trustee of the money collected and had therefore received it subject to an obligation to retain its proceeds (the successive bank accounts) and deal with them in a particular way (to hand them over to the company).
A-G’ Reference (No 1 of 1983) [1985] QB 182
The defendant, a policewoman, was overpaid. The money was credited to her bank account as a result of an error by her employer. The evidence suggested that having discovered the overpayment, the defendant simply allowed the money to remain in the account. She was charged with theft of the sum overpaid but the trial judge directed the jury to acquit. The question of whether a charge of theft was possible in such a situation was referred to the Court of Appeal.
It was decided that provided there was sufficient evidence of mens rea, a charge of theft could succeed in such a situation. The defendant had got property (the excess payment) by another’s mistake and was under an obligation to restore the debt (a chose in action) to her employer. Further, Lord Lane CJ suggested that s5(4) only started to operate from the moment the defendant became aware of the overpayment.
R v Shadrokh-Cigari [1988] Crim LR 465
The defendant, who was the guardian of a child to whose bank account approximately £ 286,000 had been credited in error instead of £ 286, persuaded the child to sign authorities instructing the bank to issue drafts credited to him. The defendant spent most of the excess money before he was discovered, and was convicted of theft of the drafts on the basis that they remained property belonging to another, namely the issuing bank.
The Court of Appeal expressed the view that the conviction for theft was sustainable on two grounds: (1) under s5(1) as the bank still had an equitable interest in the drafts; therefore the drafts could still be regarded as property belonging to another; and (2) under s5(4) as the defendant had obtained the drafts as a result of the bank’s mistake, and was under an obligation to restore the property or its proceeds.
R v Stalham [1993] Crim LR 310
The defendant was notified that he would be receiving a pay rise of £4,080, payment to be in instalments. A transfer of the total sum was made to the defendant in error, and he was told that a stop would be put on the transfer, and a cheque for the first instalment issued. The cheque was issued, but a stop was not put on the transfer. When queried by a wages clerk, the defendant expressed the view that he believed it to be a tax rebate. The defendant signed a blank cheque which, with his brother’s involvement, was subsequently made out to a woman who paid it into her account and gave the proceeds of the cheque to the defendant’s brother. On a charge of theft, the defendant had contended that the money had not been property belonging to another. He was convicted and appealed.
The appeal was dismissed. The Court of Appeal held that it was bound to apply its previous decision in A-G’s Reference (No 1 of 1983). As in that case, the property (the chose in action represented by the right to draw on the account) had been transferred as the result of a mistake by the employer. The result was that it remained, as against the employee, property belonging to another, because there was a legal obligation to make restoration, thus the provisions of s5(4) could apply.
THE MENS REA OF THEFT
1. DISHONESTY
Section 2: beliefs relevant to dishonesty
Section 2(1)(a) excluded dishonesty where a person appropriated property believing that they had a legal right to deprive the other person of it, on their own behalf or a third person’s behalf. Section 2(1)(b) concerned a belief that the owner would consent if aware of the appropriation and its circumstances.
Section 2(1)(c) concerned a belief that the person to whom the property belonged could not be discovered by taking reasonable steps. It was not enough merely to describe the property as lost. The provision excluded property received as trustee or personal representative.
Under section 2(2), willingness to pay for property did not by itself prevent an appropriation from being dishonest.
Theft Act 1968, section 2 as enacted.
R v Ghosh [1982] QB 1053
Ghosh, a surgeon working as a locum consultant, was convicted on four deception-related counts involving claims for surgical fees. His defence was that there had been no deception and that the payments were fees legitimately due to him. He appealed on the ground that the jury had been misdirected about dishonesty.
In its 1982 decision, the Court of Appeal set out a two-stage approach. The jury first had to decide whether the conduct was dishonest by the ordinary standards of reasonable and honest people. If it was, the jury then had to consider whether the defendant himself must have realised that it was dishonest by those standards. A defendant’s belief that the conduct was morally justified did not suffice if he knew that ordinary people would regard it as dishonest.
The court nevertheless dismissed Ghosh’s appeal. Once the jury had rejected his factual explanations, a finding of dishonesty was inevitable under either test. Any misdirection therefore did not require the convictions to be overturned.
2. INTENTION TO PERMANENTLY DEPRIVE
R v Warner (1970) 55 Cr App R 93
The defendant took a tool-box to annoy the owner but panicked and hid it when the police were called. He claimed that he intended to replace it as soon as he could do so undetected, but the judge directed the jury that an intention to keep property indefinitely could amount to theft. The Court of Appeal quashed the conviction.
R v Velumyl [1989] Crim LR 299
The defendant had taken money from his employer’s safe and claimed that he intended to pay it back after the weekend. The Court of Appeal held that he had not intended to return the exact coins and notes, and that therefore he was properly convicted of theft.
Section 6: treating property as one’s own to dispose of
Section 6(1) addressed cases where the defendant did not mean the owner permanently to lose the thing itself, but intended to treat it as their own to dispose of regardless of the owner’s rights. Borrowing or lending could fall within this provision only where its duration and circumstances made it equivalent to an outright taking or disposal.
Theft Act 1968, section 6 as enacted.
R v Lavender [1994] Crim LR 297
The defendant removed doors from one council property undergoing repairs and used them to replace damaged doors at another council property. It was held that this was a “disposal” under s6(1) because the defendant intended to treat the doors as his own, regardless of the council’s rights.