Freehold and Restrictive Covenants Lecture

Last updated: 3 November 2026

This chapter will focus on covenants. With leasehold covenants, a covenant regulates the use of land in some way. Freehold covenants may be positive or restrictive. A positive covenant imposes an obligation on an owner of the land to do something, or take some ‘positive’ action, for example, having to make sure the grass on the front garden is kept short. A restrictive covenant prohibits the owner of land from doing something, for example, not being able to keep certain animals on the land. A freehold covenant is usually set out in the transfer deed. An express equitable restriction can be created in writing signed by the person imposing it (Law of Property Act 1925, s.53(1)(a)). A basic way of understanding a covenant is that it is a contract between landowners to do or not to do something on the land.

This area of law would appear to be fairly simple and uncomplicated. However, as we know, land is bought and sold frequently, this raises questions as to whether the new owners of the land are bound by the promises made by the previous owners. There are four key distinctions to consider when attempting to determine whether a covenant is binding on a new owner of land:

  1. The ‘running’ of the burden
  2. The ‘running’ of the benefit
  3. The rules of the common law
  4. The rules of equity

This chapter will begin by outlining the distinctions between these four areas alongside with the key cases. We will then go on to consider the importance of registering such covenants on the land register. Next, more specific rules of freehold and restrictive covenants will be explored, such as how exactly a successor in land can enforce covenants and actions of landowners which may affect covenants. Finally, potential reform for this area of law will be explored, as some of the rules and principles can be considered unfair and outdated.

The burden of a covenant

The ‘burden’ of a covenant refers to the land which has the obligation to do, or not to do in the case of restrictive covenants, something. In our first example of the covenant to keep the grass short, the owner of that land has the ‘burden’. The ‘running’ of the burden refers to whether a new owner of the land has to abide by the covenant. Here is a quick example of where the running a covenant becomes relevant:

  • Party A and Party B are next door neighbours
  • Party A enjoys keeping their front lawn pristine, but Party B’s is extremely overgrown
  • To make sure their street looks good, Party A enters into a covenant whereby Party B promises to keep the lawn cut short (this may likely be for a sum of money)
  • Party B then sells their land on to Party C
  • Does Party C have to keep their lawn cut short like Party B promised?

These terms are also important, and will be used throughout the chapter:

  • The covenantor is the landowner making the promise (the person burdened by the promise, Party B in the example)
  • The covenantee is the landowner to whom the promise is made (the person with the benefit of the promise, Party A in the example)
  • The dominant land is the land of the covenantee
  • The servient land is the land of the covenantor
  • A positive covenant is one which requires action
  • A negative covenant is one which prevents action (restrictive covenant)

The general rule at common law

The basic rule is that the burden of a covenant in relation to land does not run with the land at common law, as per Austerberry v Corporation of Oldham (1885) 29 Ch D 750. In other words, in our example, the burden of cutting the lawn does not run at common law, Party C does not have to cut the lawn short as promised by Party B. This is fairly simple, following the basic rules of privity of contract.

Case in focus: Rhone v Stephens [1994] 2 AC 310

In this case, the owner of a house entered into a covenant with the purchaser of a cottage partly underneath the roof of the main house. On the sale of the cottage, the owner of the house covenanted with the owner of the cottage that they would keep the roof in repair in order to prevent any damage to the cottage. The roof fell into disrepair, but only once the owner of the house had been changed. The question was whether the owner of the cottage may enforce the covenant of repair on the successor in title.

The House of Lords held that the covenant was positive and could therefore not be enforced against a successor simply by virtue of ownership.

Circumventing the general rule

As you can see, the positive covenant does not itself give the covenantee a claim against a successor. Here are some quick examples of ways which this may be circumvented:

  • A chain of indemnity covenants. Each successor of land will promise the previous owner that they will be liable for any breach of covenants. In our example, Party C would promise Party B that they would indemnify any damages Party B might need to pay Party A because of a breach of covenant. Although this does not create a direct obligation for Party C to cut the lawn short, it is in their best interest to do so, as if Party A sues Party B as a result, Party C must indemnify Party B (a good way of understanding this is to draw a diagram out if you are struggling! It can be complicated to read without visualising it)
  • To lease the land instead of selling it, and replicate the covenants in the tenancy agreement. Ie. Party B would rent to Party C, and one of the covenants in the lease would be to keep the lawn short.

There are a variety of other very specific ways, but these are outside the scope of this chapter and your course. Equity does not generally make the burden of a positive freehold covenant run. A buyer can give a fresh covenant directly to the person entitled to enforce it. A successor who chooses to exercise a right may also have to accept a sufficiently related burden imposed as a condition of that right, for example paying towards road maintenance in order to use the road (Halsall v Brizell [1957] Ch 169; Rhone v Stephens; Wilkinson v Kerdene Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 44).

Exam consideration: What is the purpose of equity and can you give an explanation? This will be important in any essay questions in relation to the operation of equity in land law.

The general rule at equity

The leading case of Tulk v Moxhay [1848] EWHC J34 (Ch) created a certain set of circumstances which would result in the burden of a covenant running. A restrictive covenant can bind a purchaser in equity if the requirements below are met. Priority now depends principally on the registration rules.

Case in focus: Tulk v Moxhay [1848] EWHC J34 (Ch)

In this case, Tulk owned various pieces of land in Leicester Square. He sold one piece with a covenant to not cover the land with buildings. The land was sold on multiples times. Moxhay intended to alter the garden and claimed the right to build on it, despite being aware of the covenant.

It was held that the owner could not build on the ground, with an injunction being granted. An injunction is discretionary. Damages may now also be awarded in addition to or instead of an injunction.

When using the case of Tulk v Moxhay, four requirements must be satisfied:

  1. The covenant must be negative
  2. At the date of the covenant, it must be made to benefit the dominant land
  3. The covenant must touch and concern the dominant land
  4. The covenant must be made with the intention to burden the servient land.

In registered land an ordinary restrictive covenant should be protected by a notice in the charges register of the servient title. A registered purchaser for value normally takes free of an unprotected covenant. A notice protects priority but does not prove that the covenant is valid (Land Registration Act 2002, ss.28, 29 and 32). In unregistered land, a restrictive covenant made on or after 1 January 1926 must normally be registered as a Class D(ii) land charge against the estate owner’s name before completion. Otherwise it is void against a purchaser of a legal estate for money or money’s worth, even with actual notice (Land Charges Act 1972, ss.2(5) and 4(6)). An earlier restrictive covenant is subject to the equitable doctrine of notice.

The covenant must be negative

The test is whether the owner can comply by doing nothing. An obligation to do work or spend money is positive in substance. In our previous restrictive negative covenant example of not being allowed to keep animals on the land, it is clear this would not cost anything, therefore it is negative (Haywood v Brunswick Permanent Benefit Building Society (1881) 8 QBD 403).

This is an important distinction to make because a covenant may be worded in a way which seems negative - ‘not to allow the grass to grow too long’, the ‘not to’ seems negative but it is in fact a positive obligation to cut the grass. If a covenant contains distinct positive and restrictive obligations, the restrictive obligation may be enforceable separately.

At the date of the covenant, it must be made to benefit the dominant land

Case in focus: London County Council v Mrs Allen [1914] 3 KB 642

Mr Allen agreed not to build on two plots without the council’s written consent. In return the council approved the layout of roads. The plots were to be kept available for possible road extensions. The council owned no land that could benefit from the covenant.

Mrs Allen built three houses on one plot and took title to it. The council could not enforce the covenant against her or her mortgagee, as it owned no land that benefited. Mr Allen, the original covenantor, remained personally liable.

The best way to understand this rule is by reference to the London County Council case explained above. Essentially, there must be some kind of benefit retained by the dominant land at the date of the covenant. In the above case, the council had no dominant land. Statute can give a public body enforcement rights without dominant land, for example under s.106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. A qualifying covenant expressed to fall within s.33 of the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1982 can also bind successors. In England a conservation covenant made by deed with a responsible body for the public good may impose positive or restrictive obligations binding successors under Part 7 of the Environment Act 2021. It is a local land charge.

The covenant must touch and concern the dominant land

In other words, the covenant must benefit the dominant land. There would be no use for a restrictive covenant not to make noise if the dominant land was 100 miles away. Distance is relevant, but there is no fixed limit. The question is whether the restriction is capable of benefiting the claimant’s land. In Kelly v Barrett [1924] 2 Ch 379 the covenantee’s remaining interest in the subsoil of a public road did not benefit from the restriction. The court gave distant land at Clapham as an illustration.

Case in focus: Newton Abbot Co-operative Society Ltd v Williamson and Treadgold (1952) Ch 286

In this case, Mardon retained an ironmonger’s shop and sold a cottage and two shops on the opposite side of the road. On the sale, a covenant was entered that the new owner would not sell ironmongery (Mardon’s other shop sold ironmongery). However, the dominant land for the covenant was not listed on the conveyance. Therefore, the question was whether the benefit was annexed to the retained shop although the conveyance did not identify it.

The covenant protected the ironmongery business, but the conveyance contained no description of the land to be benefited. The circumstances alone were not enough to annex the benefit to the retained shop. They could, however, identify the land for the purposes of an assignment of the benefit. The covenant protected the use of the retained premises as a shop as well as the business carried on there.

The covenant must be made with the intention to burden the servient land

There is a distinction to be had between covenants that are intended to bind only the covenantor, and those which are intended to bind the land itself and subsequent owners.

S79(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 deems a covenant relating to the covenantor’s land to be made on behalf of their successors unless a contrary intention is expressed. The section does not make the burden of a positive covenant run. This presumption may be rebutted by any express statement in the covenant that it is intended to bind only the current owner of the land. Therefore, this requirement is easily satisfied but you should still be wary of the wording of the covenant.

The operation of privity of contract in covenants - binding the original parties

It is important to know that the original covenantor normally remains contractually liable after selling the land unless the covenant limits liability or the covenantor is released. Therefore, in our original example, despite the fact that Party B have sold on their land, Party B are still liable for the covenant and Party A can seek a remedy against them if the lawn grows too long. This seems extremely unfair Party B would not be present at the property and may have little power over Party C to enforce the covenant. This follows the principles of privity of contract.

Furthermore, if Party A sold their dominant land on to Party D, Party D could enforce the promise against Party B if its benefit passed to D. Party D could not require Party C to cut the grass simply because C now owned the servient land.

S56 of the Law of Property Act 1925 deals with a different question. Someone with whom a deed purports to covenant can take the benefit even if not named as a party. A person who merely stands to gain from performance does not qualify on that ground alone (Beswick v Beswick [1968] AC 58). The wording of the conveyance matters (see Re Ecclesiastical Commissioners for England’s Conveyance [1936] Ch 430).

A covenant is not only restricted to owners or successors in land. A generic class of persons can be referred to, such as ‘the owners of all of the houses on this street’. However, the rule is that only those persons who are identifiable and in existence at the date of the covenant can claim under S56. The Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 provides a separate route.

Referring back to our example, if Party B covenanted with 10 of their neighbours to keep his lawn short, anybody who owns these properties at the time the covenant was created can enforce the covenant. They do not need to be specifically referred to, just ‘the owners of the ten neighbouring properties’ would be sufficient. However, if somebody else moved in to one of these properties later, they would not be able to enforce the covenant under S56 simply by becoming an owner later. It is important to note that the covenant may be enforceable under different ways discussed later, but not under S56 here.

Changes implemented by the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999

The 1999 Act provides a contractual right of enforcement independent of S56. The third party must be expressly identified by name, as a member of a class or by description, but need not be in existence when the contract is made.

The Act applies to contracts made on or after 11 May 2000, and to contracts made from 11 November 1999 until then if they expressly opt in (s.10). Under s.1 an identified third party may enforce a term if:

  1. The contract expressly provides that the third party may enforce it, or
  2. The term purports to confer a benefit on the third party, unless the contract shows that the parties did not intend the third party to be able to enforce it.

A successor in title who qualifies can enforce the term against the promisor. The Act does not impose the burden on a successor to the promisor.

The benefit of a covenant

If you thought determining whether or not the burden of a covenant was complicated, unfortunately, whether the benefit of a covenant runs with the land is just as complicated. As is the case with a burden of the covenant, the common law and equity have differing rules and you will need knowledge of both.

Benefit of a covenant at common Law

Similar to the burden of covenants, there are four clear requirements:

  1. The covenant must ‘touch and concern’ the land
  2. The covenantee must hold a legal estate in the land on the date of the covenant
  3. The buyer of the land must derive their title from the original covenantee
  4. The benefit must have been intended to run with the land at the date of the covenant

The covenant must ‘touch and concern’ the land

Similar to the rule on the burden of a covenant, there must be some benefit to the dominant land. The test for whether the covenant touches and concerns the land was formed in P & A Swift Investments v Combined English Stores Group [1989] AC 632:

  1. Does the covenant benefit the owner of the dominant land? The benefit to this owner ends when ownership of the land ends
  2. Is there an effect on the nature, quality, mode of use or value of the dominant land?
  3. Is the covenant expressed to be personal? Naming the original covenantee does not by itself make it personal. A covenant to pay money can touch and concern land if the other requirements are met and the payment is connected with the land.

The covenantee must hold a legal estate in the land on the date of the covenant

This requirement is fairly straightforward. Simply, the covenantee must hold a recognised legal estate in the land. This can either be through fee simple absolute in possession or a term of years absolute under S1(1) of the Law of  Property Act 1925.

The buyer of the land must derive their title from the original covenantee

This test changes dependant on whether the covenant is pre-1926 or post-1926. For pre-1926 covenants the traditional rule required the same legal estate. For covenants made on or after 1 January 1926, S78(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 extends to persons deriving title from the covenantee, including a tenant of the benefited land.

The benefit must have been intended to run with the land at the date of the covenant

Again, this requirement is different dependant on whether the covenant is pre or post 1926. For covenants created on or after 1 January 1926, S78(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 can annex the benefit to identifiable land without express words of annexation, unless the instrument shows a contrary intention. Under pre-1926 covenants, the parties must show they intended the benefit of the covenant to pass to new owners.

Following these four requirements being met, the benefit of the covenant has passed at common law, meaning the current owner can sue for breach of covenant. If any one of the requirements have not been met, the test fails and the claimant may still rely on an express assignment of the contractual benefit. A legal assignment under S136 of the Law of Property Act 1925 must be absolute, in writing signed by the assignor, with express written notice to the person liable. The benefit may also pass in equity.

Benefit of a covenant at equity

Before the benefit of a restrictive covenant can pass in equity so as to bind a successor to the covenantor, the covenant must ‘touch and concern’ the land. You can refer to the test discussed above from P & A Swift Investments v Combined English Stores Group if you need a recap on what that means. The benefit may then pass in one of three ways:

  1. Annexation
  2. Assignment
  3. A building scheme

Annexation

Annexation is where the benefit of a restrictive covenant is clearly applicable to a defined area of land in such a way that the benefit of the covenant will pass on any transfer of the land. This can be a confusing principle and case law has attempted to clarify it. Federated Homes Ltd v Mill Lodge Properties Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 594 established the effect of statutory annexation under S78. Express or implied annexation remains possible for covenants entered into before 1926. To further understand this rule, the different types of annexation will be considered.

Express annexation

In express annexation, the document conferring the covenant will be drafted in such a way that it is clear that the covenant is made the benefit the land and not the covenantee. The covenantee may be mentioned in the document, but as long as the drafting is clearly focussed on the actual land, it will be considered express annexation.

For example - ‘This covenant is entered to with Party A and his successors in title for the benefit of the land edged blue on the attached plan’. Despite mentioning the name of the party, it is clear there is an express intention for the covenant to run with the land.

Exam consideration: Would the wording ‘This covenant is entered into for the benefit of John Smith’ be an express annexation to the land?

Case in focus: Renals v Cowlishaw (1879) 11 Ch D 866

In this case, the wording of the conveyance was that the covenant was for the benefit of the vendors, their heirs, executors, administrators and assigns.

It was held that the phrase did not identify any dominant land, therefore it could not be considered an express annexation.

Case in focus: Rogers v Hosegood [1900] 2 Ch 388

In this case, the covenant stated it was made for the benefit of the vendors, their heirs and assigns and others claiming under them in respect of their lands ‘adjoining or near to the said premises’.

It was held that the phrase ‘all or any of their lands adjoining or near to the said premises’ was sufficient in identifying a dominant land, therefore there was a valid annexation.

The above cases show two covenants with very similar wording, but highlight the importance of identifying a dominant land.

Annexation of large pieces of land

When annexing a large piece of land, you wish to place a covenant over, you can either choose to annex the covenant to only the whole of the dominant land, or to annex the covenant to each and every part of the dominant land. There are a number of differences between the two.

Disadvantages of annexing to the whole of the dominant land

The case of Re Ballard’s Conveyance [1937] Ch 473 highlights the disadvantage very well. In situations where the servient land is small and the dominant land is large in comparison, there may be an issue in proving that every part of the dominant land benefits from the covenant. Imagine a scenario where the dominant land was 1000 acres and the servient land was a small patch in one corner of the 1000 acres. How can you argue that there is a benefit for the opposite corner of the dominant land?

In Re Ballard’s Conveyance, the court held that a 16-acre servient land did not benefit the whole of the 1700 acre dominant land, meaning the annexation had failed. However, if the covenant had been drafted for the benefit of each and every part of the dominant land, there would be a valid annexation to any part of the dominant land that benefits from the covenant. The benefit would then be able to be passed on to any purchasers of smaller parts of the land.

A covenant over a small plot may still protect a large estate. For example, in the case of Wrotham Park Estate v Parkside Homes [1974] 1 WLR 798. In this case, there was conflicting expert evidence as to whether or not the covenant benefitted the whole of the dominant land. Brightman J gave weight to the parties’ own assessment and found that the covenant was capable of benefiting the estate. Whether a particular restriction can benefit the land is a question of fact.

Subdivision of dominant land

Where a covenant was annexed to the dominant land as a whole only, a buyer of a subdivided part cannot rely on that annexation alone. This was confirmed in the case of Russell v Archdale [1964] Ch 38, where the court held that an annexation to the whole of the land would not extend to any subdivided and sold land. However, if the covenant is an annexation to each and every part of the land, the covenant will be enforceable.

Therefore, consider whether the annexation is to the whole or each and every part of the dominant land. If it is to the whole, and the land is subdivided, the buyers of the divided parts cannot rely on annexation alone. However, the original covenantee retains any personal right to enforce the covenant against the original covenantor. Enforcement against a successor requires land still benefiting from the restriction.

Disadvantages of annexing to each and every part of the dominant land

After we have discussed the disadvantages of annexing as a whole, it would seem that the obvious choice would be to annex to each and every part. However, as you can imagine, the number of dominant owners could end up being extremely large, which may create problems in itself.

Imagine a situation in which the servient land is subject to a covenant to the dominant land, and the dominant land is then subdivided into smaller plots closer to the servient land. If the owner of the servient land wishes to negotiate with the owner of the dominant land to remove the covenant for a fee, they may do so. However, if they agree a fee and the covenant is lifted, the owners of the smaller plots of land on the dominant land will still be able to enforce the covenant. To obtain a release by agreement it would be necessary to negotiate with each and every owner of the parts of the dominant land with the benefit of the covenant - time consuming and a lot more expensive! This would not be an issue if the annexation was only to the whole of the dominant land.

The case of Federated Homes Ltd v Mill Lodge Properties Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 594 held that S78 normally annexes the benefit of a qualifying covenant entered into after 1925 to each part of the identified land capable of benefiting, unless a contrary intention appears. The case of Crest Nicholson v McAllister [2004] 1 WLR 2409 applied Federated Homes and held that the instrument must identify the benefited land or give a description from which it can be ascertained. External evidence can locate land described in the deed but cannot supply a missing description (Bath Rugby Ltd v Greenwood [2021] EWCA Civ 1927).

Assignment of the benefit

The rules of assignment are relevant and helpful where annexation has failed, either through a failure of valid annexation, or where the dominant land has been subdivided where the annexation was only to the whole of the dominant land.

If some kind of assignment seems to have taken place, the requirements of Miles v Easter [1933] Ch 611 need to be met:

  1. The covenant is for the benefit of some identifiable land
  2. The identifiable land must be benefitted
  3. The assignee must acquire some of the identifiable land
  4. The assignment of the restrictive covenant must be simultaneous with the conveyance of the land
The covenant is for the benefit of some identifiable land

This is satisfied if the document conveying the covenant expressly mentions the dominant land, or as per Newton Abbot Co-operative Society discussed earlier in the chapter, if evidence of the surrounding circumstances identifies land for whose benefit the covenant was taken. This concerns assignment, not annexation

The identifiable land must be benefitted

The restriction must be capable of benefiting the land in respect of which it is enforced. Where the intended benefit is for an estate as a whole, consider the benefit to that estate (Earl of Leicester v Wells-next-the-Sea [1972] 3 All ER 77). Size alone does not establish whether land is capable of benefiting.

The assignee must acquire some of the identifiable land

The assignee need not acquire the whole of the land, but some will be sufficient. This was confirmed in Stilwell v Blackman [1967] 3 All ER 514.

The assignment of the restrictive covenant must be simultaneous with the conveyance of the land

The assignment must normally accompany the transfer of the benefited land. It can be in the transfer itself or in a separate contemporaneous document. Where the benefit is not annexed, a chain of assignments may be needed. However, there are some exceptions to this requirement.

  1. Where trustees hold the benefit for the person entitled in equity, a later formal assignment may perfect that person’s existing entitlement. A mere intention to assign does not suffice - Lord Northbourne v Johnston & Son [1922] 2 Ch 309
  2. Where the owner of the dominant land dies and it devolves to the next owner, the new owner can enforce the covenants benefitted the land as if it had been expressly assigned - Leicester v Wells-next-the-sea

Building schemes

A building scheme is where land is sold or leased in lots/plots, and these pieces of land are subject to benefits and burdens of covenants which the purchasers are subject to and will be mutually enforceable between the current owners. When validly created, all properties are servient and dominant.

Returning to Party A, B and C, the positive promise to keep the grass cut short would not bind a successor under a building scheme. If their plots were subject to a scheme with a restriction against keeping animals, each owner could enforce that restriction against the others.

The requirements for a building scheme were set out in Elliston v Reacher [1908] 2 Ch 374, and a fifth was added in Reid v Bickerstaff [1909] 2 Ch 305

  1. Both parties derive title from the same seller
  2. Prior to selling, the seller set out the land for sale in lots
  3. The restrictions were to be for the benefit for all of the lots
  4. The purchasers took their lots on the common footing that the restrictions would be mutually enforceable
  5. The creator of the building scheme must have set up a scheme for a defined area of land whose limits were known to each purchaser. The scheme binds the common owner from the first sale on its terms and can bind later purchasers (Birdlip Ltd v Hunter [2016] EWCA Civ 603).

Remedies

Contractual remedies

Damages for breach of contract can be claimed against the original covenantor. A successor who has given no fresh covenant is not personally liable on the original contract (Rhone v Stephens [1994] 2 AC 310). A restrictive covenant binding a successor in equity may be enforced by a prohibitory or mandatory injunction. Under s.50 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 the court may award damages in addition to or instead of an injunction. In an appropriate case the value of a release may measure the loss (Small v Oliver & Saunders (Developments) Ltd [2006] 3 EGLR 141; Morris-Garner v One Step (Support) Ltd [2018] UKSC 20).

Avoidance of delay

If an individual is seeking an equitable remedy, delay and acquiescence may affect the relief granted. Knowingly standing by while a neighbour acts to their detriment can prevent an injunction, but delay alone does not automatically defeat all remedies. This was illustrated in Gafford v Graham(1998) 77 P&CR 73. Therefore, dominant owners should not tolerate breaches and should ensure to apply for a remedy as soon as possible.

The Law of Property Act 1925 S84(2) declaration

Often the difficult with a covenant is not determining whether it has been breached or not, but rather whether it is enforceable or not. A declaration under S84(2) will establish whether or not a covenant is binding on a person, or the person seeking to enforce it is able to enforce it. The court can determine its nature and extent. Separately, under S84(1) the Upper Tribunal may discharge or modify a restriction on use or building if it is obsolete, the beneficiaries agree, they would suffer no injury, or it impedes a reasonable use and the conditions in S84(1A) are met. For that last ground the restriction must secure no practical benefit of substantial value or advantage, or be contrary to the public interest, and money must be adequate compensation for any loss. Meeting a ground gives the Tribunal a discretion. Planning permission does not override the covenant, and a developer’s deliberate breach may count against relief (Alexander Devine Children’s Cancer Trust v Housing Solutions Ltd [2020] UKSC 45). The Tribunal may award compensation.

Exam consideration: What do you think the effect of the burdened and benefitted land coming into common ownership and occupation would be?

Reform of the law

Issues with the current law

  • The burden of a restrictive covenant does not run at law, but does in equity
  • The rules under equity are complicated
  • The benefit of a covenant runs at law and equity but under different rules
  • The rules are more complicated than the burden rules
  • The annexation and building scheme rules are technical and difficult to apply sometimes

The potential solution

‘Land obligations’ have been suggested as a new type of interest in the land. Under the proposal these obligations could be positive or negative and would be registrable. The proposed general scheme has not been enacted. This would make them more akin to easements, meaning they will pass with the property and there would be less complications when ascertaining whether they are enforceable or not. The Law Commission’s 2011 report, Making Land Work: Easements, Covenants and Profits à Prendre, Law Com No. 327, gives an in-depth explanation of this solution.

Law Teacher writing support

Writing a law essay?

We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.

Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.


To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.