Insanity, Automatism and Intoxication Lecture
This free online lecture covers the areas of Insanity, Automatism, and Intoxication within criminal law.
1.0 Introduction
Where the defendant is charged with a crime there are several ways he can go about attempting to exonerate himself of legal responsibility, reduce his liability or lessen his sentence. This can be done through arguing the facts of a case, arguing a case on a point of law, arguing mitigating circumstances or establishing a defence in his favour. In law, there exist many different types of defences and one defence may fall under a multitude of the categories.
These categories include:
- Complete defences: These defences exonerate the accused of liability for the offence to which the defence applies.
- Partial defences: These defences have the effect of reducing the charge to a lesser charge.
- General defences: These apply across a range of crimes, subject to exceptions.
- Special defences: These can only be pleaded in relation to particular crimes. For example, murder carries special defences unique to the offence.
- Excusatory defences: These excuse the accused from responsibility for the conduct and do not necessarily require an absence of mens rea.
- Justificatory defences: These defences apply where the accused’s actions were justified in the circumstances and therefore they should not be criminally culpable.
These notes focus on three different defences: Insane automatism, non-insane automatism and intoxication. Insanity can excuse a defendant who acted intentionally. Non-insane automatism concerns whether the act was voluntary. Intoxication may affect proof of the required mental element. The requirement of each defence and the effect of a successful plea of each are discussed and set out.
2.0 Automatism
As stated above, automatism concerns whether the conduct charged was voluntary and can be relevant even to strict liability offences. There are two types of automatism: Insane automatism and non-insane automatism. The distinction as to which defence applies comes from whether the cause of the defendant’s behaviour was internal or external. In order to understand this distinction, consider the two similar cases of Hennessy and Quick, both involving defendants suffering from diabetes.
Case in Focus: R v Hennessy [1989] 1 WLR 287
The defendant was an insulin dependent diabetic who did not take any insulin for several days and suffered from hyperglycaemia, or high blood sugar. In this case the Court held that the defendant’s behaviour was caused by the internal factor of the non-regulation of the blood sugar and as such the correct defence of his behaviour was insane automatism.
Case in Focus: R v Quick [1973] QB 910
The defendant was charged with assault. He had taken insulin, eaten little and consumed alcohol. The evidence suggested hypoglycaemia, or low blood sugar. Because the insulin was an external factor, the Court held that non-insane automatism should have been left to the jury.
2.1 Insane Automatism
Insane automatism is one way in which the defence of insanity can arise. The legal test is not the same as a medical diagnosis and does not require the defendant to have acted involuntarily. In the Crown Court the result of a successful plea is a finding of not guilty by reason of insanity.
2.1.1 Criteria
The criteria for the defence was established in the case of M’Naghten (1843) 8 ER 718 and is referred to as the M’Naghten rules. These set out that for a successful plea of insanity the following must be established:
- The defendant laboured under a defect of reason;
- Arising from a disease of the mind;
- So that he did not know the nature and quality of his act, OR;
- He did not know that what he was doing was wrong.
In law, everyone is presumed sane. The prosecution must prove the act or omission charged (the actus reus) beyond reasonable doubt. A defendant who raises insanity must establish it on the balance of probabilities. Section 1 of the Criminal Procedure (Insanity and Unfitness to Plead) Act 1991 requires written or oral evidence from at least two registered medical practitioners, at least one duly approved, before a jury can return the special verdict. On a murder charge, if the defendant raises diminished responsibility, the prosecution may adduce evidence of insanity under section 6 of the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964.
Case in Focus: R v M’Naghten (1843) 8 ER 718
The defendant, Daniel M'Naghten was obsessed with the Prime Minister at the time, Sir Robert Peel. M’Naghten shot and killed Edward Drummond who was the Prime Minister's Secretary. At trial it became evident that M'Naghten was suffering from insane delusions at the time of the killing and was found not guilty by reason of insanity. This led to public outcry due to the high profile nature of the crime. The verdict is reported at page 719. The House of Lords then asked the judges questions about the law of insanity. Their answers became known as the M'Naghten rules. The report summarises the answer of Tindal CJ and the other majority judges in these terms: “In all cases of this kind the jurors ought to be told that every man is presumed to be sane, and to possess a sufficient degree of reason to be responsible for his crimes, until the contrary be proved to their satisfaction: and that to establish a defence on the ground of insanity, it must be clearly proved that at the time of committing the act the party accused was labouring under such a defect of reason, from disease of the mind, as not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing, or as not to know that what he was doing was wrong.”
Examination Point
Learn these criteria and ensure that you can recite them exactly in an exam. You will need to be confident in applying them and the first step towards that is being able to fully set out the requirements of the defence. Make sure you explain that the onus is on the defendant when he raises insanity, as getting confused and stating that the onus is on the prosecution will lose you marks.
2.1.2 Defect of Reason
This is a high standard to meet as the defendant must prove that he was deprived of his power to reason. A temporary distraction or absentmindedness will not suffice.
Case in Focus: R v Clarke [1972] 1 All ER 219
The defendant having been charged with theft, admitted that she had taken the goods but only because she was absentminded at the time due to depression. She relied on lack of dishonesty. The Court held that a failure to use the power of reasoning was different from being deprived of it. The judge had wrongly treated her account as raising insanity and her theft conviction was quashed.
2.1.3 Disease of the Mind
The definition for what constitutes a disease of the mind is a legal definition confirmed in R v Sullivan [1984] AC 156, and not a medical one. Accordingly, it encompasses a number of things that doctors would be very reluctant to classify as such, for example diabetes. A disease of the mind relates to a disease affecting the mental faculties of reason, memory and understanding, and cannot arise from an external cause. This can be a difficult concept to apply but there is lots of case law to help assist in its understanding.
Case in Focus: R v Kemp (1957) 1 QB 399
A husband violently attacked his wife with a hammer and was charged with causing grievous bodily harm. At the time of the attack he suffered from a medical condition of hardening of the arteries which, on the medical evidence, could have interrupted the blood supply to the brain and caused a temporary loss of consciousness. The Court held that the hardening of the arteries was a disease of the mind within the M'Naghten Rules despite the fact it was not a degeneration of the brain. Devlin J stated that the important issue is the state of mind of the accused, not how he got there and the mind did not mean the brain instead it referred to the ordinary mental faculties of reason, memory and understanding.
Case in Focus: R v Sullivan [1984] AC 156
The defendant was prosecuted for kicking a man. At the relevant time he was suffering from epilepsy. The judged ruled that this was rightly classed as an internal factor and thus the disease of the mind and stated that the duration or temporary nature of the suspension of the mental faculties of reason, memory and understanding, particularly where it is a recurrent issue, is not relevant to the application of the M’Naghten Rules.
Case in Focus: R v Burgess [1991] 2 WLR 1206
The defendant had been sleeping over a friend’s flat when he attacked a her whilst he was sleepwalking, hitting her over the head and grabbing her throat. She screamed and he came round showing immediate horror at his actions. On the medical evidence in this case, the sleepwalking had an internal cause and qualified as a disease of the mind.
Examination Point
Learn this list and the cases as you will need to be able to cite them in the likely instance that you are confronted by one such situation in a problem scenario. Make sure you understand the distinction between a medical disease of the mind and what would constitute such disease in law for the purposes of insane automatism. Avoid seemingly becoming confused between the two by falling into the trap of focussing on psychiatric conditions and use the case law to focus your discussion on whether the issue in question impaired the defendant’s mental faculties of reasoning, memory and understanding.
2.1.4 Effect of Defect
There are two alternative elements that could be shown here for a plea to be successful. These are either or elements, although it may be possible to show both.
2.1.4.1 Nature and Quality
This relates to the defendant’s ability to recognise what he was physically doing and the physical consequences of that. For example, Lord Denning’s example of the defendant throwing a baby on the fire believing it to be a log or the oft cited example of cutting off a sleeping victim’s head as a joke to make him see it when he wakes up.
Case in Focus: R v Codere (1916) 12 Cr App R 21
The defendant was convicted of murdering a fellow soldier and appealed. Cutting a person’s throat in the belief that one is cutting bread is a hypothetical illustration of the rule. In handing down the verdict the Court confirmed that the element of the M'Naghten rules relating to a defendant’s knowledge of the nature and quality of his act was held to refer to the physical nature of the act, not its legal or moral character. The appeal was dismissed. The evidence did not show that Codere misunderstood the physical nature of what he had done.
2.1.4.2 Wrong
In R v Keal [2022] EWCA Crim 341 the Court of Appeal held that the defendant must have known neither that his act was unlawful nor that it was wrong by the standards of ordinary reasonable people. Knowledge of either is sufficient to defeat this limb. Consider the case of R v Windle [1952] 2 QB 826 for an illustration of this.
Case in Focus: R v Windle [1952] 2 QB 826
The defendant gave his suicidal wife an aspirin overdose. Medical evidence suggested that he was mentally ill. His remark to the police that he supposed he would hang for it showed that he knew the killing was legally wrong. Accordingly, the plea of insanity failed.
Case in Focus: R v Johnson [2007] EWCA Crim 1978
This case law confirmed the ruling in Windle. In this instance, the defendant who was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia stabbed his victim. Whilst he was clearly labouring under a defect of reason arising from a disease of the mind, medical evidence drawn from an assessment of the accused stated in his defence that he thought he had a moral right to do this. This was insufficient as the accused at all times knew that his actions were legally wrong. Accordingly, the defence of insanity was not available to him.
Examination Point
The requirement of legal knowledge on the part of the defendant has attracted a lot of criticism. As evidenced from the two cases discussed it operates harshly on defendants that are mentally ill and who really should be afforded the defence. The Butler Committee on Mentally Abnormal Offenders concluded in a 1975 report that knowledge of the law was a very narrow ground of exemption as even people who are severely disturbed generally possess the knowledge that murder is a crime. What do you think? Could you propose a more suitable test in relation to this arm of the M’Naghten guidelines?
2.1.5 Effect of a Successful Plea
In the Crown Court the effect of a successful plea is a special verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. Under section 5 of the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964 the court may order hospital treatment, with or without restrictions, supervision, or absolute discharge. For an offence with a sentence fixed by law, such as murder, it must make a hospital order with a restriction order if it has power to make a hospital order under the Mental Health Act 1983. In the magistrates’ court a successful defence results in an acquittal rather than the Crown Court special verdict.
2.2 Non-Insane Automatism
Somewhat confusingly this defence is also referred to as just automatism. It was defined by Lord Denning in Bratty v Attorney General for Northern Ireland [1963] AC 386 as an act which is done by the muscles without any control by the mind or an act done by a person who is not conscious of what he is doing. In lay terms, the defence applies in situations where by reason of an external cause the defendant’s mind has no control over the actions of his limbs, for example, a spasm, involuntary reflex or convulsion. The oft cited example here is the swarm of bees scenario quoted by Lord Goddard in Hill v Baxter [1958] 1 All ER 193, and proposed in Kay v Butterworth (1945) 61 TLR 452. Consider a driver is going along when a swarm of bees come through the window and start attacking the driver. If the attack deprives the driver of all voluntary control, the resulting movement is involuntary. An instinctive but controlled reaction is not enough.
The requirement that the defendant have no control over his limbs means that in cases where the defendant retains some, albeit limited control, the defence will fail. This was highlighted in the case of Broome v Perkins (1987) 85 Cr App R 321 where a diabetic suffering from a hypoglycaemic attack was charged with driving without due care and attention. He retained the ability to negotiate junctions and swerve away from vehicles and thus had some control over his body so the defence failed.
2.2.1 Effect of a Successful Plea
A successful plea of non-insane automatism results in an acquittal. The defendant must first raise evidence capable of supporting a total loss of voluntary control. Once the issue is properly raised, the prosecution must disprove the defence beyond reasonable doubt. Prior fault may prevent the defence succeeding, as discussed below.
2.2.1.1 Specific or Basic?
Up to this point in your studies you will probably understand the distinction to be that an offence with a mens rea of intention and nothing less is a specific intent crime, where as any other mens rea, such as recklessness or negligence, or even strict liability crimes are basic intent offences. Unfortunately, the distinction is not that straight forward!
Examination Point
This is an examiner’s favourite for an essay question! There is an abundance of case law existing on the matter and you will need to know the cases and explain the distinction provided between the two classes of offence in each case. It will come up again later on in relation to intoxication so unfortunately there is no short cut or way around it here and you will just have to memorise it.
In DPP v Morgan [1976] AC 182 an intention going beyond the immediate act was discussed as a feature of specific intent. DPP v Majewski [1977] AC 443 confirmed that self-induced intoxication cannot be relied on to negative the mental element of an offence of basic intent. In R v Caldwell [1982] AC 341 the House of Lords applied that rule to reckless criminal damage. Its objective test for recklessness was later overruled in R v G [2003] UKHL 50. R v Heard [2008] QB 43 classed sexual assault as a basic intent offence despite the requirement of intentional touching. There is no single test based on the word ‘intention’ alone.
Examination Point
As can be seen from the above narrative on the development of the definition, the law remains uncertain here. Thankfully for examination purposes some crimes such as murder, theft, robbery and s.18 grievous bodily harm are all non-contentiously classed as specific intent crimes. In other cases if it is not obvious you will usually be told whether the offence is a specific or basic intent crime so don’t panic too much. The marks come from recognising that there is a distinction and explaining the law accordingly as opposed to correctly identifying whether the crime is specific or basic.
2.2.1.2 Reckless Defendant
If the apparent automatism is the immediate effect of voluntary intoxication by alcohol or a dangerous drug, the intoxication rules apply (R v Coley [2013] EWCA Crim 223). In other cases, an unexpected total loss of voluntary control through an external cause may excuse the act. The only instance in which the specific/basic distinction matters is where the defendant has been reckless in becoming an automaton. Whether the defendant has been reckless is a subjective question to be determined on a case to case basis with regard to the defendant’s knowledge of the risk.
Case in Focus: R v Bailey [1983] 1 WLR 760
The defendant said that he struck the victim while hypoglycaemic after taking insulin and failing to eat enough. The Court held that self-induced automatism of this kind does not automatically bar a defence to a basic intent offence. However, where a defendant realises there is a risk of becoming aggressive, unpredictable or uncontrolled and causing injury to others, and he nevertheless takes that risk, the jury may find him reckless. Bailey’s appeal against conviction for wounding with intent was dismissed because there was insufficient evidence of automatism.
Case in Focus: R v Clarke [2009] EWCA Crim 921
The defendant was a diabetic who suffered a hypoglycaemic episode while driving. His car struck two pedestrians, killing a child. He was convicted of causing death by dangerous driving. The appeal concerned sentence. The court proceeded on the jury’s finding that he had been aware, at least briefly, of the onset of symptoms but had continued to drive.
Where the defendant takes a substance usually known to have a soporific effect, the fact that he took it voluntarily does not by itself establish recklessness.
Case in Focus: R v Hardie [1985] 1 WLR 64
The defendant set light to some furniture after taking some out of date Valium which was prescribed to his partner. He took the valium tablets in response to feeling stressed as his partner and him had had a big argument and he had been kicked out of their home. He was charged with arson. He said that he remembered nothing of starting the fire and relied on the effect of the Valium when disputing the recklessness required for the offence. The Valium was taken for the purpose of calming the nerves and the defendant was told it would do him no harm. The Court of Appeal quashed the conviction because the jury had been directed to disregard the tablets. The jury should have considered their effect and whether the defendant himself had appreciated a risk that taking them would make his behaviour aggressive or unpredictable.
2.3 Insane vs. Non-Insane Automaton
The effect of a successful plea of insane automatism is a ruling of not guilty by reason of insanity. In the past this verdict meant only one thing for the defendant and that was a hospital order, under which the defendant would be detained in a psychiatric hospital for an indefinite period of time. Considering that defendants such as Hennessy who are perfectly sane individuals suffering from a very common and non-psychiatric related medical condition would have been subjected to this order it can be seen that this was very undesirable. Accordingly, once the death penalty had been abolished most defendants historically have been reluctant to plead this defence, often choosing to take a guilty verdict for a crime in law that they were not responsible for as the incarceration was preferable than being locked up in hospital with no set release date and the stigma such a detainment would carry.
Even though hospital admission is no longer automatic, the special verdict carries a lot of stigma, even today, and can still result in incarceration in a psychiatric hospital if deemed necessary. The effect of this ruling in contrast to the not guilty verdict of non-insane automatism makes the distinction between the two defences crucial, with defendants seeking to argue wherever possible that an external factor caused their automatism, for example, the drugs not the disease. Consider the following case of R v T [1990] Crim LR 256. Here, the defendant was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder following from being raped. They had committed a robbery and stabbed the victim. The trial judge held that the rape could be an external cause of a dissociative state and left automatism to the jury. The jury convicted.
Examination Point
The ruling in T turned on the evidence of exceptional trauma. Ordinary stresses and disappointments do not by themselves provide an external cause of automatism. If such an instance were to arise in a problem question consider which defence and thus the line of argument would be preferable to the defendant. Explain why this is, as showing an understanding of the real world implications and the wider context of the defences is the kind of critique that will open you up to the higher grades.
Another opportunity for critique is to discuss the artificial distinction between internal and external factor. Consider the Hennessy and Quick cases in which both defendants were essentially suffering from the same underlying cause, i.e. their diabetes, but the immediate causes of their conditions pointed to different defences. Do you think this is an acceptable position for the law to take?
3.0 Intoxication
Intoxication may result from alcohol, dangerous drugs or other substances, including prescribed medicines. Dangerous drugs were defined in Hardie as those which are known to give rise of unpredictable or aggressive actions by their consumer.
3.1 Dangerous Drugs
The distinction concerns the known effects of the substance. A prescription does not by itself make a drug non-dangerous. The dose, any warnings and what the defendant knew about its effects can matter in deciding whether taking it was reckless.
3.2 Involuntary Intoxication
A defendant will be classed as involuntarily intoxicated where he is not aware he is consuming an intoxicant, for example, in cases of spiked drinks.
Case in Focus: R v Allen [1988] Crim LR 698
The defendant was drinking wine but unbeknown to them the wine had an unusually high alcohol content and they became heavily intoxicated. The Court held that not knowing the precise strength of the alcohol being consumed did not make the resulting intoxication involuntary.
Under Hardie, the unexpected effect of a sedative can be relevant even to a basic intent offence if the defendant was not reckless in taking it.
In these situations, the question is whether the defendant actually formed the mens rea required for the offence. It is for the prosecution to prove that he did. Where the defendant does still form the mens rea of the offence then he will be guilty regardless of any intoxication. In cases where drink or drug lowers the inhibitions of the defendant so that they act in a way which they would not sober, they nevertheless often have the mens rea of the crime. Consider for example the dreaded drunken phone call to an ex-partner. This phone call would not be made sober as despite wanting to, one is able to process thoughts and conclude that this is a dreadful idea! Exposed to alcohol however this process does not occur and the phone call is made. It can be seen the desire to make the phone call exists in both scenarios. The alcohol does not remove the desire, it just prevents the thought process that usually operates to prevent one following up on this desire. In these situations, the law will not excuse the behaviour of the defendant.
Case in Focus: R v Kingston [1994] 3 WLR 519
The defendant had a disagreement with another person whom subsequently employed an investigator to gain some damaging information on Kingston in order to blackmail him. The detective discovered that Kingston was homosexual who had paedophilic predilections. The defendant was not proud of this and did everything he could not to act on these urges. The investigator invited a young boy to his flat and gave him a soporific drug in his drink. The boy remembered nothing from the time of drinking the drink. The defendant was then invited to the flat. His case was that his drink too had been spiked. The investigator and the defendant then engaged in sexual activity with the unconscious boy with the investigator recording the events. The defendant was charged with the offence of indecent assault on the youth and sought to rely on intoxication.
The Court held that in assessing intent there is a distinction between intention at the time and a lack of memory as to what happened after the time. Involuntary intoxication where the defendant holds the requisite mens rea of the crime is no defence. The prosecution had established the defendant had the necessary mens rea for the offence and a drunken intent is still an intent.
3.3 Voluntary Intoxication
Where the defendant is voluntarily intoxicated and is charged with a specific intent offence and his intoxication means he did not form the mens rea of the offence then he will be not guilty. This is not because he has successfully pleaded the defence of intoxication but only because he has not formed the mens rea. If however, a basic intent alternative offence is available he may be convicted of it if its elements are proved, for example, murder to manslaughter.
Case in Focus: R v Lipman [1970] 1 QB 152
The defendant killed his victim whilst high on LSD. He rammed a bed sheet down her throat and suffocated her. The defendant was so intoxicated that he had no knowledge of what he was doing and thus had not formed the intention to kill or cause really serious injury required for murder. In the circumstances he was convicted of the basic intent alternative of manslaughter.
The only caveat on this principle arises in Attorney General for Northern Ireland v Gallagher [1963] AC 349 which states that where the defendant gets intoxicated in order to commit an offence, for example ‘Dutch courage’ then there will be no reduction in liability and the specific intent charge will remain as a matter of policy.
Case in Focus: Attorney General for Northern Ireland v Gallagher [1963] AC 349
The defendant wanted to murder his wife and in preparing to do so he purchased a knife as his murder weapon of choice and a bottle of whiskey to help him build up the courage to carry out his crime. There was no direct evidence of how much whisky he drank before the killing. The Court held that in cases where a sane and sober person who forms an intention to kill and knowing that this is legally wrong, then gets so intoxicated that at the point of carrying out the act they are unable to hold that intention, no defence shall be afforded with regards to the lack of mens rea and they will be charged as if the intention was indeed held at the relevant time.
If the defendant is voluntarily intoxicated and charged with a basic intent offence then the jury must decide whether the defendant would have formed the mens rea had he been sober. If the defendant would not have formed the mens rea then he is not guilty. If the defendant would have formed the mens rea then he will be guilty and there is no requirement for the prosecution to further prove that the mens rea was actually formed. The prosecution must still prove the offence. For an offence requiring recklessness, the issue is whether the defendant would have appreciated the relevant risk if sober.
3.4 Intoxicated Mistakes
Whether an intoxicated mistake can be relied on depends on the particular offence or defence. A mistaken belief in the need for self-defence attributable to voluntarily induced intoxication cannot be relied on (Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, section 76(5)). The statutory lawful excuse for criminal damage provides a different example.
Case in Focus: Jaggard v Dickinson [1981] QB 527
The defendant caused criminal damage to the victim’s house, believing that the house belonged to her friend who would have consented to the damage. Despite the drunken and unreasonable nature of the belief, s.5(2)(a), read with s.5(3) of the Criminal Damage Act 1971, meant that so long as the belief was honestly held the reasonableness of the belief was irrelevant and thus the defendant was found not guilty.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
Cite This Module
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below: